forums

DT Frederic Sainteus Commits to Miami

View as article
Advertisement
IMG_4548.gif
 
P-Tizzle said:
Good questions.

1. I have a big issue when the talent he plays against. I’m not an expert in evaluation but his competition looked uncompetitive.
Click to expand...

OK fair point…But good players can come from bad hs leagues

P-Tizzle said:
2. Kelly would not be on the two deep. That’s why he left.
Click to expand...

You are not correct… Try again. He would be #3 or at the worst #4


P-Tizzle said:
3. Skinner sucks. He has 6 rec in two years at UL and he’s a receiving TE.
Click to expand...

He's playing a lot of snaps in a pretty good offense. He's not a star, not every player you recruit is…If he ends up a 15-20 catch guy in a top 25-30 offense, that's a bust and bad eval?

P-Tizzle said:
4. Correct, no one bats a 1.000 that’s my point in saying this guy is more than likely a bust and portals out after sophomore year
Click to expand...

How can you say this when you look at the trenches on this team right now? There may be faults with CMC, staff…building trenches isn't one of them. These guys know what they're looking for, but again not everyone pans out.
 
Advertisement
P-Tizzle said:
And Skinner, Archeampong, Graves, Chance, Moss, Kelly, Harris, just to name a few.

Dude isn’t a take for us.
Click to expand...
Lmao really dude?
Some of those guys had injuries and others couldn’t gain weight. Some were knuckleheads. Every kid don’t hit. Ask Saban if they all do. You just gotta bring enough beasts to where the poodles get weeded out
 
@P-Tizzle and @Dwinstitles

After watching his highlights, which are extensive for a Dlineman, what are you seeing that makes you question his abilities? I don’t know what the verified height and weight are, and I never accept the listed numbers as accurate. But putting that aside, he seems to play very hard and strong. So assuming his height and weight are in the ball park of what is listed, what do you see that he is lacking.

I ask because I don’t think we should ever criticize, or praise, without stating our own reasons based on what we see with our own eyes. Not to say you are wrong in your criticism, but just asking for clarification to better understand it.
 
Advertisement
AtlAtty said:
@P-Tizzle and @Dwinstitles

After watching his highlights, which are extensive for a Dlineman, what are you seeing that makes you question his abilities? I don’t know what the verified height and weight are, and I never accept the listed numbers as accurate. But putting that aside, he seems to play very hard and strong. So assuming his height and weight are in the ball park of what is listed, what do you see that he is lacking.

I ask because I don’t think we should ever criticize, or praise, without stating our own reasons based on what we see with our own eyes. Not to say you are wrong in your criticism, but just asking for clarification to better understand it.
Click to expand...
I think he’s questioning (not me) the fact that he wants to see the bamas ugas of the world go after this dude. That’s what I think. I can’t speak for him but maybe he’s going by the serious offers. He has the size and may be a break out sleeper. Or he could be someone who leaves, and if that is the case PT wants higher rated guys just in case that happens and he flames out.
 
Back
Top