It's not a reach if they took the player who is higher on their board and fits their defensive scheme rather than catering to a fictional board created by fans that usually is always skewed to offensive skill players.
I understand the bolded part. But even if I agree, what about the past 20 years should have anyone trusting the fins board?
I know, I know... different people in charge. But remember, Chris Grier was an area scout for the fins in 2000-2002, our assistant director of college scouting 2003-2007, director of college scouting 2007-2015, and GM beginning 2016.
Tua at No. 5 was a necessary risk, and I am just glad they didn't get played into giving something up to move one or two spots for him.
Jackson at 18 feels like a reach at OT, not because of a "fictional board," but because his production never matched his physical tools. Ask Buffalo's 2nd round pick, Epenesa, about Jackson. When they played in the Holiday Bowl, Epenesa had 2.5 sacks (and a FF) and was named the defensive player of the game.
Igbinoghene at 30 could work because of his crazy physical traits, and I get that it is a passing league, but spending a 1st on a CB when our starting CBs are among the highest paid in the NFL feels off. At least they moved back and grabbed an extra pick, though.
Hunt is a beast that also fills a need. Great pick.
Davis has bust written all over him. Had one solid year at Baga then disappeared off the face of the Earth. Nowhere to be found against L$U.
Jones is a hyper-limited safety.
Kindley is a mauler that fits a need. Not sure if he's a plug in play guy or not, but I'm good with this pick. OL was horrible and Kindley is hard to move.
Trading a 5th for Breida was a shrewd move. The kind of move that gives me hope. Great value at this point.
Stowbridge, eh. Maybe a higher floor type. Probably more athletically talented guys around, but not a bad pick. My recollection of him is that whenever UNC plays Miami this kid blocks a ******* kick. At worst he has some special teams value.
Weaver is a hyper-productive pass rusher who would have been drafted much higher but for concerns about his athleticism. I'll always be happy with a pick like this in the 5th round. Strong pick.
Drafting a LS No. 185 is a reach. Fictional board, draft board, dream board, card board... it doesn't matter. Big reach.
Malcolm Perry. This late in the draft, why not? Solid production (albeit in a RB/QB role).
Trading a late 7th for a 6th next sure. Solid move. We can only sign so many guys anyway, might as well get some more ammo in next year's draft (where we also have an extra 1st and 2nd).