CFP Weekly Rankings - Nov 17 -Week 3

According to espn analytics, chances to make the SEC championship game:

48% — Texas

35% — Alabama

17% — Tennessee

99% — UGA
 
Every single one of Alabama’s “good” wins lost yesterday. They do not have a single win over a team that should be ranked (LSU does not count).

Can’t wait to see the committee move them up.
The Committee will automatically forfeit all the other teams and automatically schedule a UGA/Bama Natty.
 
When you really step back and look at it, this is the third year in a row Alabama should be on the outside looking in bubble for the playoffs yet they are being boosted by their branding

Texas > Tennessee > Alabama

Wake Forest > BYU > Texas Tech > Alabama > Iowa


Instead, the bubble conversation revolves around WF, BYU, TT and Iowa
 
When you really step back and look at it, this is the third year in a row Alabama should be on the outside looking in bubble for the playoffs yet they are being boosted by their branding

Texas > Tennessee > Alabama

Wake Forest > BYU > Texas Tech > Alabama > Iowa


Instead, the bubble conversation revolves around WF, BYU, TT and Iowa
You know who works for espn now lol?
 
You know who works for espn now lol?
College Football Championship GIF by ESPN




South Park D GIF
 
Tennessee is basically OU from last year….i actually believe Alabama can beat them in a rematch but again why even bother to play the games if H2H is thrown out lol

I think the committee can only run this shell game, Alabama being ranked above Tennessee, for one more week. The media / fan ire about to become vicious if Tennessee beats LSU yet is still ranked below Alabama imo
 
Now that there are only two weeks left, most of the fantastical scenarios are pretty much over
Avengers Assemble GIF by MOODMAN



There are thirteen programs who — based upon the past two years of the 12-team playoffs — could/should expect one outta eleven slots in the playoffs if they win out in the regular season alone.


SEC: UGA, Alabama, Texas, Tennessee

ACC: Miami, WF

B1G: UCLA, Indiana, Iowa

Big XII: Utah, Texas Tech, BYU

Two must be eliminated. Iowa is the easy weakest link.

One thing both the committee and the general public will agree upon is that Iowa is the weakest link. Their Minnesota loss will be their undoing. Iowa is fairly similar to 10-2 Vanderbilt last year, whereby both squads don’t have a standout victory. Moreover, both squads lost to a 9-3, potentially, team who could argue deserves a spot more than them: Ohio State. 9-3 Texas last year had a better résumé, still, you get the idea.

Now we are down to twelve teams for eleven spots; assuming everybody wins out.

The committee has done two deft sleight of hand maneuvers the last two years: 1st, put a 9-3 Alabama above a 10-2 Miami. Miami’s 2017 and 2020 seasons, along with losing two outta their last three to GT + Syracuse, plus being generally disliked, it being the 1st year of the 12-team playoffs, while Bama still had the Saban afterglow, withdrew the potential controversy pre-CCGs. Moreover, post-CCGs, it became about SMU vs Alabama.

2025: ND vs Miami as a distraction to avoid Bama vs ND vs Miami, when Miami beat FSU; a common opponent between Miami & Bama.

While this was going on, BYU went 21-3 the last two regular seasons; including giving SMU their only regular season loss in’24. Yet, no playoff appearances, as the big XII has been a 1-bid league both times. BYU is poised to go 10-2 again, and has another major OOC victory like 2024. Just like 2024, BYU is on the outside looking in of the CCG.

The obvious predicament for the corrupt committee is if they are prepared to leave BYU outta the playoffs for a third straight year? If Texas Tech beats Utah in the big XII CCG, they’ll force their hand. If they lose, i think the committee will withstand Cody Campbell’s ire and put BYU in because of their better wins.

I feel like WF, IU, Tennessee will all be in if they win out the rest of the way. Something that will help WF is that they have two common opponents with UCLA; and their margin of victory is near-identical: 36 vs 35 (Purdue & Cal Berkley). Going to be tough for IU to get a home game tho, unless they can beat UCLA in the CCG, which is why i think Cignetti made that tweet defending Lincoln Riley.

TLDR: the eleven p4 spots should be broken up into three SEC, three big XII, two ACC, and two B1G this year; but corruption will give the SEC 4 and the big XII two. If it’s chalk the rest of the regular season, we’re just awaiting whether or not BYU or TT will be the school pushed aside to make space for Alabama
 
I was just reflecting.

There NEVER used to be a 2 loss P4 team in front of a 1 loss P4 team..or a 1 loss P4 team in front of a zero loss P4 team.

They've normalized it by now. Only for the SEC..it's happened several years in a row now for them. But why?

They got 5 teams in the playoffs last year and went 0-3 against other conference P4 teams.

Anybody who says they're trying to prevent a super league isn't paying attention. It's already here because of the corruption of the CFP. There's too much subconscious unjustified bias towards for SEC.

I like the playoffs but they've given too much power to a small # of people who can't be held accountable for corruption. They can do what they want. There's ZERO doubt that lobbying and influence is happening behind closed doors. Too much $$$$ involved not to be.

Texas has some good wins (Ohio state) but some bad losses. They should not be ahead of us. Their best win is now 8-2 Tennessee (worse than our best win against WF). Their previous "good wins" are now 6-4 Ole Miss, 7-3 Ohio state (they were better before Saying got hurt), 6-4 Mizz, and 6-4 LSU. They lost to 6-4 Florida and 6-4 Oklahoma.

Bama shouldn't be ahead of us either. Their "good wins" are against 7-3 Kentucky, 6-4 South Carolina, 4-6 Miss St, 6-4 LSU.

These teams haven't "played anybody" when you ignore preseason hype and overrated preseason SEC rankings.

I'm not sure how this cycle ends but it'll just keep on leading to more overrated SEC teams getting beat in the playoffs.
 
I was just reflecting.

There NEVER used to be a 2 loss P4 team in front of a 1 loss P4 team..or a 1 loss P4 team in front of a zero loss P4 team.

They've normalized it by now. Only for the SEC..it's happened several years in a row now for them. But why?
It’s really for Alabama more than anybody else. Alabama gets the highest ratings and is the biggest CFB brand.

The p4 itself is only three years old. They did it against us the first time in 2024 when they put 3 loss Alabama over 2 loss Miami. Last year, we were the beneficiaries—along with others—as we were ahead of 11-1 then 11-2 BYU. Conference realignment weakened the big 12 entirely and the newcomers to the conference — Utah & BYU primarily — are still staking out their place in college football’s mainstream. BYU beating ND was enormous for pushback on the idea that the p4 is actually the p2; which had gained some traction as the SEC loses its prevalence on postseason success and tries to rewrite the concurring narrative.

When there are only 4 teams it’s basically impossible to put any 2 loss teams in the playoffs. Even so, they first bent the spirit of the selections — even before us — when they put 12-1 Alabama in the playoffs over 13-0 FSU.
 
Back
Top