One thing both the committee and the general public will agree upon is that Iowa is the weakest link. Their Minnesota loss will be their undoing. Iowa is fairly similar to 10-2 Vanderbilt last year, whereby both squads don’t have a standout victory. Moreover, both squads lost to a 9-3, potentially, team who could argue deserves a spot more than them: Ohio State. 9-3 Texas last year had a better résumé, still, you get the idea.
Now we are down to twelve teams for eleven spots; assuming everybody wins out.
The committee has done two deft sleight of hand maneuvers the last two years: 1st, put a 9-3 Alabama above a 10-2 Miami. Miami’s 2017 and 2020 seasons, along with losing two outta their last three to GT + Syracuse, plus being generally disliked, it being the 1st year of the 12-team playoffs, while Bama still had the Saban afterglow, withdrew the potential controversy pre-CCGs. Moreover, post-CCGs, it became about SMU vs Alabama.
2025: ND vs Miami as a distraction to avoid Bama vs ND vs Miami, when Miami beat FSU; a common opponent between Miami & Bama.
While this was going on, BYU went 21-3 the last two regular seasons; including giving SMU their only regular season loss in’24. Yet, no playoff appearances, as the big XII has been a 1-bid league both times. BYU is poised to go 10-2 again, and has another major OOC victory like 2024. Just like 2024, BYU is on the outside looking in of the CCG.