CFP Weekly Rankings - Nov 17 -Week 3

Yeup this is an improvement from the one i linked

My major change would just be i believe Alabama should be 12, or otherwise, the first team out of the playoffs. This does have them in the 10-12 rank with Tennessee and BYU; although Bama ends up tenth.

Quite odd that so many better rankings schemes still end up w/ Tennessee below Alabama; tbf, this same one has us ahead of ND.

I just believe the idea of ND getting a top 4 bye is blasphemous altogether; so I’m happy that doesn’t seem to be a possibility at this point
 
"A win at unranked Missouri on Saturday will help, but it won't carry the same weight as it did earlier in the campaign because that would be the Tigers' fifth loss." (Dinich)

Lol. Guess the teams that gave them their first four losses still get credit though.
Tennessee beating LSU, Vandy, UK and A&M are meaningless because Alabama beat them first type beat
 
SIAP.
 

Attachments

  • HXa8ypGWkAA9TGy.jpeg
    HXa8ypGWkAA9TGy.jpeg
    34.8 KB · Views: 0
Tennessee beating LSU, Vandy, UK and A&M are meaningless because Alabama beat them first type beat
Yeah. She also is trial-ballooning a subjective standard for conference championship losers:

"Last year, the committee put three-loss Alabama in the playoff even after it suffered one of the worst losses in a conference championship game in the playoff era because it didn't want to punish a team for making its league title game. In that instance, though, Alabama had a regular-season win against Georgia, the eventual SEC champs. Texas Tech didn't play BYU or Utah during this regular season. So, the committee's decision would depend on how the Big 12 title game unfolds and what else happens to the other contenders -- especially in the ACC, where Wake Forest has legitimized its playoff hopes to go along with those of Miami."

Like, she could have just said if TTU is at 12 they would be out for the same reason BYU was out when they were ranked 11 going into the Big12-CG last year, but she didn't
 
Tennessee and Alabama are so similar

Both lost to a top 5 SEC team: Texas and UGA

They share 6 common opponents, then have played each other. They each have an FCS game. They each played an ACC team. Each played an unremarkable g6 opponent.

Tennessee beat GT by a higher margin than Alabama beat FSU.

So they’re basically implicitly telling us that Alabama’s stomping of South Carolina and Tennessee’s close loss to South Carolina (a team they view so highly that they’re ranked!) is the difference-maker between the two teams—notably not their H2H.

Additionally, they are still hanging their hat on the fact that Alabama beat Mississippi state w/ Kamario Taylor — even tho he was obviously injured and shouldn’t been playing, the broadcaster literally said he walked into their preproduction meeting in a boot— as being the major separator between Alabama and Tennessee; since Tennessee only beat Arkansas on the road by 7 (Arkansas hasn’t/won’t played Alabama and Tennessee hasn’t/won’t played Miss State).

Which is ****** absurd considering how UGA’s close loss to unranked auburn means nothing; as does Auburn’s win over uga mean anything in the committee’s eyes.

It gives kudos to Alabama for beating undefeated (1-0 lmfao) kentucky but shrugs their shoulders at Tennessee for beating 7-1 Kentucky lmao. Likewise, Tennessee beating LSU + Vandy in the upcoming weeks won’t matter anymore because of their current situations; but Alabama beating those teams when they did were impressive because it was a few weeks prior.

Alabama gets to be static in positivity; everyone else is judged dynamically and negatively; except UGA + the rest of the SEC.
Id wait and see what they do with the outcome of this weekends game with LSU. Its obvious they have a perception or narrative about what Bama is but ultimately the committe will factor in the final results when comparing teams. Bamas only route to a top 4 seed is to make and win the sec title game.
I think you're being (way) too generous to the CFP committee. This is big big business, the stakes are super high, and we know who pays their paycheck.
i think the powers that be would rather get a bama home playoff game vs a bye
 
The committee dosn’t even consider Tennessee and Indiana to be in the same “pool,” as the teams above them.

They believe UGA 1, Utah 2, Bama 3, and then the next 4 are up for debate. Alabama losing to UGA again doesn’t mean anything to them
its more about Miami UCLA/Indiana/Utah winning their conferences
 
Tennessee and Alabama are so similar

Both lost to a top 5 SEC team: Texas and UGA

They share 6 common opponents, then have played each other. They each have an FCS game. They each played an ACC team. Each played an unremarkable g6 opponent.

Tennessee beat GT by a higher margin than Alabama beat FSU.

So they’re basically implicitly telling us that Alabama’s stomping of South Carolina and Tennessee’s close loss to South Carolina (a team they view so highly that they’re ranked!) is the difference-maker between the two teams—notably not their H2H.

Additionally, they are still hanging their hat on the fact that Alabama beat Mississippi state w/ Kamario Taylor — even tho he was obviously injured and shouldn’t been playing, the broadcaster literally said he walked into their preproduction meeting in a boot— as being the major separator between Alabama and Tennessee; since Tennessee only beat Arkansas on the road by 7 (Arkansas hasn’t/won’t played Alabama and Tennessee hasn’t/won’t played Miss State).

Which is ****** absurd considering how UGA’s close loss to unranked auburn means nothing; as does Auburn’s win over uga mean anything in the committee’s eyes.

It gives kudos to Alabama for beating undefeated (1-0 lmfao) kentucky but shrugs their shoulders at Tennessee for beating 7-1 Kentucky lmao. Likewise, Tennessee beating LSU + Vandy in the upcoming weeks won’t matter anymore because of their current situations; but Alabama beating those teams when they did were impressive because it was a few weeks prior.

Alabama gets to be static in positivity; everyone else is judged dynamically and negatively; except UGA + the rest of the SEC.
Id wait and see what they do with the outcome of this weekends game with LSU. Its obvious they have a perception or narrative about what Bama is but ultimately the committe will factor in the final results when comparing teams. Bamas only route to a top 4 seed is to make and win the sec title game.
 
Dawg, they have had a two-loss Alabama team above undefeated UCLA this whole process. That isn’t going to change if UCLA or IU wins out. The committee sees the top 3 as separate from the rest
It's just puzzling to give a 2 loss team, one loss being a beatdown, a bye in the playoffs. They didn't earn it. They are a great two loss team relative to others but to be ahead of UCLA, or even ND or Miami, is a joke. If they are just going of computer rankings then let the computers rank them based on AP poll, not their sorry *** SEC biased rankings. Otherwise just use the AP and call it a day. This committee is utterly useless
 
Read this gem on USA Today.

A week ago, all six of Indiana’s previously faced Big Ten opponents lost while the Hoosiers were on a bye week. Indiana then dropped from No. 4 to No. 9 in the CFP poll.

Fast forward to last weekend: five SEC teams previously beaten by Alabama lost, and the Tide — with an ugly win at Vanderbilt — stayed firm at No. 3.

“Three things happened to Indiana. One were the conference losses, and there were five games involved with Top 14 teams, so there was (poll) movement around Indiana,” Yurachek said. “And Indiana had a bye and didn’t have an opportunity to improve its resume.”

If that doesn’t make you want to ditch the selection committee system, Yurachek wasn’t done. He then said that Alabama didn’t move down, and the five opponent losses didn’t have the same impact that it did on Indiana a week prior, because — and I can’t believe I’m writing this — “the quality of strength of schedule those five teams had lost.”
 
It's just puzzling to give a 2 loss team, one loss being a beatdown, a bye in the playoffs. They didn't earn it. They are a great two loss team relative to others but to be ahead of UCLA, or even ND or Miami, is a joke. If they are just going of computer rankings then let the computers rank them based on AP poll, not their sorry *** SEC biased rankings. Otherwise just use the AP and call it a day. This committee is utterly useless
While i know Alabama is very dangerous when hitting on cylinders, they haven’t done that enough for me to buy-in to them. I don’t think they should be in the playoffs as it currently stands.

I think IU, WF, BYU, Tennessee, Texas and TT all have better résumé-seasons; I’d give the nod to Alabama over Iowa though.
 
They will cook the rankings a bit to influence the bracket and spread the sec teams around and keep Texas and bama away from Georgia imo
We’re an Indiana beating UCLA in the B1G-CCG conditional away from there being 3 SEC teams who get first round byes.
And none of them are undefeated like other teams in the field.
 
Back
Top