CFP Weekly Rankings - Nov 17 -Week 3

Remember Hanlon's Razor: “Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity”
Sure, but it would be stupid as **** to ignore this is the 5th year of pro-Bama evidence & their own stupid logic is too inconsistent to pass the smell test. A stupid committee could still be transparent & release their metrics or release segments — chosen propaganda clips — of their discussions to the public for better PR. & yet they don’t do any of that.

Okay 2017 11-1 Alabama over 12-1 Wisconsin, 10-3 Auburn, and 11-2 Ohio State can be justified because CCGs mattered for determining the 4-team playoff. I don’t care about this year.

It’s the 4 straight years—notably, when saban had more pressure on him and then the first 3 years of the post-saban era where their massive ratings held steady

2023 Alabama over 13-0 FSU — okay the logic is there but it’s still against everything they’ve done before and quite frankly was unprecedented.

Then in the 12-team playoff, it has gotten shameless; but as much as i dislike the Seminoles, their injury is greater than ours..

2024; 9-3 Alabama is over 10-2 Miami; both teams beat UF who was 8-4. We smacked UF. But “SOS,” makes their 3rd loss more acceptable somehow. Nvm UGA needed 8 overtime’s to beat GT who we lost to. Nvm that Syracuse’s quarterback was literally Ohio State’s quarterback the year prior; & led the country in passing yards. Never mind our margin of defeat was by a total of 7 points; meanwhile, Alabama lost to 6-6 OU by 21 points & 6-6 Vandy by 5 points. 10-2 Tennessee wasn’t even in the discussion despite their loss to Arkansas; since they beat Alabama.

Thankfully, SMU lost narrowly to Clemson which bumped Alabama out of the playoffs; but it was clear and obvious that they didn’t expect this to happen at all. BYU at 10-2 w/ a win over SMU wasn’t even in the discussion for the bubble teams w/ 9-3 Alabama, 9-3 South Carolina, 9-3 Ole Miss and 10-2 Miami.

2025 Alabama, with a loss to fsu, is ranked higher than Miami who beat FSU; their only common opponent. 11-2 BYU isn’t taken very seriously with their true freshman qb for the entirety of this process.

They purposefully wait to make the switch at the end because of numerous championship game conditionals, but covered their own Alabama *** — learning from the year prior — by swapping Alabama to 9th instead of 10th to ensure that they would get in the playoffs despite a loss. When in reality ND deserved Alabama’s spot. Kickstarting a year+ of making fun of ND and saying they don’t deserve a playoff spot if they lose to BYU + Miami and go 10-2 this season. Alabama looked awful against an auburn team with an interim HC.

Now, our H2H with ND holds us back while Tennessee’s H2H with Texas holds them back; but somehow, Alabama’s H2H w/ Tennessee never enters the same pod. Yet, Tennessee and Alabama have six common opponents: Auburn, Vanderbilt, Kentucky, Texas A&M, South Carolina, and LSU.

The last three national championships have come from one conference yet 8 of the 10 toughest schedules are supposedly in the SEC. It’s stupidity and corruption; but to act like there’s no corrupt bargaining is to remain blind. They have 7-3 Ohio state over 8-2 Iowa; but cannot be helped to put Tennessee over Alabama? Last week, USC was ahead of Ohio State.

When the rankings opened, 7-1 ND was behind 7-1 BYU. 6-2 ole miss was ahead of 6-2 LSU but below 6-2 Texas. They had 7-1 Kentucky behind 6-2 Alabama because bama beat Kentucky. Now Kentucky is 7-3 and Alabama remains number 3. It’s absurd and a farce
 
Last edited:
Meanwhile, 6-4 Northwestern played Oregon close with a hurt qb and lost to Iowa & Ohio State with their backups — while looking better than South Carolina ever did with their backup — yet is unranked lmaooo

Illinois is on their third quarterback and is 6-4. Syracuse is 5-5 using 4 different quarterbacks this year
I've been frustrated with rankings before, but I've never seen anything like this. Blatant favoritism towards Alabama has been a thing for decades, but this is investigation worthy.

Alabama's schedule isn't looking too hot right now, much less their ranked wins.

They should not be getting "a locked in top 25 win against Miss St." Its the most absurd thing the committee has ever said. Taylor was hurt the week BEFORE Alabama even played them, and their schedule up to that point was not top 25 worthy.

South Carolina should not be ranked. They're 6-4 and just lost by 31 points to a 4 win team.

LSU fell out of the top 25.

That leaves Kentucky, Georgia and Tennessee. Alabama lost against 2 of them.

The one they beat, Kentucky, already has 3 losses, is a 7 point underdog this week and only has a 40% chance of beating Louisville next week according to ESPN.

The **** are we doing here?!
 
Bama Tennessee is us and nd from last year. A head to head that’s being ignored
If Bama makes and loses the sec title game and the right teams win their conferences I think itll be like last year. Tennessee will leapfrog Bama once they are forced into the same pod and have virtually the same records. It may even happen after Tennessee beats LSU to make the explanation easier. Wouldnt shock me if the commuttee pushes all these sec teams up right before title games only to roll other teams in front of them once they win their conferences.

All these early rankings are posturing and designed to drive interest. I wont deny they position these SEC teams where they need to keep them in the discussion, BUT The committee has shown that they are going to do whatever they want on the final ranking. They have no problem saying previous rankings do not matter at all once the full body of work is there.

Going into the final weekend. I expect it to be

UGA
Utah
UCLA (after USC win)

Bama Texas Tennnessee ND (not sure the order)
Miami

When we win out we will move to 4 or 5 depending on if they penalize ND for not playing in a conference title game. I believe they will be penalized for it.

If Toney plays and balls in the ACCCG and we win comfortably Id bet we get the 4 seed more to make ND play that extra game than to reward us.
 
I've been frustrated with rankings before, but I've never seen anything like this. Blatant favoritism towards Alabama has been a thing for decades, but this is investigation worthy.

Alabama's schedule isn't looking too hot right now, much less their ranked wins.

They should not be getting "a locked in top 25 win against Miss St." Its the most absurd thing the committee has ever said. Taylor was hurt the week BEFORE Alabama even played them, and their schedule up to that point was not top 25 worthy.

South Carolina should not be ranked. They're 6-4 and just lost by 31 points to a 4 win team.

LSU fell out of the top 25.

That leaves Kentucky, Georgia and Tennessee. Alabama lost against 2 of them.

The one they beat, Kentucky, already has 3 losses, is a 7 point underdog this week and only has a 40% chance of beating Louisville next week according to ESPN.

The **** are we doing here?!
Tennessee and Alabama are so similar

Both lost to a top 5 SEC team: Texas and UGA

They share 6 common opponents, then have played each other. They each have an FCS game. They each played an ACC team. Each played an unremarkable g6 opponent.

Tennessee beat GT by a higher margin than Alabama beat FSU.

So they’re basically implicitly telling us that Alabama’s stomping of South Carolina and Tennessee’s close loss to South Carolina (a team they view so highly that they’re ranked!) is the difference-maker between the two teams—notably not their H2H.

Additionally, they are still hanging their hat on the fact that Alabama beat Mississippi state w/ Kamario Taylor — even tho he was obviously injured and shouldn’t been playing, the broadcaster literally said he walked into their preproduction meeting in a boot— as being the major separator between Alabama and Tennessee; since Tennessee only beat Arkansas on the road by 7 (Arkansas hasn’t/won’t played Alabama and Tennessee hasn’t/won’t played Miss State).

Which is ****** absurd considering how UGA’s close loss to unranked auburn means nothing; as does Auburn’s win over uga mean anything in the committee’s eyes.

It gives kudos to Alabama for beating undefeated (1-0 lmfao) kentucky but shrugs their shoulders at Tennessee for beating 7-1 Kentucky lmao. Likewise, Tennessee beating LSU + Vandy in the upcoming weeks won’t matter anymore because of their current situations; but Alabama beating those teams when they did were impressive because it was a few weeks prior.

Alabama gets to be static in positivity; everyone else is judged dynamically and negatively; except UGA + the rest of the SEC.
 
Sure, but it would be stupid as **** to ignore this is the 5th year of pro-Bama evidence & their own stupid logic is too inconsistent to pass the smell test. A stupid committee could still be transparent & release their metrics or release segments — chosen propaganda clips — of their discussions to the public for better PR. & yet they don’t do any of that.

Okay 2017 11-1 Alabama over 12-1 Wisconsin, 10-3 Auburn, and 11-2 Ohio State can be justified because CCGs mattered for determining the 4-team playoff. I don’t care about this year.

It’s the 4 straight years—notably, when saban had more pressure on him and then the first 3 years of the post-saban era where their massive ratings held steady

2023 Alabama over 13-0 FSU — okay the logic is there but it’s still against everything they’ve done before and quite frankly was unprecedented.

Then in the 12-team playoff, it has gotten shameless; but as much as i dislike the Seminoles, their injury is greater than ours..

2024; 9-3 Alabama is over 10-2 Miami; both teams beat UF who was 8-4. We smacked UF. But “SOS,” makes their 3rd loss more acceptable somehow. Nvm UGA needed 8 overtime’s to beat GT who we lost to. Nvm that Syracuse’s quarterback was literally Ohio State’s quarterback the year prior; & led the country in passing yards. Never mind our margin of defeat was by a total of 7 points; meanwhile, Alabama lost to 6-6 OU by 21 points & 6-6 Vandy by 5 points. 10-2 Tennessee wasn’t even in the discussion despite their loss to Arkansas; since they beat Alabama.

Thankfully, SMU lost narrowly to Clemson which bumped Alabama out of the playoffs; but it was clear and obvious that they didn’t expect this to happen at all. BYU at 10-2 w/ a win over SMU wasn’t even in the discussion for the bubble teams w/ 9-3 Alabama, 9-3 South Carolina, 9-3 Ole Miss and 10-2 Miami.

2025 Alabama, with a loss to fsu, is ranked higher than Miami who beat FSU; their only common opponent. 11-2 BYU isn’t taken very seriously with their true freshman qb for the entirety of this process.

They purposefully wait to make the switch at the end because of numerous championship game conditionals, but covered their own Alabama *** — learning from the year prior — by swapping Alabama to 9th instead of 10th to ensure that they would get in the playoffs despite a loss. When in reality ND deserved Alabama’s spot. Kickstarting a year+ of making fun of ND and saying they don’t deserve a playoff spot if they lose to BYU + Miami and go 10-2 this season.

Now, our H2H with ND holds us back while Tennessee’s H2H with Texas holds them back; but somehow, Alabama’s H2H w/ Tennessee never enters the same pod. Yet, Tennessee and Alabama have six common opponents: Auburn, Vanderbilt, Kentucky, Texas A&M, South Carolina, and LSU.

The last three national championships have come from one conference yet 8 of the 10 toughest schedules are supposedly in the SEC. It’s stupidity and corruption; but to act like there’s no corrupt bargaining is to remain blind. They have 7-3 Ohio state over 8-2 Iowa; but cannot be helped to put Tennessee over Alabama? Last week, USC was ahead of Ohio State.

When the rankings opened, 7-1 ND was behind 7-1 BYU. 6-2 ole miss was ahead of 6-2 LSU but below 6-2 Texas. They had 7-1 Kentucky behind 6-2 Alabama because bama beat Kentucky. Now Kentucky is 7-3 and Alabama remains number 3. It’s absurd and a farce
I actually do agree they are corruptly boosting the SEC at the expense of everyone else. Remember, this outfit made a special deal with ND that is blatantly unfair on it's face, so nothing is beneath them.
And consider the arcane and absurd "criteria" they say they go by: "quality losses", "conference strength", players being in or out of the lineup, strength of schedule as determined by their own placement of teams in their own top 25. Then they juggle all this BS to justify whatever outcome they want. At the same time they claim to just be looking for the "best teams". It surely looks like a system set up to make virtually any outcome justifiable under their garbled and incomprehensible explanations. The SEC teams in the 20-25 range? Just setting the precedent for 8-10 SEC slots in the 24 team playoff next year. But all that said, they're still morons first and foremost, otherwise their bul**** wouldn't be so laughably fatuous.
 
Just found this interview from last week

TLDW; the top 3 teams are all but set no matter what happens, and they’ve been set since we lost.

 
If Bama makes and loses the sec title game and the right teams win their conferences I think itll be like last year. Tennessee will leapfrog Bama once they are forced into the same pod and have virtually the same records. It may even happen after Tennessee beats LSU to make the explanation easier. Wouldnt shock me if the commuttee pushes all these sec teams up right before title games only to roll other teams in front of them once they win their conferences.

All these early rankings are posturing and designed to drive interest. I wont deny they position these SEC teams where they need to keep them in the discussion, BUT The committee has shown that they are going to do whatever they want on the final ranking. They have no problem saying previous rankings do not matter at all once the full body of work is there.

Going into the final weekend. I expect it to be

UGA
Utah
UCLA (after USC win)

Bama Texas Tennnessee ND (not sure the order)
Miami

When we win out we will move to 4 or 5 depending on if they penalize ND for not playing in a conference title game. I believe they will be penalized for it.

If Toney plays and balls in the ACCCG and we win comfortably Id bet we get the 4 seed more to make ND play that extra game than to reward us.

I think you're being (way) too generous to the CFP committee. This is big big business, the stakes are super high, and we know who pays their paycheck.
 
Full interview from November 11


In this interview, he talks about Texas having 4 good wins: Tennessee, Ole Miss, Ohio State, and Mizzou. After the interview, they beat LSU and Mizzou dropped out. But, their two losses became quality losses because OU and UF jumped into the rankings (no bull****)

We need UF and OU to lose again among other things in order for us to keep climbing
 
If Bama makes and loses the sec title game and the right teams win their conferences I think itll be like last year. Tennessee will leapfrog Bama once they are forced into the same pod and have virtually the same records. It may even happen after Tennessee beats LSU to make the explanation easier. Wouldnt shock me if the commuttee pushes all these sec teams up right before title games only to roll other teams in front of them once they win their conferences.

All these early rankings are posturing and designed to drive interest. I wont deny they position these SEC teams where they need to keep them in the discussion, BUT The committee has shown that they are going to do whatever they want on the final ranking. They have no problem saying previous rankings do not matter at all once the full body of work is there.

Going into the final weekend. I expect it to be

UGA
Utah
UCLA (after USC win)

Bama Texas Tennnessee ND (not sure the order)
Miami

When we win out we will move to 4 or 5 depending on if they penalize ND for not playing in a conference title game. I believe they will be penalized for it.

If Toney plays and balls in the ACCCG and we win comfortably Id bet we get the 4 seed more to make ND play that extra game than to reward us.
The committee dosn’t even consider Tennessee and Indiana to be in the same “pool,” as the teams above them.

They believe UGA 1, Utah 2, Bama 3, and then the next 4 are up for debate. Alabama losing to UGA again doesn’t mean anything to them
 
"A win at unranked Missouri on Saturday will help, but it won't carry the same weight as it did earlier in the campaign because that would be the Tigers' fifth loss." (Dinich)

Lol. Guess the teams that gave them their first four losses still get credit though.
 
Back
Top