cookies
All American
- Joined
- Feb 21, 2021
- Messages
- 12,440
Sure, but it would be stupid as **** to ignore this is the 5th year of pro-Bama evidence & their own stupid logic is too inconsistent to pass the smell test. A stupid committee could still be transparent & release their metrics or release segments — chosen propaganda clips — of their discussions to the public for better PR. & yet they don’t do any of that.Remember Hanlon's Razor: “Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity”
Okay 2017 11-1 Alabama over 12-1 Wisconsin, 10-3 Auburn, and 11-2 Ohio State can be justified because CCGs mattered for determining the 4-team playoff. I don’t care about this year.
It’s the 4 straight years—notably, when saban had more pressure on him and then the first 3 years of the post-saban era where their massive ratings held steady
2023 Alabama over 13-0 FSU — okay the logic is there but it’s still against everything they’ve done before and quite frankly was unprecedented.
Then in the 12-team playoff, it has gotten shameless; but as much as i dislike the Seminoles, their injury is greater than ours..
2024; 9-3 Alabama is over 10-2 Miami; both teams beat UF who was 8-4. We smacked UF. But “SOS,” makes their 3rd loss more acceptable somehow. Nvm UGA needed 8 overtime’s to beat GT who we lost to. Nvm that Syracuse’s quarterback was literally Ohio State’s quarterback the year prior; & led the country in passing yards. Never mind our margin of defeat was by a total of 7 points; meanwhile, Alabama lost to 6-6 OU by 21 points & 6-6 Vandy by 5 points. 10-2 Tennessee wasn’t even in the discussion despite their loss to Arkansas; since they beat Alabama.
Thankfully, SMU lost narrowly to Clemson which bumped Alabama out of the playoffs; but it was clear and obvious that they didn’t expect this to happen at all. BYU at 10-2 w/ a win over SMU wasn’t even in the discussion for the bubble teams w/ 9-3 Alabama, 9-3 South Carolina, 9-3 Ole Miss and 10-2 Miami.
2025 Alabama, with a loss to fsu, is ranked higher than Miami who beat FSU; their only common opponent. 11-2 BYU isn’t taken very seriously with their true freshman qb for the entirety of this process.
They purposefully wait to make the switch at the end because of numerous championship game conditionals, but covered their own Alabama *** — learning from the year prior — by swapping Alabama to 9th instead of 10th to ensure that they would get in the playoffs despite a loss. When in reality ND deserved Alabama’s spot. Kickstarting a year+ of making fun of ND and saying they don’t deserve a playoff spot if they lose to BYU + Miami and go 10-2 this season. Alabama looked awful against an auburn team with an interim HC.
Now, our H2H with ND holds us back while Tennessee’s H2H with Texas holds them back; but somehow, Alabama’s H2H w/ Tennessee never enters the same pod. Yet, Tennessee and Alabama have six common opponents: Auburn, Vanderbilt, Kentucky, Texas A&M, South Carolina, and LSU.
The last three national championships have come from one conference yet 8 of the 10 toughest schedules are supposedly in the SEC. It’s stupidity and corruption; but to act like there’s no corrupt bargaining is to remain blind. They have 7-3 Ohio state over 8-2 Iowa; but cannot be helped to put Tennessee over Alabama? Last week, USC was ahead of Ohio State.
When the rankings opened, 7-1 ND was behind 7-1 BYU. 6-2 ole miss was ahead of 6-2 LSU but below 6-2 Texas. They had 7-1 Kentucky behind 6-2 Alabama because bama beat Kentucky. Now Kentucky is 7-3 and Alabama remains number 3. It’s absurd and a farce
Last edited: