Oh he is, but I'm not shocked. The point I'm making is that it doesn't make sense for a woman with options to willingly choose someone with that reputation. Alyssa is a solid person and a looker to boot, I'll never for the life of me understand why she chose to date Chick. It's not an accident that he had that reputation on campus, odds are it was very true. Miami is a small community, for anyone to get that kind of reputation, you had to not only do it, but do it multiple times and people find out about it. It's akin to Pike having the rape label on campus before they got booted. You can't say it isn't true when there's multiple examples of you doing rapey crap.
Then again, a lot of women are awful judges of character, hence why some of the most reprehensible men on earth are lady killers. Ted Bundy was getting mail from Playboy centerfolds right up until he died, despite him being a convicted serial killer of women. I think society was onto something when a girl's father had to vet the guys she dated. A lot of these women can't pick a decent dude for crap. Then again, if you go back to someone who kicked your ***, I feel zero sympathy for you if it happens again.