All-Time Rankings in the Top Three College Sports

Kirijax

Senior
Joined
Dec 20, 2012
Messages
2,264
There's no question college football is the most popular sport in college athletics, followed by basketball and then baseball coming in at a distant third. All other sports are non-revenue sports and can't be compared to these three sports in college. I started wondering where Miami, Florida and Florida State are ranked all-time in the three sports and who would come out on top.

Florida_iPhone_2.webp

College Football
There are a bunch of all-time rankings out there and the results are mixed, so I went to the College Football Warehouse. They seem to have put together a simple formula to come up with an up-to-date ranking for the football programs. The three Florida teams are all ranked as follows:

College Football Warehouse All-Time Rankings
No. 12 Florida Gators
No. 14 Miami Hurricanes
No. 18 Florida State Seminoles

The thing that put the Gators ahead of the Canes and Noles is their strength of schedule points. Which might suggest there may be a tad bit of SEC bias creeping in here as well but that's hard to avoid.

College Basketball
ESPN put out a list of the Top 50 list in 2012, and the site http://fansided.com/2014/10/21/75-greatest-college-basketball-programs-time-statistically-ranked/4/ recently. The only team of the three Florida schools to be listed is Florida. The Gators came in at No. 40 in the ESPN rankings and No. 43 in the Fansided rankings. The Seminoles would have to come in second with the 1972 NCAA runner-up finish and 14 NCAA appearances. The Canes have a ways to go to catch up here.

College Baseball
An all-time ranking for college baseball is a bit hard to find, especially one that goes beyond the Top 10, but no matter where you look, Miami is the winner here hands down. The Canes are the only one of the three to win the College World Series and they also have the most players in the Major Leagues. Florida State isn't far behind and usually right around the No. 10 ranking. The only thing holding them back is the fact that they have never won the College World Series, despite making it to the World Series over 20 times (ouch). Miami was also responsible for keeping them winless by beating the Noles in the final round of the 1999 World Series. Florida has only recently been making some noise but they have nowhere near the Canes' and Noles' success.

So In college football, Florida leads the rankings, even though Miami has the most championships. In basketball, it's Florida all the way. In baseball, Miami is king with the Noles always being held back at the last round.

As far as national championships in the big three sports go, Miami is far ahead of the other two with nine championships. Florida has five titles and Florida State has three. Despite all the noise the Gators and Noles have been making in the last couple of decades, they still have a long ways to go before they can catch up to the Miami Hurricanes.

miamigoodbad.webp

And just in case you were wondering, Miami wipes the tennis court with the Gators and Noles as well!
 
Advertisement
That fan sided basketball list is baaaaad and same with that cfb list. How does scheduling outweigh national championships by so so much?
 
That fan sided basketball list is baaaaad and same with that cfb list. How does scheduling outweigh national championships by so so much?

Good question. I wish someone could come up with a system to rank teams fairly. Maybe impossible though with all the independent teams and scheduling.
 
I wish our team would win more games. Let's actually care about what matters and the opinions of the irrelevant.
 
Noles are distant last. At least gator won NC in two major sports. If Miami ever wins one in Bball then it is no-brainer with one is all three majors. Even if you consider basketball bigger than baseball, I still have to go with Miami because of pure numbers 9 to 5 but also because we were first on the national stage, changed football completely, and probably made college baseball into what it is today.
 
Oops. This just in ..Duke is probably ahead of us considering resurgence of football over basketball...
 
Oops. This just in ..Duke is probably ahead of us considering resurgence of football over basketball...

So their football is better than their hoops, and our hoops is better than our football. It's a topsy turvy world we live in these days.
 
Cool read. Good work Homie. Love the tennis there at the end. I know you love yourself some tennis.
 
if we coulda been at least avg as a program, historically, before schnell, we would be top ten all time and ahead of uf by a good margin.
 
Advertisement
Back
Top