All Canes NFL team can win Super Bowl: AJ

Cane2

Band
Banned
Joined
Feb 22, 2013
Messages
1,438
Andre_Johnson_Andrew_Luck_Best_QB_NFL (1).webp
Could Andre and the Canes win a title? (USATSI)

There is no lack of brashness when it comes to football players out of "The U." For years, the Miami Hurricanes ruled college football and ruled the NFL in perhaps even more impressive fashion, consistently sending piles of prospects to the pros.

It's petered off a bit lately (even though Al Golden's six-win Canes team sent seven players to the NFL this year!) but former Canes standout and new Colts wide receiver Andre Johnson thinks a team comprised of all Hurricanes could win the Super Bowl.

"Yeah I really think you can [win a Super Bowl],” Johnson said. "If you put a team together and all of the guys are in their prime, yes, I think you could get it done."

Asked about putting the group together RIGHT NOW -- not dudes in their prime, but right now, including Ray Lewis and Ed Reed for some reason -- Johnson didn't waffle.

"I think you could put something together that would get you there," Johnson said. "I think you can put a team together that can get it done."

Johnson's own team in Indy is basically all U players already. There's Johnson, Frank Gore, Philip Dorsett, tight end Erik Swoope and two coaches in Rob Chudzinski and Chuck Pagano from Miami.

That's a pretty good head start. But let's construct a team real quick based on all Miami Hurricanes players and see how it would do.

QB --

Oh well see right here we have ourselves a bit of a problem. THERE'S NO QUARTERBACK.

Not literally, but almost. Certainly a dropoff from the "best quarterback in the NFL." The closest thing is either:

1) Ken Dorsey/Vinny Testaverde. One (Dorsey) is the quarterbacks coach of the Panthers, while the other (Vinny) last played for the Panthers in 2007. Don't tell me he couldn't suit up tomorrow and game-manage some team.

2) Jacory Harris. Currently playing in the CFL.

3) Stephen Morris/Ryan Williams/Jake Heaps. All undrafted free agents in the last two years on NFL rosters.

None of these are good ideas, but technically we could try and win a Super Bowl with Stephen Morris.

Onto the rest of the roster ...

RB -- Frank Gore/Lamar Miller/Mike James -- Strong backfield!

WR -- Andre Johnson/Philip Dorsett/Allen Hurns/Travis Benjamin/Tommy Streeter/LaRon Byrd/Reggie Wayne/Devin Hester/Santana Moss -- Steep drop off but a dangerous depth chart nonetheless. Again, who's throwing to them?

TE -- Jimmy Graham/Greg Olsen -- Best tight end combo in the league. Trade one dude for a QB.

OL -- Ereck Flowers/Orlando Franklin/Chris Myers/Eric Winston/Jason Fox/Seantrel Henderson/Brandon Linder/Jon Feliciano/Shane McDermott -- Throwing some bodies out here via PFR and Wikipedia, but we've got enough to field a full offensive line.

DL -- Calais Campbell/Allen Bailey/Olivier Vernon/Vince Wilfork -- Surprisingly weak group of guys.

LB -- D.J. Williams/Jon Beason/Sean Spence/Denzel Perryman -- Plenty of linebacker bodies here (not even counting Lewis!) so maybe we go 3-4 with this bad boy?

DB -- Sam Shields/Antrel Rolle/DeMarcus Van Dyke/Brandon Meriweather/Brandon Harris/Kenny Phillips -- Pretty strong group here actually.

So, does this team win the Super Bowl? Probably not. Maybe it contends in a weak division and maybe it makes the playoffs. But the quarterback problem is a real one and it's gonna keep this team from contending.

Still an impressive showing from The U. By Will Brinson | NFL Writer
 
Advertisement
He left out:

P/K: Matt Bosher. Pat O'Donnell

OG: Harland Gunn, Brandon Washington
TE: Clive Walford, Chase Ford, Richard Gordon
RB: Duke Johnson
WR: Leonard Hankerson

LB/DE: Anthony Chickillo
LB/ST: Ray Ray Armstrong, Tavarious Gooden, Spencer Adkins
LB: Jonathan Vilma, Darryl Sharpton
DB: Brandon McGee
DT: Micanor Regis
 
Last edited:
Offense:
QB: Morris, Harris, Williams PS: Heaps
RB: Gore, Miller, Duke, James
TE: Graham, Olsen, Clive, Ford PS: Gordon, Cleveland, Swoopes
WR: Johnson, Dorsett, Hankerson, Hurns, Benjamin, Hester, Wayne, Moss PS: Byrd, Streeter
OT: Flowers, Franklin, Henderson, Winston, Fox
OG: Linder, Washington, Felicano, Gunn PS: Renfrow, Wheeler
OC: Myers, McDermott

Defense:
DE: Campbell, Bailey, Vernon, Chickillo PS: Green
DT: Wilfork, Micanor, Robinson, Forston PS: Pierre
LB: Beason, D.J. Williams, Vilma, Spence, Perryman, Sharpton PS: Armstrong, Gooden, Adkins, Gaines, Armbrister
CB: Shields, Harris, DVD, McGee, Gunter
S: Rolle, Merriweather, Phillips

ST:
K: Matt Bosher
P: Pat O'Donell
KR/PR: Devin Hester, Travis Benajmin

Bold = Can start on most teams
Italic = Starter or started some games last season, can start or be solid backup

Staff
HC: Pagano
OC: Chud
DC: Wannstedt

QB: Dorsey
RB: Richardson
WR: Williams
TE: Roberts
OL: Sullivan, Stoutland

DL: Johnson
Pas Rush Specialist: Pratt
DB: McGriff
LB: Moss
ST: Armstrong
S&C: Krein, Kanavy, Tolbert

Scout: Highsmith
Personnel Director: Morgan
 
Last edited:
Love Dorsey, but he wouldve been the only thing holding the team back

It pains me to say this but I have to agree with this statement. I love Dorsey also...but a Super Bowl winning QB he is not. The NFL is a quarterback league and if you don't got one you aren't winning a Super Bowl.
 
Advertisement
Former Probowler in RED

Offense:
QB: Morris, Harris, Williams PS: Heaps
RB: Gore, Miller, Duke, James
TE: Graham, Olsen, Clive, Ford PS: Gordon, Cleveland, Swoopes
WR: Johnson, Dorsett, Hankerson, Hurns, Benjamin, Hester, Wayne, Moss PS: Byrd, Streeter
OT: Flowers, Franklin, Henderson, Winston, Fox
OG: Linder, Washington, Felicano, Gunn PS: Renfrow, Wheeler
OC: Myers, McDermott

Defense:
DE: Campbell, Bailey, Vernon, Chickillo PS: Green
DT: Wilfork, Micanor, Robinson, Forston PS: Pierre
LB: Beason, D.J. Williams, Vilma, Spence, Perryman, Sharpton PS: Armstrong, Gooden, Adkins, Gaines, Armbrister
CB: Shields, Harris, DVD, McGee, Gunter
S: Rolle, Merriweather, Phillips

ST:
K: Matt Bosher
P: Pat O'Donell
KR/PR: Devin Hester, Travis Benajmin
 
"Yeah I really think you can [win a Super Bowl],” Johnson said. "If you put a team together and all of the guys are in their prime, yes, I think you could get it done."

I'm sorry, did everyone for that statement??? I'm pretty sure he's talking about an all Cane team full of players in their PRIME that made it to the NFL.
 
"Yeah I really think you can [win a Super Bowl],” Johnson said. "If you put a team together and all of the guys are in their prime, yes, I think you could get it done."

I'm sorry, did everyone for that statement??? I'm pretty sure he's talking about an all Cane team full of players in their PRIME that made it to the NFL.

Asked about putting the group together RIGHT NOW -- not dudes in their prime, but right now, including Ray Lewis and Ed Reed for some reason -- Johnson didn't waffle.

"I think you could put something together that would get you there," Johnson said. "I think you can put a team together that can get it done."
 
2010 would have been good:

10 probowlers and 1 alternate:
AFC Andre Johnson WR Houston Texans Starter
AFC Reggie Wayne WR Indianapolis Colts Super Bowl
AFC Ray Lewis MLB Baltimore Ravens Starter
AFC Ed Reed FS Baltimore Ravens Starter
AFC Vince Wilfork DT New England Patriots Starter
AFC Brandon Meriweather FS New England Patriots Reserve
AFC D.J. Williams LB Denver Broncos Alternate
NFC Frank Gore RB San Francisco 49ers Reserve
NFC Jonathan Vilma LB New Orleans Saints Super Bowl
NFC Bryant McKinnie OT Minnesota Vikings Starter
NFC Antrel Rolle FS Arizona Cardinals Starter
NFC Jon Beason MLB Carolina Panthers Reserve
 
Here is the roster for 2010:

* = 10 guys coming off of Probowl seasons and 1 probowl alternate in 2009
+ = We also had another 11 guys who were past or future probowlers
# = other starters in 2010
- = active players in the NFL in 2010

QB (2) - Worst QBs in the NFL
-Ken Dorsey (8) QB Argonauts (CFL)
-Brock Berlin (6) cut by Rams in 2009 (DNP)

RB (4) - Best RBs in the NFL
*Frank Gore (6) 49ers (started 11 games, rushed for 853 yds and 3 tds, 46 rdc for 452 yds and 2 tds)
+Willis McGahee (8) Ravens (played in 15 games starting 2, rushed for 380 yds and 5 tds, probowl in 2011)
+Clinton Portis (9) Redskins (played 5 games Injured, last year)
-Javarris James (R) Colts (played in 10 games, 6 tds)

WR (5) - Best WRs in the NFL
*Andre Johnson (8) Texans (Pro bowl - started 13 games 1216 yds and 8 tds)
*Reggie Wayne (10) Colts (All pro - started 16 games, 111 rec for 1355 yards and 10 tds)
+Santana Moss (10) Redskins (started 16 games, 93 rec for 1115 yds and 6 tds)
+Devin Hester (5) Bears (Pro bowl, played 16 started 13 at WR
-Roscoe Parrish (6) Bills (started 6 of 8 games, 33 rec for 400 yds and 2 Tds)
PS:
-Sinorice Moss (5) Giants (DNP)
-Darnell Jenkins (3) Patriots
-Lance Leggett (3) Giants Camp


TE (4) - Best TEs in the NFL
+Kellen Winslow II (7) Browns (started 11 of 16 games, 66 rec for 730 yds and 5 tds)
+Jeremy Shockey (9) Giants (started 11 of 13 games, 41 rec for 408 yards and 3 tds)
+Greg Olsen (4) Panthers (started 13 oif 16 games, 41 rec for 441 yds 5 Tds)
+Jimmy Graham (R) Saints (started 5 of 15 games, 31 rec for 356 yards and 5 tds)
PS:
-Dedrick Epps (R) TE Dolphins (played in 3 games)


OL (8) - 4 solid starters but no depth
LT *Bryant McKinnie (9) Vikings (started 16 games @ LT)
LG #Rashad Butler (5) OT Texans (played in 16 games and started 4 at LT)
C +Chris Myers (6) Texans (started 16 gmaes @ C, made probowl in 2011)
RG #Vernon Carey (7) OT Dolphins (started 12 games at RT)
RT #Eric Winston (5) OT Texans (started 16 games at RT)
-Jason Fox (R) OT Lions (4th) (played in 4 games)
-Brett Romberg (8) C Falcons (DNP)
-Martin Bibla (9) Sacaramento Mountain Lions (UFL) (DNP)

DL (7) - Best DT in the game but no DE other than Campbell
DT *Vince Wilfork (7) Patriots (Pro-bowl started 16 games with 2 sacks and 46 tackles)
DE +Calais Campbell (3) Cardinals (started 15 games @ LDE, 6 sacks and 45 tackles)
DT #Antonio Dixon (2) Eagles (played in 15 games starting 10, 25 tackles and 2 sacks)
DT -Damione Lewis (10) Texans (last season, played in 10 games, 1 sack, 13 tackles)
DT -William Joseph (8) Raiders (DNP)
DE -Baraka Atkins (4) Broncos Camp (DNP)
DT -Orien Harris (5) Bengals Camp
PS
DT -Kareem Brown (4) Titans (DNP)
DT -Joe Joseoh (appeared in 1 game) Washington Redskins
DT -Santonio Thomas (6) New York Giants Camp
DT -Dwayne Hendricks (2) New York Giants

LB (9) - Best LBs in the NFL
*Ray Lewis (15) Ravens (pro Bowl - started 16 games @ MLB 102 tackles)
*Jon Beason (4) Panthers (Pro Bowl - started 16 games @ RLB 90 tackles)
*Jonathan Vilma (7) Saints (Pro bowl - started 16 games @ MLB, 4 sacks and 71 tackles))
*D.J. Williams (7) Broncos (started 15 of 16 gmaes at LILB, 5.5 sacks and 94 tackles)
#Rocky McIntosh (5) Washington Redskins (started 15 games at LB, 73 tackles)
#Darryl Sharpton (R) Texans (4th) (started 6 of 12 games @ RLB, 1 sack and 13 tackles)
-Leon Williams (5) Cowboys (played in 11 games)
-Tavares Gooden (3) Ravens
-Spencer Adkins (2) Falcons (Special teams)

S (4) - Best Safties in the NFL
*Ed Reed (9) Ravens (all pro - 8 int and 30 tackles, started 10 games)
*Brandon Meriweather (4) Patriots (Pro Bowl -Started 13 games at FS3 int, 49 tackels)
*Antrel Rolle (6) Cardinals (Pro Bowl - started 16 games, 1 int, 75 tackles)
#Kenny Phillips (3) Giants (started 15 of 16 games, 1 int, 60 tackles)

CB (5) - Solid group with 3 starters
#Phillip Buchanon (9) Redskins (played 16 games and started 5 RCB, 2 picks 41 tackles)
#Kelly Jennings (5) Seahawks (started 14 games, 1 int, 35 tackles)
+Sam Shields (R) Packers (started 6 of 14 games, 2 int adn 24 tackles)
-Bruce Johnson (2) Giants (played in 6 games)
-Glenn Sharpe (3) Saints PS
PS:
-Khalili Jones (2) WR/S Packer Camp


ST (2)
P Jeff Feagles (retired in 2009)
K Matt Bosher (leave as JR)

PR/KR +Devin Hester (5) Bears (pro bowl, played 16 started 13 at WR)
PR/KR #Roscoe Parrish (6) Bills (started 6 of 8 games, 33 rec for 400 yds and 2 Tds)
 
Last edited:
Advertisement
Back
Top