I was offered seats in your same section/row, or in 542 row 15. After talking for a minute, he offered the 5 seats in the 5th row. We had to take the extra ticket to get those seats (was only looking for four), they had five together, so wouldn’t sell just the 4. Hope that makes sense, you didn’t get shafted, I just got lucky and/or asked the right questions to get the guy to offer me the seats I got. I also mentioned to him we wouldn’t mind 2 and 2 if they were close together for better seats. End of the day, we won’t have any trouble finding use for the 5th ticket. I wasn’t made aware of the club seats you mentioned.
I think they’re pretty busy, so not necessarily going to be running through all the options with every person they talk to. Hope that helps you feel better.