• Attention: Register today to view CanesInSight Ad-Free for 7 days.

247 Article - 2018 Commit NFL Comparison

nvlahos

Junior
Joined
Feb 14, 2012
Messages
3,561
Here's the article...

NFL Comps: Who Do The 2018 Miami Commits Remind Us Of?


Thought this was an interesting way to look at the class. Wanted to do my own comparisons.


QB Artur Sitkowski - Andrew Luck

RB Lorenzo Lingard - Darren Mcfadden

RB Camron Davis - Mark Ingram

WR Mark Pope - Reggie Wayne/ Stacy Coley

WR Brian Hightower - Brandon Marshall

WR Daquris Wiggins - Allen Hurns

TE Brevin Jordan - Jordan Reed/Delanie Walker

TE Will Mallory - Greg Olsen

OL Cleveland Reed - Chance Warmack

OL Delone Scaife - Rodney Hudson

DT Nesta Silvera - Kawann Short

DE Gregory Rousseau - Aldon Smith

DB Josh Jobe - Eric Berry

DB Gurvan Hall - Earl Thomas

DB Gilbert Frierson - Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie

DB DJ Ivey - Artie Burns

DB Randy Russell - Brandon Meriweather
 

Port Knox

Hollywood Cole
Joined
Feb 3, 2012
Messages
5,950
giphy.gif
 

LuCane

Administrator
Administrator
Joined
Oct 21, 2011
Messages
13,813
Here's the article...

DB Gilbert Frierson - Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie

DB DJ Ivey - Artie Burns
I get what you and they are doing by looking at player styles. But, think these two are way off, especially Frierson, who is a different type of player altogether than the attributes DR-C brings to the table.
 
Last edited:
W

westcoastcanes

Guest
So I think what you and that article are trying to say is

Andrew Lucky, Darren Mcfadon, Marc Ingraham, Reggie Wane, Brandin Marsal, Alan Hurns, Jordin Read, Third Leg, Chance Warmick, Rodney Hutson, Kawan Shirt, Eldon Smith, Eireck Berry, Earl Thomas, DRC, Artie Burns, Brandon merriweather are Artur Sitkowski, Lorenzo Lingered, Camron Davis, Mark Pope, Brian Hightower, Daiquiris Wiggins, Brevin Jordan, Will Mallory, Cleveland Reed, Delone Scaife, Nesta Silvera, Gregory Rousseau, Josh Jobe, Gurvan Hall, Gilbert Frierson, DJ Ivey, and Randy Russell's floors respectively?
 

Ver

Senior
Joined
Dec 31, 2015
Messages
3,904
I think those are ceiling comparisons, and if so we assembled the greatest team ever lol
 

Liberty City El

Dejazmach
Joined
May 14, 2016
Messages
18,832
Artur Sitkowski - Christian Hackenberg

Lorenzo Lingard - Edgerrin James/ Marcus Allen

Camron Davis - Alfred Morris

Mark Pope - Marvin Harrison

Brian Hightower - Allen Robinson

Daquris Wiggins - Devante Parker

Brevin Jordan - Vernon Davis

Will Mallory - Zach Ertz

Cleveland Reed - Kelechi Osemele

Delone Scaife - Travis Frederick

Nesta Silvera - Ian Williams/ Geno Atkins

Gregory Rousseau - Brian Orakpo

Josh Jobe - Byron Jones

Gurvan Hall - Devin McCourty

Gilbert Frierson - Antrel Rolle

DJ Ivey - Xavier Rhodes

Randy Russell - Brandon Meriweather/ Brian Dawkins
 
Last edited:

STORM_FRONT 1964

Buddy & Jimmy @ Greentree
Joined
May 9, 2017
Messages
153
Artur Sitkowski - Christian Hackenberg

Lorenzo Lingard - Edgerrin James/ Marcus Allen

Camron Davis - Alfred Morris

Mark Pope - Marvin Harrison

Brian Hightower - Allen Robinson

Daquris Wiggins - Devante Parker

Brevin Jordan - Vernon Davis

Will Mallory - Zach Ertz

Cleveland Reed - Kelechi Osemele

Delone Scaife - Travis Frederick

Nesta Silvera - Ian Williams/ Geno Atkins

Gregory Rousseau - Brian Orakpo

Josh Jobe - Byron Jones

Gurvan Hall - Devin McCourty

Gilbert Frierson - Antrel Rolle

DJ Ivey - Xavier Rhodes

Randy Russell - Brandon Meriweather/ Brian Dawkins



The Lingard / Marcus Allen comparison is VERY good. Similar styles.
 

AllAboutDaU

Freshman
Joined
Sep 27, 2013
Messages
1,021
I like the McFadden to lingard comparison. I think they run similar. You could throw gurley into the mix too. Run a little high. And more power and speed than lateral ability.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

nvlahos

Junior
Joined
Feb 14, 2012
Messages
3,561
So ~15 Pro Bowlers in one recruiting class?


It's just a discussion piece. Obviously all these guys won't turn out to be perennial Pros and Pro Bowlers

Just comparing styles and ceilings

Good job adding value to the discussion
 

nvlahos

Junior
Joined
Feb 14, 2012
Messages
3,561
Here's the article...

DB Gilbert Frierson - Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie

DB DJ Ivey - Artie Burns
I get what you and they are doing by looking at player styles. But, think these two are way off, especially Frierson, who is a different type of player altogether than the attributes DR-C brings to the table.

Yea i agree, and I wasn't really sure who to compare Frierson to. Maybe more of a Kenny Phillips with more fluidity and ability to play Corner too
 

Themadcane

Ready for a new day
Joined
Jul 19, 2016
Messages
329
Sit is peyton manning!!
LO is Chris Johnson

Ivey is revis island

Cmon as long as we are playing. Lets be fair
 
Top