Can Malachi Toney Win The Heisman Trophy?

Trinton Breeze
2 min read
We knew Malachi Toney was going to have another solid season at Miami after blowing up his freshman year, recording well over 1,000 receiving yards. However, after Friday's 45-6 win over the Stanford Cardinal, he is most definitely in contention for the Heisman Trophy this season.

The Trophy will be given at the end of the year to the most outstanding player in the 2026-27 college football season. Only two players from Miami have won the award: quarterbacks Vinny Testaverde and Gino Torretta. There have only been a total of five receivers to win the trophy, meaning it is harder to win the award as a receiver. But after Toney's video-game performance against the Cardinal, he is pushing to be the sixth.

Against Stanford, Toney recorded 12 receptions for 234 yards and three scores. He was just simply unstoppable. Double team? No worries. Toney was going to get open and he made sure that Stanford wasn't going to do anything about it. His quickness and elusiveness mixed in with his fast release gets him open with ease.

Toney also made history Friday night by breaking the single-game receiving record in Hurricanes’ history, previously held by Eddie Brown. After scoring three touchdowns, he hit the 'Heisman Trophy' pose in the end-zone, showing that he is coming for the trophy this season.

1788699018767.png


The sports gambling sites have Malachi Toney inside the top-10 among the best players in college football to win Heisman. According to FanDuel Sportsbook, he has the 8th best odds to claim the trophy. BetMGM slots him at the No. 7 with +1500 odds.

Toney should be able to keep this momentum up as the Hurricanes will host in-state FCS foe, the FAMU Rattlers. He should be able to put up solid numbers and potentially rise in the Heisman odds if he has a decent performance.

This leaves us with a question: Can Malachi Toney claim the Heisman Trophy as a 18-year old?
 

Comments (16)

He has a U on the side of his helmet, so no.
 
Not from receiving only because Mensah will also get the credit. Needs special team and throwing some TDs.
 
Not from receiving only because Mensah will also get the credit. Needs special team and throwing some TDs.
Was coming in to say samething. Every TD he catches Mensah benefits which makes sense.. He needs to house punts because I dont think we see too much Malicat this year because the QB play will be too good.. Malicat last year was to grease the wheels of a stalling offense plus if it doesnt go perfect, everyone gets mad at Dawson and says he gets tooo cute and just run the regular O.
 
The voting is heavily biased to qb, so it's gonna be hard for him when his qb is out there throwing more TDs than incompletions.
When breaks a few punts for touchdowns that conversation with change. He is going to run a couple and throw a couple for sure.
 
His best shot would be if we let him play more QB, maybe 4-5 plays a game as an offensive wrinkle. Kind of like last year but would need more throws.

If he did that + his reception numbers + punt returns, you could definitely make a case since he’s such a unique player.

Thing is, we have Mensah now, I don’t know why we’d ever want to take throwing opportunities away from him just to help Mali with his Heisman case. And everything we know about Mali suggests he’s truly just about the team winning, so I don’t even think he’d want to make it just about him.
 
This is going to be Dorsey-McGahee all over again.

Darian and Malachi are going to take each other’s votes
Yea funny that didn’t happen with Devonta Smoth.

Only happens with Miami players. They’ll make up a new rule of two Canes are finalists
 
I believe he can win the heisman. He doesnt drop the ball. I didnt care for the heisman pose he already has a target on his back. He’s clutch and isn’t afraid to throw a block for his teammates. Awesome person also.
 
Back
Top