Has Herman ever had success offensively with a concrete-footed QB? Ward is an insane athlete, JT Barrett was an excellent runner as was Braxton Miller. Cardale Jones isn't a burner, but he's a good powerful runner who did a lot of damage with his feet in last year's championship run.
I don't believe he's worked with one who isn't a threat at all with their legs in the last 8 years.
During his two-year stint as the OC at Rice from 2007-2008, he improved their total offense ranking from 51st in '07 to 10th in '08. But Chase Clement, who threw for over 4,000 yards as a senior in '08, also ran for over 700 yards and was a 4.6 guy.
As the OC at Iowa State, he improved their Offensive S&P+ rank from 105th in '08 (before he arrived) to 42nd in '09 (his first year on the job) with Austen Arnaud at QB. Arnaud was a JAG who never averaged more than 4 YPC in a season and wasn't necessarily a great runner or athlete, but he wasn't completely immobile either. Their QBs in 2011 (Barnett and Jantz) were complete dumpster fires and their offense regressed. But Urban was smart enough to realize Herman was a great young coach in a disastrous situation talent-wise at ISU, so he didn't hesitate to bring him to OSU at the beginning of his tenure and the rest was history.
I'd imagine he'd exclusively recruit dual-threat QBs and adapt his offense to his personnel for the first year or two to cater to Kaaya's strengths.
People make a big deal about the system you run. But I've learned though the years that your system has to marry your talent. One of my proudest seasons is when we went 12-0 in my first year at Ohio State in 2012. Philosophically, we wanted to be balanced. But we couldn't throw the ball. We had a good line, a beast at tailback in Carlos Hyde and a freak at quarterback in Braxton Miller. It was one of my proudest achievements in coaching. We didn't try to fit a square peg in a round hole. And that's how we're going to approach stuff at Houston. You start with a vision of, "Here's who we are. Here's our beliefs. Here's how we play." What our vision may be is going to be entirely dependent on the players we have.
Good stuff, big man.
My only concern with a guy who has done nothing but run that spread option with QBs who are a running threat is that he might struggle with a QB like Kaaya. Look at Chip Kelly in the NFL with QBs who don't or can't run. His offenses look pretty bad.
I've also seen quite a few college teams struggle with that system when they don't have a running threat at QB. Just look at how bad UF's offense got when Brantley had to play QB.
Philly was 2nd in total offense in 2013, 5th in 2014. Kelly hasn't had good QBs either.
I don't see it being a problem with Herman either.