Would you rather go 8-4 with NP or JW, or 10-2 with Rosier?

[407cane]

This is the definition of a porst.

unfortunately it's what all these porsters demanding rosier be benched are asking for

if perry truly gave us a better chance to win he would be starting, he is not, which leads you to believe that he's not as good as we hoped for and that we would lose a game or two more with perry than we would with rosier

 

[deleted2525]

I'll go 0-12 with your Avi

 

[kennesaw_cane]

Don't care right now. @nobeastofburden I've watched your avatar over and over and it NEVER gets old. Brings a smile to my face every time. Who is that?

 

[TexasCane90]

We win 10 games with Rosier? lol

Kosi, Weldon could get us 10 wins and a bowl win against a decent club

Williams I worry about as he would have a lot of growing pains but even then 8/9 wins

 

[borncane]

is this real life.

 

[Loose Cannon]

We win 10 games with Rosier? lol

Kosi, Weldon could get us 10 wins and a bowl win against a decent club

Williams I worry about as he would have a lot of growing pains but even then 8/9 wins

Those three players barely have 10 completions spread between them in 3 quarters of action against a DII school, yet you see an easy 10 wins with them over the guy who’s actually done it?

 

[rok]

10-2 to keep the momentum going. 8-4 looks wack.

 

[SinCityCane]

The funniest part of this thread is seeing that we still have fans who think we'd win more games with Malik than Williams or Perry. Experience doesn't matter if you can't execute the plays. I think some don't realize how fortunate we were to get to 10-0 last year with all the nailbiters against mediocre teams while dominating the turnover battles. We should've wiped those teams out. Either of the two QBs (Jarren in particular) would be more effective using only 50% of the playbook than what we're seeing now with Malik. That's what I think people are missing on. With the talent we have at the skill positions, put a good enough QB behind center & most defenses will have a hard time stopping it regardless of how simple the offense is.

 

[mirvin88]

You forgot 11-1 with Weldon

 

[Silver King]

Here's a Better one:

Consider FSU's Deondre Francois 2016 season; and UM's Malik Rosier 2017 season.

Each beat their rival (each other's team) and notched 10 wins in those seasons. Also consider the anticipation both programs had for their coming second year as starters.

Who do you think had the better first year as a starter; and which is looking better to this stage in their actual 2nd year starting?

 

[Gatorhater]

I take the 10 wins, unless, one of the 8 is in the ACC title game against Clemson. That is a big steeping stone that goes beyond preferring any QB.

 

[Invalid Username]

Delete your account

I'll take 8-4

Delete you account. Pack your bag. Leave the country. Never come back.

 

[423Hurricane]

11-1 no matter what, how, who.

 

[Cknucks305]

I can't decide which is worse. Fans who would rather toss away a season for the sake of getting someone else PT, or fans who are actively rooting for our starting QB to play poorly so another QB can get PT.

This right here. I am not a huge fan of the choice to continue to play Malik but idgaf I root for the canes to win no matter who’s in the game if you got that U on the side of the helmet I want you to succeed.

 

[Awsi Dooger]

If we switched quarterbacks and lost 3 more games there would be heat all over Richt, and plenty assigned to Perry also.

Don't kid yourself about the latter. Savior reputation gone or at best severely dented.

Recruiting probably drops 3-5 spots, and we can't afford 3-5 spots. We were already 16th in this preseason 2018 talent ranking, based on the last 5 recruiting classes. LSU was 6th. Every champion since the switch to the Final Four has been within the top 8. If we continue with recruiting classes between 5-10 we'll reach the top 8 soon. If we slide back to classes in the teens we won't get there.

https://athlonsports.com/college-football/ranking-college-footballs-rosters-2018

 

[canecat]

If anyone said 8-4 they are a true *****. YOU PLAY TO WIN THE GAME HELLO!

 

[OriginalGatorHater]

I can't decide which is worse. Fans who would rather toss away a season for the sake of getting someone else PT, or fans who are actively rooting for our starting QB to play poorly so another QB can get PT.

I think the worst is the guy who spends the whole offseason gassing up a terrible QB and calling people porsters for disagreeing and then after the LSU disaster still trys to post like he isn't completely football illiterate.

 

[mirednmediocrity2]

We’re not going 10-2 with this team. Already got 1 loss and no way we’re not getting at least two other L’s along the way, especially with this OL and Rosier. 10-2 is probably 2019.

 

[jsy]

It's a no brain'er. dUh. 10-2 and another shot at mighty Clemson in the ACC title game.

I don’t want us to be embarrassed again on prime time

Bad optics

 

[jsy]

You take wins over losses EVERY. SINGLE. TIME.

We might still be with golden if that’s the case