Lets say two teams each sign 15 players.
Each class has 1 five star player, 10 four star players and 3 three star players.
Each class has 14 players broken down as follows........ 2 RB, 3 WR, 2 OL, 3 DL, 2 LB, 1 S, 1 CB all graded euqually.
The only difference is that the 1st class has a 5 star QB (Andrew Luck, Matt Stafford, etc.) and the other class has 5 star punter as the 15th player.
Classes are ranked the same according to almost every service.....right?
I would argue the class with the QB is astronomically more likely to win than the other.