forums

Who has the edge per position?

WaterburyCane

WaterburyCane

Big Balls
Premium
Joined
Nov 23, 2011
Messages
5,246
My opinion going off of limited time watching FSU this year. I just cant stomach to watch much of them.

QB = FSU

RB = Miami

OL = Miami (if Flowers plays)

TE = Miami

WR = Im torn on this. I want to say Miami but the way Coley has played this season...and the way Rudolph has played for them, its closer than I want to believe. A push?

DL = FSU

LB = Miami.... are my orange and green glasses on or do I have some support on this? The cast around 52 has been looking really good since Gtech.

DB = Miami Im not high on FSU's backfield this year

K = FSU

Punter = not sure...its sad but I rarely see FSU punt in the few times Ive watched.

Coach = yeah right
 
Advertisement
WaterburyCane said:
My opinion going off of limited time watching FSU this year. I just cant stomach to watch much of them.

QB = FSU

RB = Miami

OL = Miami (if Flowers plays)

TE = Miami

WR = Im torn on this. I want to say Miami but the way Coley has played this season...and the way Rudolph has played for them, its closer than I want to believe. A push?

DL = FSU

LB = Miami.... are my orange and green glasses on or do I have some support on this? The cast around 52 has been looking really good since Gtech.

DB = Miami Im not high on FSU's backfield this year

K = FSU

Punter = not sure...its sad but I rarely see FSU punt in the few times Ive watched.

Coach = yeah right
Click to expand...

First half or second half?
 
Sorry, I'd take Greene, Rudolph, Wilson and Lane over PD, Waters, Coley and Lewis. It's close though.

TE is a push.

Agree with the rest.
 
You're crazy if you think our Secondary is better than Theirs is. Not even close.




WaterburyCane said:
My opinion going off of limited time watching FSU this year. I just cant stomach to watch much of them.

QB = FSU

RB = Miami

OL = Miami (if Flowers plays)

TE = Miami

WR = Im torn on this. I want to say Miami but the way Coley has played this season...and the way Rudolph has played for them, its closer than I want to believe. A push?

DL = FSU

LB = Miami.... are my orange and green glasses on or do I have some support on this? The cast around 52 has been looking really good since Gtech.

DB = Miami Im not high on FSU's backfield this year

K = FSU

Punter = not sure...its sad but I rarely see FSU punt in the few times Ive watched.

Coach = yeah right
Click to expand...
 
Surely you don't mean for this year. Greene is the only one who has produced outside of one game for Rudolph. I'll take our receivers this year over FSU. Granted I guess the same could be said for Dorsett but I think the difference is we havent had to rely on the Pass, so our guys arent getting too many looks as opposed to FSU needing the PASS to win and still all hinges on Greene.
TheU1984 said:
Sorry, I'd take Greene, Rudolph, Wilson and Lane over PD, Waters, Coley and Lewis. It's close though.

TE is a push.

Agree with the rest.
Click to expand...
 
Advertisement
QB - FSU (But Kayaa is right there with Jameis this year)
RB - Miami (by a wide margin)
WR - Push (Miami way more depth)
TE - Push
OL - Miami (by a wide margin this season idk how the ****)


DE - FSU
DT - FSU (By a VERY wide margin)
LB - Miami
CB - Push (Darby has underperformed this season)
S - FSU

KR - FSU
PR - Miami

K - FSU
P- Miami
 
You forgot one if not the most important position, coaching. Until last season Jimbo was an under achiever and fsu fans wanted him out the same way some fans want Golden out. Is time for Golden to earn his pay check and win the coaching battle.



:neonu:
 
TE is push (career stats for both our nearly identical and they both produce for their team) Walford has stepped it up this season.

DB is them unfortunately. Its close tho.
 
5Ringz said:
QB - FSU (But Kayaa is right there with Jameis this year)
RB - Miami (by a wide margin)
WR - Push (Miami way more depth)
TE - Push
OL - Miami (by a wide margin this season idk how the ****)


DE - FSU
DT - FSU (By a VERY wide margin)
LB - Miami
CB - Push (Darby has underperformed this season)
S - FSU

KR - FSU
PR - Miami

K - FSU
P- Miami
Click to expand...

WHo the **** returns punts for FSU where he cant beat out or atleast make it a push with Coley? Lol...
 
skyman said:
TE is push (career stats for both our nearly identical and they both produce for their team) Walford has stepped it up this season.

DB is them unfortunately. Its close tho.
Click to expand...

The TE one is arguable. Walford is a much better blocker which is a big part of that position which is why I gave him the edge...also O'Leary gets more targets per game so his numbers should be on par if not better than Walford's on paper.

Cant really argue with the DB thing...in the limited time Ive seen FSU, I wasnt impressed with their coverage or run support ability as in past years. Not saying they are garbage...Im sure most teams would trade their backfield for FSU's but when compared to ours, I like our unit as a whole a little better.
 
puertorricane said:
You forgot one if not the most important position, coaching. Until last season Jimbo was an under achiever and fsu fans wanted him out the same way some fans want Golden out. Is time for Golden to earn his pay check and win the coaching battle.



:neonu:
Click to expand...

Umm no

he had a 12-2 and 10-4 season right before. all he needed, like most top 15 teams, is a dynamic qb. fail!
 
Advertisement
AllAboutDaU said:
I would say their secondary is better.
Click to expand...

Safeties. Our corners are better. Our LBs are better. Their DL is better. Most importantly, Jimbo >>>>>>>>> Dorito

On offense,

QB = Push
RB = Miami
WR = Miami (but Greene is best)
TE = push
OL = Miami

Switch coaching staffs and Miami wins by 10
 
Last edited:
Back
Top