Who has the best QB in this game?

[Pimp Tight]

Our QB is having the better year. Theirs is much more accomplished. It's not that complicated.

WRONG


Their QB is having the better year.......JW WINS ALL OF HIS GAMES......Kaaya does not.

 

[supacane]

Yeah and rapist has to carry the team and we see what he does.

Yeah.....WIN.

Again, Punch yourself in the Jaw. When you fall down, kick yourself in the Jaw. Maybe those Nuts will fall out.

Ur a **** clown. We have el Foldo and No D. They have Jimbo and a team full of talent. And Kaaya still....still **** has better stats than a seasoned QB. A true FR who showed up two months before we played UL. Gtfoh

Lil Lady, WTF are you smoking? UM has talent too.

Kaaya is not in JW's class.

Ur a clown. True Fr hasn't even gone through 1 year in school. Rapist has had 3 years to learn Jimbo system and he's playing like crap. And not only has Brad played better overall, he has gotten better since the first few games struggles. Put the red ball on ur nose. Clown. No one is saying Byron Leftwich son didn't have a amazing year last year. I'm comparing him and Brad this season and Brad has played better. Rapist **** must be blinding you.

 

[drifters1234]

So based on this logic, Timmy Tebow is a better QB than Peyton Manning since Peyton never won a Heisman?

Tebow is absolutely one of the best college football QBs of all time. Urban Meyer's offense perfectly exploited his skill set, which is why Florida was unbelievably successful under Tebow's leadership. And given UF's success - as well as Tebow's individual awards - I do not see a compelling argument that that Manning was a better college football QB than Tebow.

****, UT won the national title the year AFTER Manning graduated. If Peyton were truly in the discussion of best college QBs of all time then UT should have had more success with him leading the team.

You are confusing team success with ondividual success. Heck tebow won the heisman with a four loss season. And teboe was a heck of a running back in college but not much of a QB.

I'm not confusing anything. Tebow was the undisputed leader of that team, and made play after play after play. He was literally unstoppable on his never-ending first down runs up the middle. And he did more than enough in the passing game.

You may characterize his role as that of a running back, but the record books don't. That was Urban Meyer's system, and it was perfectly suited for Tebow's skills.

I would be happy to have a running back as a QB at UM if it would deliver national titles.

Yet his team lost four games when he won the heisman which is more of a popularity contest nowadays. And didnt have one undefeated season during his career, something that a bunch of other QBs have been able to do.

"[P]opularity contest nowadays"? There is nothing new about who wins the Heisman. QBs are by far the highest percentage of winners, as they are the team leaders.

RBs are second, and a handful of exceptional WRs are in third.

As far as Tebow's stats, he was the SEC's all-time leader in passing efficiency and total rushing touchdowns. In the NCAA, he was 2nd and 10th in those categories.

 

[drifters1234]

So based on this logic, Timmy Tebow is a better QB than Peyton Manning since Peyton never won a Heisman?

Tebow is absolutely one of the best college football QBs of all time. Urban Meyer's offense perfectly exploited his skill set, which is why Florida was unbelievably successful under Tebow's leadership. And given UF's success - as well as Tebow's individual awards - I do not see a compelling argument that that Manning was a better college football QB than Tebow.

****, UT won the national title the year AFTER Manning graduated. If Peyton were truly in the discussion of best college QBs of all time then UT should have had more success with him leading the team.

You are confusing team success with ondividual success. Heck tebow won the heisman with a four loss season. And teboe was a heck of a running back in college but not much of a QB.

I'm not confusing anything. Tebow was the undisputed leader of that team, and made play after play after play. He was literally unstoppable on his never-ending first down runs up the middle. And he did more than enough in the passing game.

You may characterize his role as that of a running back, but the record books don't. That was Urban Meyer's system, and it was perfectly suited for Tebow's skills.

I would be happy to have a running back as a QB at UM if it would deliver national titles.

Yet his team lost four games when he won the heisman which is more of a popularity contest nowadays. And didnt have one undefeated season during his career, something that a bunch of other QBs have been able to do.

Undefeated like Winston, right?

 

[Pimp Tight]

..

 

[The Franchise]

The big dumb sociopath is like a zombie. Until someone finally kills him, he's the best in the game. He's always as good as his team needs him to be to win. If they have the ball last, and they're within a score they're going to win until I see otherwise.

You can pull stats until your balls atrophy even more, but what that big sociopathic mummy does in crunch time is immeasurable.

 

[Pimp Tight]

The big dumb sociopath is like a zombie. Until someone finally kills him, he's the best in the game. He's always as good as his team needs him to be to win. If they have the ball last, and they're within a score they're going to win until I see otherwise.

You can pull stats until your balls atrophy even more, but what that big sociopathic mummy does in crunch time is immeasurable.

JW: "I'ma Make It Do What It Do"

Can't Knock or Hate the Hustle.........only haters do that.

 

[The Franchise]

The big dumb sociopath is like a zombie. Until someone finally kills him, he's the best in the game. He's always as good as his team needs him to be to win. If they have the ball last, and they're within a score they're going to win until I see otherwise.

You can pull stats until your balls atrophy even more, but what that big sociopathic mummy does in crunch time is immeasurable.

JW: "I'ma Make It Do What It Do"

Can't Knock or Hate the Hustle.........only haters do that.

Clearly, his stats aren't what they were last year, but ask 1000 astute football guys who they'd rather go into a championship game with RIGHT NOW at QB (because that was OP's original hypothetical), and every one of them would take Jemima over Kaaya.

 

[Pimp Tight]

The big dumb sociopath is like a zombie. Until someone finally kills him, he's the best in the game. He's always as good as his team needs him to be to win. If they have the ball last, and they're within a score they're going to win until I see otherwise.

You can pull stats until your balls atrophy even more, but what that big sociopathic mummy does in crunch time is immeasurable.

JW: "I'ma Make It Do What It Do"

Can't Knock or Hate the Hustle.........only haters do that.

Clearly, his stats aren't what they were last year, but ask 1000 astute football guys who they'd rather go into a championship game with RIGHT NOW at QB (because that was OP's original hypothetical), and every one of them would take Jemima over Kaaya.

NO DOUBT.....

 

[rickay]

The Team with the Better Coaches.

Go ahead.....I dare you!

AY I'm no Donofrio supporter and Jimbo is the best second half adjustment coach in the nation. I'm not saying that, I'm trying to start the coversation that this kid is exceeding everyone's expectations (even those that said he is the bet we had since Dorsey) and on paper right now is better than Jameis.

Kaaya is not better than JW in his dreams. Stop Tripping. Yeah, we beat three Campbell's Tomato Soup Cans. Duke was the horse, NOT Kaaya.

Look at those numbers carefully. Keep in mind that JW missed a game. Completion %? Competition?

So you're cherry picking? That missed game makes his conference leading 11 interceptions far worse. Even more so that his missed game was against Clemson so they didn't have an opportunity to pick him.

You are missing the point.

Even with a missed game, JW has more passing attempts and Completions....HIGHER COMPLETION PERCENTAGE....MORE YARDS

Again, in less games.

If you are going to Compare them, COMPARE THEM.

JW CARRIED his team to victories over tough opponents. Kaaya did not do that.

Don't pull the freshman card now. YOU COMPARED THEM.....

When was the freshman card pulled? Also FSU leads the ACC in pass per downs so that has something to do with his yardage...give me more Tuchdowns and less Turnovers all day.

 

[CaniacMike21]

Our QB is having the better year. Theirs is much more accomplished. It's not that complicated.

WRONG


Their QB is having the better year.......JW WINS ALL OF HIS GAMES......Kaaya does not.

There seems to be some confusion. I wasn't talking about which team was having the better year. Just which QB was having the better year.

 

[demcanes26]

I don't really care who people think is better. What I do know is if Brad Kaaya throws two or three touchdowns, and Miami wins the game, Brad Kaaya will be first team all ACC. And no one on this board saw that happening before the season.

 

[Pimp Tight]

Our QB is having the better year. Theirs is much more accomplished. It's not that complicated.

WRONG


Their QB is having the better year.......JW WINS ALL OF HIS GAMES......Kaaya does not.

There seems to be some confusion. I wasn't talking about which team was having the better year. Just which QB was having the better year.

JW is having the better year.