Who do you think is better Malachi Toney or De’Anthony Thomas (Oregon. Ducks)?

[CityboyCanes4life82]

When I think of Freshman impact, this comparison comes to mind. What are you thoughts on who was the better Freshman?

 

[Go Canes!!]

I’ll take Toney against the field.

 

[CityboyCanes4life82]

I’ll take Toney against the field.

Me to. I think Chip used Thomas better. We didn’t really get that towards the end of the season with Malachi

 

[Carolinacane83]

10 Nickname is Baby Jesus…do the math

 

[TooColdToHold]

Sammy Watkins is another one that was an immediate impact player as a freshman.

 

[StPeteCane]

Toney >

 

[Go Canes!!]

 

[TheOriginalCane]

When I think of Freshman impact, this comparison comes to mind. What are you thoughts on who was the better Freshman?

 

[Travis Bickle]

His face should be the entry for "football player" in any dictionary. What a joy it was to watch him play this year. Hoping for more great stuff in the next 2-3 years!

 

[Madabs]

Does a Black Mamba constrict?

 

[jed2410]

Considering Malachi doesn't have the 4.3 speed that Thomas has, I'd consider what Malachi has done more impressive at his size and speed

 

[ThomasM]

Didn't even mention his beastly blocking.

 

[skyman]

Didn't even mention his beastly blocking.

In full video he mentioned multiple times

 

[jsy]

only freshman WR that i would take over toney is J Smith
otherwise hes baby jesus for a reason

 

[Sandman211]

#10 on next year's cover of NCAA!!! Why not?

I know, I know... that's a long shot, but hey...

 

[Dark Cane]

only freshman WR that i would take over toney is J Smith
otherwise hes baby jesus for a reason

Baby Jesus >>> Jeremiah Smith

 

[skyman]

#10 on next year's cover of NCAA!!! Why not?

I know, I know... that's a long shot, but hey...

After playoff run and introduction to nation its very possible..

 

[Samson Doyo]

Toney an all around football player. DeAnthony Thomas was fast, really F’ing fast but that was it. Toney much better and not close. My $0.02.

Go Canes!