Being that I’ve been disabled my whole life no never played but worked in mlb for three years. Yes, he lacks feel and his recruiting profile for pitchers is awful
A *PRIME* example of his lack of Feel was on display at the game in Raleigh this past Saturday night.
Top 8, down 8-7. We load the bases with 2 out. Striding to the plate, Alex Sosa. Former NC State Wolfpuppy, coming into that AB with 3 K's and a walk. He's your DH, mind you. Didn't really look that great in any of the AB's. Crowd was rowdy every time he came to bat.
At some point - a guy is feeling the pressure. You've got to feel that for him as a manager (I know I did just sitting in the stands). 3 K's, he's pressing, wanting a big moment versus his former team.
As the leader and manager, sometimes you've got to look at a kid and say - hey, let's give someone else a shot, today's just not your day. You're important for us, but time to let someone else take some cuts and hopefully come through for us.
Dubovik is sitting *RIGHT THERE*. You need a big hit, he's probably the best stick you have on the bench. Right-handed DH, same for same. You lose *nothing* at all making that switch, and who knows...Dubovik might strike out, he might get out some other way. But if you read the ******* room...someone else not named Alex Sosa needs to take that AB. It was late, the game was tight, and that AB was super important. Yes - you're trusting it to a Freshman, but given the context, I trust him more at that point than Sosa.
JD did not feel that...or if he did, he didn't act on that, or let one of his assistants or Sosa talk him out of it. Any of that is damning in and of itself in my eyes. If I can feel it, and the whole stadium can feel it, and you can't act on it...woof.
Sosa promptly grounds out to 2nd on the first pitch he sees. Then NC State hits a Grand Slam in the bottom of the 8th and puts us out of our misery and make it all acadmic anyways...so it may not have mattered.
But these small moments add up, and are indicative of why JD just doesn't have it...that is, if you're paying attention and not busy shining his shoes up.