Watching the game now...

AutoCANE

All the pieces matter.
Premium
Joined
Nov 5, 2011
Messages
4,434
OK so I was at the game yesterday and I wasn't sure that I was able to process all of the bad. So I thought, what the **** I'll watch the game even though I'm sure it will be painful. A couple quick observations (I just got to the point where Evan was brought in):

1. Rosier was worse than I thought. There were some really, really, really poorly thrown balls yesterday. They were playing single high a lot and bringing a lot of heat, and our WR's were more open than I even realized. Richards should have had 200+ yards receiving in this game. He was torching #14 man to man every single snap he was on the field. At least four long TD passes were missed that shouldn't have really been that hard to complete. Two to Jeff Thomas and two to Ahmmon Richards. Awful, just awful misses. And missing on bubble screens is so egregious it shouldn't ever happen. If we're not going to have a run game, we have to at least be able to hit the bubble when they're giving it to us and use that as our run game.

2. Speaking of run game - please, for the love of God stop with the false narrative that Pitt was stacking the box trying to shut down our run game. They played nickel almost the entire game with 6 guys in the box. Sometimes they would send extra guys, but in most instances those were obvious passing downs and it was a true blitz rather than run blitz. Flat out, our OL got whipped, play after play after play. Our horizontal run game did not work against them. They set edge contain well and stretched our run game sideline to sideline. Homer had no holes to run through whatsoever. The jet motion counter that we ran to open the second half didn't work either, but we certainly should have gone to it more to try to get something going. There are multiple options you can run out of that and maybe something would have hit for a big play.

3. Berrios didn't have a great game. Rosier wasn't it making it easy on him but there were at least two, possibly three plays that he usually makes that he flat out didn't yesterday. If Rosier threw dimes I'm sure he would have caught them but it seems "meh" was contagious amongst our guys yesterday.

4. The decision to bring Sherrifs in was one of the worst coaching decisions I have ever seen. Right up there with the onside kick against Georgia Tech. ****, on the onside kick at least it would have been successful if we executed it properly. This had zero ******* chance of being successful. Evan was put in a terrible spot, on the road, completely cold, and Malik didn't even look like he gave a ****. Maybe he will after it sinks in, but my lord at that point in the game we have to put some first downs together. The defense had just gotten two three and out stops and was doing everything they could to keep us in the game.

5. Defensively, those guys played their asses off and did enough to get us out of there with a W. There were some bad instances, giving up long 3rd downs that make you want to smash something, but for the most part they did what they had to do. It was definitely annoying how that QB kept falling forward though. Got positive yards on a few plays that should have gone for losses. Can't explain that one. All that said - our blitzes were poorly timed, and were of Manny's favorite overload chaos variety. We didn't get home...and it gave their QB lanes to scoot around. Stunting and overload blitzing shouldn't have been part of the game plan here, but it is the foundation of what we do, so you have to take the good with the bad I suppose.


Man. I hope we can shake the stink off of this one quickly and come out pumped and ready to play against Clemson. This has been an incredible season, and I would really hate to see it end with such a whimper. A win and we're in the playoff. Never thought I would be saying that earlier this year but here we are.
 
Advertisement
One of the worst calls, ever? I guess you missed the Golden/Shannon Era's. Not a bad call, timing should have been in the 2nd quarter. Sometimes a QB needs to watch for a few minutes an reset. I'm guessing a physical issue with Rosier. You were at the game and he took a hard hit in the 2nd Qtr. when he didin't slide and was driven into the ground on his throwing shoulder. Tough guy, surprised he didn't come out of the game at that point.


OK so I was at the game yesterday and I wasn't sure that I was able to process all of the bad. So I thought, what the **** I'll watch the game even though I'm sure it will be painful. A couple quick observations (I just got to the point where Evan was brought in):

1. Rosier was worse than I thought. There were some really, really, really poorly thrown balls yesterday. They were playing single high a lot and bringing a lot of heat, and our WR's were more open than I even realized. Richards should have had 200+ yards receiving in this game. He was torching #14 man to man every single snap he was on the field. At least four long TD passes were missed that shouldn't have really been that hard to complete. Two to Jeff Thomas and two to Ahmmon Richards. Awful, just awful misses. And missing on bubble screens is so egregious it shouldn't ever happen. If we're not going to have a run game, we have to at least be able to hit the bubble when they're giving it to us and use that as our run game.

2. Speaking of run game - please, for the love of God stop with the false narrative that Pitt was stacking the box trying to shut down our run game. They played nickel almost the entire game with 6 guys in the box. Sometimes they would send extra guys, but in most instances those were obvious passing downs and it was a true blitz rather than run blitz. Flat out, our OL got whipped, play after play after play. Our horizontal run game did not work against them. They set edge contain well and stretched our run game sideline to sideline. Homer had no holes to run through whatsoever. The jet motion counter that we ran to open the second half didn't work either, but we certainly should have gone to it more to try to get something going. There are multiple options you can run out of that and maybe something would have hit for a big play.

3. Berrios didn't have a great game. Rosier wasn't it making it easy on him but there were at least two, possibly three plays that he usually makes that he flat out didn't yesterday. If Rosier threw dimes I'm sure he would have caught them but it seems "meh" was contagious amongst our guys yesterday.

4. The decision to bring Sherrifs in was one of the worst coaching decisions I have ever seen. Right up there with the onside kick against Georgia Tech. ****, on the onside kick at least it would have been successful if we executed it properly. This had zero ****ing chance of being successful. Evan was put in a terrible spot, on the road, completely cold, and Malik didn't even look like he gave a ****. Maybe he will after it sinks in, but my lord at that point in the game we have to put some first downs together. The defense had just gotten two three and out stops and was doing everything they could to keep us in the game.

5. Defensively, those guys played their asses off and did enough to get us out of there with a W. There were some bad instances, giving up long 3rd downs that make you want to smash something, but for the most part they did what they had to do. It was definitely annoying how that QB kept falling forward though. Got positive yards on a few plays that should have gone for losses. Can't explain that one. All that said - our blitzes were poorly timed, and were of Manny's favorite overload chaos variety. We didn't get home...and it gave their QB lanes to scoot around. Stunting and overload blitzing shouldn't have been part of the game plan here, but it is the foundation of what we do, so you have to take the good with the bad I suppose.


Man. I hope we can shake the stink off of this one quickly and come out pumped and ready to play against Clemson. This has been an incredible season, and I would really hate to see it end with such a whimper. A win and we're in the playoff. Never thought I would be saying that earlier this year but here we are.
 
One of the worst calls, ever? I guess you missed the Golden/Shannon Era's. Not a bad call, timing should have been in the 2nd quarter. Sometimes a QB needs to watch for a few minutes an reset. I'm guessing a physical issue with Rosier. You were at the game and he took a hard hit in the 2nd Qtr. when he didin't slide and was driven into the ground on his throwing shoulder. Tough guy, surprised he didn't come out of the game at that point.


OK so I was at the game yesterday and I wasn't sure that I was able to process all of the bad. So I thought, what the **** I'll watch the game even though I'm sure it will be painful. A couple quick observations (I just got to the point where Evan was brought in):

1. Rosier was worse than I thought. There were some really, really, really poorly thrown balls yesterday. They were playing single high a lot and bringing a lot of heat, and our WR's were more open than I even realized. Richards should have had 200+ yards receiving in this game. He was torching #14 man to man every single snap he was on the field. At least four long TD passes were missed that shouldn't have really been that hard to complete. Two to Jeff Thomas and two to Ahmmon Richards. Awful, just awful misses. And missing on bubble screens is so egregious it shouldn't ever happen. If we're not going to have a run game, we have to at least be able to hit the bubble when they're giving it to us and use that as our run game.

2. Speaking of run game - please, for the love of God stop with the false narrative that Pitt was stacking the box trying to shut down our run game. They played nickel almost the entire game with 6 guys in the box. Sometimes they would send extra guys, but in most instances those were obvious passing downs and it was a true blitz rather than run blitz. Flat out, our OL got whipped, play after play after play. Our horizontal run game did not work against them. They set edge contain well and stretched our run game sideline to sideline. Homer had no holes to run through whatsoever. The jet motion counter that we ran to open the second half didn't work either, but we certainly should have gone to it more to try to get something going. There are multiple options you can run out of that and maybe something would have hit for a big play.

3. Berrios didn't have a great game. Rosier wasn't it making it easy on him but there were at least two, possibly three plays that he usually makes that he flat out didn't yesterday. If Rosier threw dimes I'm sure he would have caught them but it seems "meh" was contagious amongst our guys yesterday.

4. The decision to bring Sherrifs in was one of the worst coaching decisions I have ever seen. Right up there with the onside kick against Georgia Tech. ****, on the onside kick at least it would have been successful if we executed it properly. This had zero ****ing chance of being successful. Evan was put in a terrible spot, on the road, completely cold, and Malik didn't even look like he gave a ****. Maybe he will after it sinks in, but my lord at that point in the game we have to put some first downs together. The defense had just gotten two three and out stops and was doing everything they could to keep us in the game.

5. Defensively, those guys played their asses off and did enough to get us out of there with a W. There were some bad instances, giving up long 3rd downs that make you want to smash something, but for the most part they did what they had to do. It was definitely annoying how that QB kept falling forward though. Got positive yards on a few plays that should have gone for losses. Can't explain that one. All that said - our blitzes were poorly timed, and were of Manny's favorite overload chaos variety. We didn't get home...and it gave their QB lanes to scoot around. Stunting and overload blitzing shouldn't have been part of the game plan here, but it is the foundation of what we do, so you have to take the good with the bad I suppose.


Man. I hope we can shake the stink off of this one quickly and come out pumped and ready to play against Clemson. This has been an incredible season, and I would really hate to see it end with such a whimper. A win and we're in the playoff. Never thought I would be saying that earlier this year but here we are.

Agreed. Earlier in the game would have made more sense. Earlier in the season as well. There were so many games Rosier just seemed to sleepwalk through all season, and it was just a matter of time before it caught up to him.

Here's looking forward to an open QB competition in 2018. If Rosier wins the job, so be it. At least he'll know he has to focus every **** game.
 
The Sherieffs call was bad. We had momentum after Berrios return and it crushed all of that. I don't agree with the call, understand what he was trying to do but still don't agree.
 
If Shireffs hits a few passes people would be saying great move. We haven't seen him get much of a chance and rightfully so. He isnt mobile and has a weaker arm than Rosier. But Richt knew Rosier was zoned out. He had to do something.
 
Should have done it out of the half. Would have woken Rosier up and given Evan time to get mentally prepared.
 
So you're saying Malik didn't care and he was terrible, and yet it was horrible he got pulled?

Double negatives don't make a positive bro....
 
Both times I’ve seen sherieffs play, it wasn’t good.

Kinda reminds me of a kicker trying to play QB because the third string QB just got injured.
 
Advertisement
One of the worst calls, ever? I guess you missed the Golden/Shannon Era's. Not a bad call, timing should have been in the 2nd quarter. Sometimes a QB needs to watch for a few minutes an reset. I'm guessing a physical issue with Rosier. You were at the game and he took a hard hit in the 2nd Qtr. when he didin't slide and was driven into the ground on his throwing shoulder. Tough guy, surprised he didn't come out of the game at that point.


OK so I was at the game yesterday and I wasn't sure that I was able to process all of the bad. So I thought, what the **** I'll watch the game even though I'm sure it will be painful. A couple quick observations (I just got to the point where Evan was brought in):

1. Rosier was worse than I thought. There were some really, really, really poorly thrown balls yesterday. They were playing single high a lot and bringing a lot of heat, and our WR's were more open than I even realized. Richards should have had 200+ yards receiving in this game. He was torching #14 man to man every single snap he was on the field. At least four long TD passes were missed that shouldn't have really been that hard to complete. Two to Jeff Thomas and two to Ahmmon Richards. Awful, just awful misses. And missing on bubble screens is so egregious it shouldn't ever happen. If we're not going to have a run game, we have to at least be able to hit the bubble when they're giving it to us and use that as our run game.

2. Speaking of run game - please, for the love of God stop with the false narrative that Pitt was stacking the box trying to shut down our run game. They played nickel almost the entire game with 6 guys in the box. Sometimes they would send extra guys, but in most instances those were obvious passing downs and it was a true blitz rather than run blitz. Flat out, our OL got whipped, play after play after play. Our horizontal run game did not work against them. They set edge contain well and stretched our run game sideline to sideline. Homer had no holes to run through whatsoever. The jet motion counter that we ran to open the second half didn't work either, but we certainly should have gone to it more to try to get something going. There are multiple options you can run out of that and maybe something would have hit for a big play.

3. Berrios didn't have a great game. Rosier wasn't it making it easy on him but there were at least two, possibly three plays that he usually makes that he flat out didn't yesterday. If Rosier threw dimes I'm sure he would have caught them but it seems "meh" was contagious amongst our guys yesterday.

4. The decision to bring Sherrifs in was one of the worst coaching decisions I have ever seen. Right up there with the onside kick against Georgia Tech. ****, on the onside kick at least it would have been successful if we executed it properly. This had zero ****ing chance of being successful. Evan was put in a terrible spot, on the road, completely cold, and Malik didn't even look like he gave a ****. Maybe he will after it sinks in, but my lord at that point in the game we have to put some first downs together. The defense had just gotten two three and out stops and was doing everything they could to keep us in the game.

5. Defensively, those guys played their asses off and did enough to get us out of there with a W. There were some bad instances, giving up long 3rd downs that make you want to smash something, but for the most part they did what they had to do. It was definitely annoying how that QB kept falling forward though. Got positive yards on a few plays that should have gone for losses. Can't explain that one. All that said - our blitzes were poorly timed, and were of Manny's favorite overload chaos variety. We didn't get home...and it gave their QB lanes to scoot around. Stunting and overload blitzing shouldn't have been part of the game plan here, but it is the foundation of what we do, so you have to take the good with the bad I suppose.


Man. I hope we can shake the stink off of this one quickly and come out pumped and ready to play against Clemson. This has been an incredible season, and I would really hate to see it end with such a whimper. A win and we're in the playoff. Never thought I would be saying that earlier this year but here we are.

Agreed. Earlier in the game would have made more sense. Earlier in the season as well. There were so many games Rosier just seemed to sleepwalk through all season, and it was just a matter of time before it caught up to him.

Here's looking forward to an open QB competition in 2018. If Rosier wins the job, so be it. At least he'll know he has to focus every **** game.

The timing is exactly why the move was so egregious. I have no issue with the thought of pulling the guy if you want to send a message - however, if Richt sensed that Malik was just going through the motions, you don't wait until the most important possession of the game to make that decision. Maybe I would have done it on the second possession of the second half, I don't know, but at that time in the game, considering where we stood on the season, the move was just unthinkable IMO.
 
If Shireffs hits a few passes people would be saying great move. We haven't seen him get much of a chance and rightfully so. He isnt mobile and has a weaker arm than Rosier. But Richt knew Rosier was zoned out. He had to do something.

Except people who have played with him say he's mobile. Also, arm strength is not why Rosier wasn't completing passes. For all the talk about arm strength, people tend to forget about touch and accuracy, until a loss comes. Arm strength didn't do us a lot of good yesterday, but a lack of accuracy and touch was a killer.
 
One of the worst calls, ever? I guess you missed the Golden/Shannon Era's. Not a bad call, timing should have been in the 2nd quarter. Sometimes a QB needs to watch for a few minutes an reset. I'm guessing a physical issue with Rosier. You were at the game and he took a hard hit in the 2nd Qtr. when he didin't slide and was driven into the ground on his throwing shoulder. Tough guy, surprised he didn't come out of the game at that point.


OK so I was at the game yesterday and I wasn't sure that I was able to process all of the bad. So I thought, what the **** I'll watch the game even though I'm sure it will be painful. A couple quick observations (I just got to the point where Evan was brought in):

1. Rosier was worse than I thought. There were some really, really, really poorly thrown balls yesterday. They were playing single high a lot and bringing a lot of heat, and our WR's were more open than I even realized. Richards should have had 200+ yards receiving in this game. He was torching #14 man to man every single snap he was on the field. At least four long TD passes were missed that shouldn't have really been that hard to complete. Two to Jeff Thomas and two to Ahmmon Richards. Awful, just awful misses. And missing on bubble screens is so egregious it shouldn't ever happen. If we're not going to have a run game, we have to at least be able to hit the bubble when they're giving it to us and use that as our run game.

2. Speaking of run game - please, for the love of God stop with the false narrative that Pitt was stacking the box trying to shut down our run game. They played nickel almost the entire game with 6 guys in the box. Sometimes they would send extra guys, but in most instances those were obvious passing downs and it was a true blitz rather than run blitz. Flat out, our OL got whipped, play after play after play. Our horizontal run game did not work against them. They set edge contain well and stretched our run game sideline to sideline. Homer had no holes to run through whatsoever. The jet motion counter that we ran to open the second half didn't work either, but we certainly should have gone to it more to try to get something going. There are multiple options you can run out of that and maybe something would have hit for a big play.

3. Berrios didn't have a great game. Rosier wasn't it making it easy on him but there were at least two, possibly three plays that he usually makes that he flat out didn't yesterday. If Rosier threw dimes I'm sure he would have caught them but it seems "meh" was contagious amongst our guys yesterday.

4. The decision to bring Sherrifs in was one of the worst coaching decisions I have ever seen. Right up there with the onside kick against Georgia Tech. ****, on the onside kick at least it would have been successful if we executed it properly. This had zero ****ing chance of being successful. Evan was put in a terrible spot, on the road, completely cold, and Malik didn't even look like he gave a ****. Maybe he will after it sinks in, but my lord at that point in the game we have to put some first downs together. The defense had just gotten two three and out stops and was doing everything they could to keep us in the game.

5. Defensively, those guys played their asses off and did enough to get us out of there with a W. There were some bad instances, giving up long 3rd downs that make you want to smash something, but for the most part they did what they had to do. It was definitely annoying how that QB kept falling forward though. Got positive yards on a few plays that should have gone for losses. Can't explain that one. All that said - our blitzes were poorly timed, and were of Manny's favorite overload chaos variety. We didn't get home...and it gave their QB lanes to scoot around. Stunting and overload blitzing shouldn't have been part of the game plan here, but it is the foundation of what we do, so you have to take the good with the bad I suppose.


Man. I hope we can shake the stink off of this one quickly and come out pumped and ready to play against Clemson. This has been an incredible season, and I would really hate to see it end with such a whimper. A win and we're in the playoff. Never thought I would be saying that earlier this year but here we are.

Agreed. Earlier in the game would have made more sense. Earlier in the season as well. There were so many games Rosier just seemed to sleepwalk through all season, and it was just a matter of time before it caught up to him.

Here's looking forward to an open QB competition in 2018. If Rosier wins the job, so be it. At least he'll know he has to focus every **** game.

The timing is exactly why the move was so egregious. I have no issue with the thought of pulling the guy if you want to send a message - however, if Richt sensed that Malik was just going through the motions, you don't wait until the most important possession of the game to make that decision. Maybe I would have done it on the second possession of the second half, I don't know, but at that time in the game, considering where we stood on the season, the move was just unthinkable IMO.

Can't really disagree with this. In my humble opinion it should have happened much earlier in the season. However, we were winning so it's hard to argue with Richt's decisions. It was a damned if you do, damned if you don't situation, really. I just hope we can get enough talent at the position that whomever wins the job is talented enough to lead us to championships.
 
Advertisement
Great post. I agree with everything you said

Richt needs to scrap that sweep play out of the shotgun. I don’t recall it ever working
 
And why not try the Wildcat with DJ back there?

This would have been a better option imo

How is wildcat gonna work if ya can't run block?

DJ can make plays with his athleticism that sherieefs can not. Simple.

Run blocking sir. If ya can't run block, wildcat is utterly useless.

It's cool to say wildcat whenever questioning a HC or OC tho......so carry on.
 
And why not try the Wildcat with DJ back there?

This would have been a better option imo

How is wildcat gonna work if ya can't run block?

DJ can make plays with his athleticism that sherieefs can not. Simple.

Run blocking sir. If ya can't run block, wildcat is utterly useless.

It's cool to say wildcat whenever questioning a HC or OC tho......so carry on.

If your defending sherieefs ok cool. But the kid hasn’t shown he can pass or run. So, if the play breaks down (as it did) sherieefs looks like a fish out of water. DJ could make something happen and not just flop. That’s all I’m saying
 
Back
Top