Walk me through the flag that was picked up for PI Brevin Jordan and the comment from Herbstriet about no contact being made

[Garnacho]

How can one watch that and honestly say no contact was made?

Back Judged vetoed Field Judge’s flag. I was told he can do this if the play involves a tight end. If it was a WR the pass was thrown to, that flag stands

 

[bacane]

How can one watch that and honestly say no contact was made?

Back Judged vetoed Field Judge’s flag. I was told he can do this if the play involves a tight end. If it was a WR the pass was thrown to, that flag stands

Would like to hear others weigh in on call. Thought Herbstreit went out of his way defending the reversal. My eyes definitely saw contact, but maybe I only saw it through the lens of a Cane.

 

[Fluffhead]

How can one watch that and honestly say no contact was made?

Back Judged vetoed Field Judge’s flag. I was told he can do this if the play involves a tight end. If it was a WR the pass was thrown to, that flag stands

I don’t know the veto or not but what I do feel confident about is if they did not just have two penalties called for blatant PI, this one would have stood. I think the refs picked it up solely because of that, which is ridiculous.

 

[PhenomCane]

Glenn Sharpe got flagged for less in the '03 Fiesta Bowl.

 

[For_The_U]

Glenn Sharpe got flagged for less in the '03 Fiesta Bowl.

Lol I had exact same thought at that moment last night too

 

[zeeblet01]

Them picking it up is not the problem to me, them doing so after the horrendous calls on Finley and Blades earlier in the game is a problem. Both #30 and #7 had less contact. If you set a standard that you are calling those calls, then call them.

 

[For_The_U]

We're talking about a potential third straight PI in a row to keep a final winning drive alive. Let's move on from this and focus on the real reasons we lost last night.

 

[jjacks93]

I don’t know the veto or not but what I do feel confident about is if they did not just have two penalties called for blatant PI, this one would have stood. I think the refs picked it up solely because of that, which is ridiculous.

I had that feeling too . It’s almost like they just picked it up cuz it would’ve been the 3rd in a row

 

[CaneFanWNY]

If blades and Finley's PI's were called as such. That **** sure should have been too.

Refs dictating our games whenever they're given the opportunity, per usual

 

[DPCane]

Them picking it up is not the problem to me, them doing so after the horrendous calls on Finley and Blades earlier in the game is a problem. Both #30 and #7 had less contact. If you set a standard that you are calling those calls, then call them.

Same. Tbh I really didn’t think it was PI, but if you hit Blades and Finley with phantom calls then the same should be applied throughout the game.

 

[native]

Right in Brevins hands, gotta make that catch.

 

[24/7canes]

Not only was there contact but Jordan was help around the 5 yard line. You could see his jersey get pulled. Either way something should have been called. The refs must of got a call at halftime because we got taken to the wood shed by them.

 

[bacane]

Agree with the three in a row and officials subconsciously not wanting to impact the game. Problem is, it's pass interference or it's not.

 

[zeeblet01]

Not only was there contact but Jordan was help around the 5 yard line. You could see his jersey get pulled. Either way something should have been called. The refs must of got a call at halftime because we got taken to the wood shed by them.

That's the big one to me. I do not know if there is defensive holding in college but if there is that should have been called, if not DPI should have. As the ball got close it was less egregious

 

[emrok]

We're talking about a potential third straight PI in a row to keep a final winning drive alive. Let's move on from this and focus on the real reasons we lost last night.

If PI doesn't matter if you do it 3x in a row we should start having our DBs and LBs doing it on every play.

 

[For_The_U]

If PI doesn't matter if you do it 3x in a row we should start having our DBs and LBs doing it on every play.

You obviously didn't understand my overriding point.

 

[CanesAreAble]

That wasn’t PI.

The thing that stood out to me, though, was the ball placement by Jarren. He threw a dime.

That could’ve been caught.

If Brevin had come down with it, that play goes down in Miami lore.

 

[#1cane]

We're talking about a potential third straight PI in a row to keep a final winning drive alive. Let's move on from this and focus on the real reasons we lost last night.

I know Mallory got hit in the head at the 5 yard line also that same drive and it was not called. Mallory's arms went up the second he did not catch the ball.

 

[CaneFanWNY]

That wasn’t PI.

The thing that stood out to me, though, was the ball placement by Jarren. He threw a dime.

That could’ve been caught.

If Brevin had come down with it, that play goes down in Miami lore.

I was honestly completely shocked he didnt come down with it with the night he was having. When the replay hit my heart felt like it sunk and I turned my tv off.

I think we're in good hands with jarren though for sure. 11 more opponents in the regular season to hopefully take last night's frustrations out on..

 

[Angry Ibis]

I know Mallory got hit in the head at the 5 yard line also that same drive and it was not called. Mallory's arms went up the second he did not catch the ball.

Correct