Ty Simpson Injury - Baga hiding something?

[ddann]

If you apply "FSU rule" AS THEY SHOULD...

- Bama probably out
- Ole Miss absolutely out
- Indiana out now?

Why would Indiana be out?

 

[NBCOwnsUs]

The committee can only consider injuries if they can actually measure it - how the team looked with and without the player. If he got hurt against Georgia, they can’t project how they’d look with a backup, so they can’t use it against them. That's my undersstanding, and I'm sure that's exactly waht they would have used to justify keeping them in.

They got destroyed and didn't move a spot, and the good reason was to judge ND and Miami H2H. I think that's a load of **** - they could have compared ND and Miami H2H regardless of where they put bama, and Miami could hvae been justified at 9 no different than 10.

I think they left bama at 9 b/c it increases the odds of four SEC teams in the quarters. Setting up a first round with Miami vs AnM instead of Miami vs OK boosts those chances.

 

[Empirical Cane]

Why would Indiana be out?

Star DL injured

 

[NC_Canes_11]

Deboer to Michigan would make sense if this is the case. If he loses to OU again, after not making the playoff last year, they’ll be calling for his job.

 

[ddann]

Star DL injured

Is he that big of a deal? I mean, it’s not like Mendoza is out.

 

[90scane]

I had a herniated disc back in August and I’ve never experienced so much pain in my life. I literally couldn’t walk for 1-2 days and I was literally living on the couch for 5-6 days. Brutal.

did you have surgery?

 

[90scane]

Is he that big of a deal? I mean, it’s not like Mendoza is out.

5.5 sacks I believe. Likely NFL late rounder.

 

[Alex_Dynamix]

He’s going to play guys

 

[aelmiami]

UGA hid the Beck injury last year, too, until the final rankings came out. It’s scummy behavior, for sure.

Biggest difference was UGA was in regardless from beating Texas. Definitely would’ve impacted where they were seeded.

 

[aelmiami]

If you apply "FSU rule" AS THEY SHOULD...

- Bama probably out
- Ole Miss absolutely out
- Indiana out now?

But IU won the BIG 10 Championship. I would get dropping them but you can’t drop a champion.

Simpson seems off. He missed a ton of throws. By a lot. The one that comes to mind is that 4th down he wasn’t even close on that out pattern. Seemed like he couldn’t drive the ball. I’m not saying he should’ve completed it. But he was off by close to 10 feet.

 

[TRick72]

I had a herniated disc back in August and I’ve never experienced so much pain in my life. I literally couldn’t walk for 1-2 days and I was literally living on the couch for 5-6 days. Brutal.

I have a perfectly healthy back but still subscribe to this treatment protocol

 

[CityboyCanes4life82]

This has been gaining steam....
It may not be true, but if it is and Baga hid Simpon's injury, the Domers would have a real reason to be angry. Would the CFP Committee had let Baga in if Ty Simpson were going to be out?

View attachment 346544

Bama schedule and wins were way better than Notre Dame. Notre Dame needs to go sit down

 

[CityboyCanes4life82]

UGA hid the Beck injury last year, too, until the final rankings came out. It’s scummy behavior, for sure.

I don’t see any issues with it. Players getting hurt is not a reason a team should be robbed of the playoffs. F the committee for even doing that in the first place.

 

[CityboyCanes4life82]

If it had come out prior to Selection Sunday that Bama had been hiding this injury, the Committee might have had an excuse to toss Bama, much as they would not have wanted to, NOT because of the injury itself, but because Bama had tried to deceive the Committee.

It's conceivable they could still take action, but since ND's leadership have acted ignobly, to put it mildly, since Selection Sunday, Bama is safe.

You don’t punish a school for an injury. That’s crazy. Ohio State won a chip with a backup

 

[Fly1]

You don’t punish a school for an injury. That’s crazy. Ohio State won a chip with a backup

Who was the backup?

 

[Canesfan1899]

It’s the $EC, it just means more

 

[AUcane]

did you have surgery?

No, wasn’t really on the table. Just had the steroid ****tail injection.

 

[WesternMDCane]

Deboer to Michigan would make sense if this is the case. If he loses to OU again, after not making the playoff last year, they’ll be calling for his job.

Kiffin already has that job locked up