Jimmy Johnson took over at UM the year after a national championship. Richt inherited the Al Golden/NCAA cloud show. Still, Jimmy lost 5 games his first year and lost 2 in his second. Even in year 3 with an amazing collection of talent and a Heisman QB, he lost "the big one." But JJ is rightly thought of with reverence here. So for Richt, these next 2 games won't say much about whether he can win the big one, and they certainly won't determine where this program is going to be 2-3 years from now. That's Richt's job - to build the foundation so that this program is ready to win the big one without it being some kind of crazy upset. Anything big we win in the meantime is pure joy our fans ought to bask in, but the real goal is to get to a different place than where we are now.
And some here say older folks (with knowledge of the history of this program) shouldn't be on this message board. Money post!
That is all well and good........Lets define the "Big One" versus "Fair Expectations"...... The "Al Golden/NCAA cloud" can't be a catch all excuse for every loss or shortcoming (if they happen)
So lets look at this game specifically.
We have out recruited VT by an average of 13.5 spots over the last 4 years(only our junior class where VT-24, UM-26 did they out recruit us). Our average class rank is 18 versus 31.5 for VT. I know recruiting rankings aren't the end all be all......but a good indicator of overall talent level on team. This team still won 8 games in a season that Golden was fired midway that Richt inherited and they beat VT.
We are at home, the talent advantage is really in our favor, VT is in year 2 of a new coach as well.........So why shouldn't the expectation today be for us to win this game?
I don't buy into myth of the 3-4 year rebuilding at schools that are expected to win. Richt himself took over for a perennial 7-8 win team at UGA....went 13-1 year 2. I can come up many more examples. Saban took over a 3 win LSU, Won SEC year 2, and a 6-6 team at Bama was 12-0 in SECCG year 2, Tressel took over 8 win OSU teams Undefeated year 2, Meyer won MNC year 2 taking over for fired 7-8 win Zook, Stoops won MNC year 2 at OU after they won 18 games previous 4 years, Carroll went 11-2 year 2 and finished
#4 at USC taking over for a perennial 6-8 win team.....Right guy doesn't need 3-4 years.
I think we have over inflated the actual damage to the program from the NCAA cloud as an excuse for way too many years. We have severely underachieved to our talent level......and that includes last year. And let me be perfectly clear....I am not down on Richt at all....He is exactly doing what he should be doing....weird crap happens year 1, Saban lost to LA-Monroe.
I can accept that we may not be ready to compete with Bama and maybe a few others........but I don't agree with the poster that beating VT at home on Saturday night is "icing on the cake" right now like he is alluding to or doesn't "say much" about Richt's ability to win the big one. It should be the expectation as of today and Franchise is right......a loss would be major gut punch.