I saw Choc play some games at Carol City. He was a heck of an athlete and I was disappointed that he never reached the same level in college as some of his contemporaries he played with and against at Traz Powell, like Dalvin Cook. I guess Choc never learned the playbook or adjusted to the higher levels of play at the D1 level, so he never reached his full potential. But I must confess that Choc had some incredible raw talent; upon reflection, we had a lot of Greentree All Americans during the 2006 - 2023 era who didn’t live up to expectations. That’s probably a big reason why we struggled during those years
This is where I truly think preparation, experience, baller mentality and culture matter and rankings are less important. Toney is an average starting WR by normal measures (height, weight, 40, shuttle). Bain an average DE with "short arms".
We'll never know. But I agree with you that Choc and several of our underachievers had unrealized potential. Can't even blame it on the coaches. Because the way Mario demands 100% 24x7, I'm not sure these types of players would have demonstrated enough grit to earn the offer to begin with.