forums

The Evolution of Mark Fletcher

Advertisement
bshaw28 said:
I

@TheOriginalCane - I'm on your side here.

All off season I said Fletcher was our best RB. I consistently defended him & said he was getting too much hate.

If you read my posts vs automatically hating on me - you'll see we agree on more than you think.

Like when my OP says: "If I were coaching Fletcher the two things I'd have him work on are:"

So if we can agree Fletcher needed coaching (and he eventually took a huge leap) - then we can also acknowledge it's completely fair for Cali or anyone else to be critical of Fletcher since it did take 3 full seasons for the results to look different.

You both make good & fair points - it's just a matter of opinion of how good Fletcher is/can be. There's been plenty of positives and negatives along the way in Fletcher's career to support both your opinions.
Click to expand...


Look, the post you just made is eminently fair.

I'm just pointing out that lots of posters love to IMMEDIATELY judge a player as "not good enough" or whatever other assessment they make off of limited data.

This is simple. I've been watching Miami games, as a student or an alum since the early 1980s. I've seen all kinds of different running backs at The U. They are not all the same, they all have relative strengths and weaknesses. Many of them have suffered injuries and require recovery time.

Where I AM CRITICAL is in the assessment of "it did take 3 full seasons for the results to look different". I think that is a ridiculous standard to apply. What happened to the days of guys having 5 years to play 4? Why do we think that a kid coming out of ****** Florida high schools with underpaid coaches and very little skills development would suddenly be good in college, IN A TOP COLLEGE PROGRAM, in the first year or two of his enrollment? Particularly if he suffers a major injury along the way?

This is the problem with "armchair quarterbacks" sitting on their couches while they assess players with far more talent than they will ever possess. These armchair QBs are not coaches or scouts or even weekend volunteers. They are just guys with bigscreen TVs who think that their eyes are as trained and qualified as the eyes of the guys who are paid millions to coach.

The bottom line goes back to what I said earlier. It's not "stating everything based on hope" (as Calinative said) when we simply want to watch a talented kid DEVELOP and overcome his injuries. That's all.

I wish every player was equally good at every one of his positional skills. That's rare, though. On the other hand, wanting a hard-working high-quality person like Mark Fletcher to have every opportunity to regain his starting role and develop his skills is not "stating everything based on hope". It's simply a rooting interest in football and football players.

If a credit card fraudster like Martin Patton washes out at Miami, so be it. But I'm going to enjoy watching the developmental process that Mark Fletcher is experiencing, and I won't be writing him off too early.
 
DMoney said:
Fletcher improved, as hard workers often do. He also got healthier and flourished in the pistol formation.

But the OP is a long way to avoid saying, "I was wrong about Fletcher." We all remember who said what.

Mark Fletcher is a championship player and I'm grateful he's a Hurricane.
Click to expand...
Early on, I thought Fletcher had poor footwork. His feet seemed to get tangled up very easily just as it looked like he was going to break free into the secondary. He also seemed just a bit slow to recognize an opening and exploit it. He definitely seemed to overcome that issue last season. Sometimes young athletes go through some growing pains as their body matures. Hard to tell whether the difference came from a physical aspect or from gaining mental clarity.
Whatever the reason was, he has certainly overcome it and has become the complete back we hoped to see. I will be honest and admit that I thought Lyle was going to become the breakout star from our RB group and I still believe he is very talented. Fletcher just seized the opportunity and it would be hard to imagine anything except injury keeping him from remaining the featured back in our offense. I can’t wait to see what this RB group does next season.
 
Back
Top