Scenarios: How do we finish? Realistic Expectations

Season Scenario

  • ACC Championship & National Championship Appearance

    Votes: 49 32.0%
  • ACC Championship & Semis Appearance

    Votes: 60 39.2%
  • ACC Championship & First Round

    Votes: 24 15.7%
  • Close loss to Wake in ACC Championship and still get in

    Votes: 20 13.1%
  • Blow out loss to Wake and Stay Home

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    153
We want Wake to continue to look good in their next couple of games, and if we both win out, both teams should make it in.
 
TrumpyCane thinks the defense has played a lot better the last two weeks than what we saw against FSU and UNC, keep slightly improving and hopefully come playoff time we can get healthy and be an above average defense
 
Hot take: if we commit to playing Fitz at free safety 100 percent of the time, run more man and use one LB to blitz instead of strong safety blitz and offense has healthy Buchanan and Toney back, we absolutely roll to the title game.
 
Can't begin to give a guess until I know the status and effectivity of Malachi Toney.

Is Malachi Toney back and let's say 95+% healthy by the ACCCG? Probably not, but that's question #1. Is he 100% by the playoffs? Is he essentially done for the year, either by not returning at all or being totally ineffective if he does?

If you told me Malachi Toney was, today, the kid who started the season, I would tell you the ceiling is the national championship. Yes, with the defense and OL. Because the QB and skill talent is just that good, it'd be a possibility.

If you tell me Malachi Toney will either not play or be a shell of himself for the rest of the season, then I would say we probably get bounced in the quarterfinals. I think we could beat someone like BYU or Indiana or Texas Tech if we played them in the round of 12, but if we got a bye or won and had to play someone like UGA or Notre Dame or Tennessee, I wouldn't be super confident.

It's college football, and nobody is great this year. Anything can happen. But without Mali, I don't think we have enough firepower to overcome the defense and OL deficiencies. Mensah is the best QB in the country and can mask a lot, but did he complete a single pass over 10 yards last week? Air yards, I mean. I don't remember a single one? You're not gonna beat great teams like that, certainly not teams that can score 30+ on your defense, which most of the teams we'd see deep in the playoffs probably could.

Mali gives us a puncher's chance. But he's gotta actually be Mali, not a dude limping around out there wearing his jersey.
 
Last edited:
We have to win out, unfortunately.

One thing: I saw one prediction with Wake in the same pod as the Irish.

God help those Domer ba$tards. Wake will beat the brakes off them.
 
Can't begin to give a guess until I know the status and effectivity of Malachi Toney.

Is Malachi Toney back and let's say 95+% healthy by the ACCCG? Probably not, but that's question #1. Is he 100% by the playoffs? Is he essentially done for the year, either by not returning at all or being totally ineffective if he does?

If you told me Malachi Toney was, today, the kid who started the season, I would tell you the ceiling is the national championship. Yes, with the defense and OL. Because the QB and skill talent is just that good, it'd be a possibility.

If you tell me Malachi Toney will either not play or be a shell of himself for the rest of the season, then I would say we probably get bounced in the quarterfinals. I think we could beat someone like BYU or Indiana or Texas Tech if we played them in the round of 12, but if we got a bye or won and had to play someone like UGA or Notre Dame or Tennessee, I wouldn't be super confident.

It's college football, and nobody is great this year. Anything can happen. But without Mali, I don't think we have enough firepower to overcome the defense and OL deficiencies. Mensah is the best QB in the country and can mask a lot, but did he complete a single pass over 10 yards last week? Air yards, I mean. I don't remember a single one? You're not gonna beat great teams like that, certainly not teams that can score 30+ on your defense, which most of the teams we'd see deep in the playoffs probably could.

Mali gives us a puncher's chance. But he's gotta actually be Mali, not a dude limping around out there wearing his jersey.
Toney will definitely be returning either acc title or playoff. That's the plan. I guess there is always a chance he has a setback unfortunately. So not guaranteed.

I suspect he may not be all the way back to form early on. Who knows, but we better make sure he is healthy enough to even play. With Toney, it opens up so much on offense including our run game and pass game for other players. It masks our struggling line.

I guess it would be hard to expect him to be 100% of what he was before injury right away at least. We just have to play it by ear and pray he fully recovers.

The good news is he is ahead of schedule. That's all we know for now. Go Canes!
 
Toney will definitely be returning either acc title or playoff. That's the plan. I guess there is always a chance he has a setback unfortunately. So not guaranteed.

I suspect he may not be all the way back to form early on. Who knows, but we better make sure he is healthy enough to even play. With Toney, it opens up so much on offense including our run game and pass game for other players. It masks our struggling line.

I guess it would be hard to expect him to be 100% of what he was before injury right away at least. We just have to play it by ear and pray he fully recovers.

The good news is he is ahead of schedule. That's all we know for now. Go Canes!

Well that's a big difference. If he returns for Charlotte, that's basically 4 weeks from the surgery. Anything is possible, but I'd be beyond shocked if he was Mali in 4 weeks after this procedure. Can he play? Maybe. Can he be a human joystick? Eh.

As far as playoffs, the first round is 6 weeks post-surgery. Now we're talking. Can he be Mali in 6 weeks? That's more likely.

If we can somehow get a bye, now you're pushing almost 8 weeks. If you tell me he needs to be 100% in 8 weeks after surgery, now we're cooking with gas. That's a reasonable expectation.

IMO, if we win the next 2 games by massive scores, we're in. I can't believe I'm saying that, because I've said forever the ACC is a one-bid league, but with our brand and resume, the way Wake is absolutely demolishing people, and how much carnage we've seen, I think it's now a 2-bid league (Assuming we both win significantly the next 2 weeks). I think we smoke VT and BC off the field, and unless Mali is literally 100.0% ready, which I doubt seriously, he sits for Wake, and we get him ready for the playoffs. If we win, we probably get a bye, and he gets 4 more weeks (so, 8 weeks from surgery). If we lose, we should still make it and have to play in the first round, which at 6 weeks, gives Mali a realistic shot to be himself.
 
The odds say both wake and Miami get in. But the odds haven’t really reflected what that group of idiots will do
 
Well that's a big difference. If he returns for Charlotte, that's basically 4 weeks from the surgery. Anything is possible, but I'd be beyond shocked if he was Mali in 4 weeks after this procedure. Can he play? Maybe. Can he be a human joystick? Eh.

As far as playoffs, the first round is 6 weeks post-surgery. Now we're talking. Can he be Mali in 6 weeks? That's more likely.

If we can somehow get a bye, now you're pushing almost 8 weeks. If you tell me he needs to be 100% in 8 weeks after surgery, now we're cooking with gas. That's a reasonable expectation.

IMO, if we win the next 2 games by massive scores, we're in. I can't believe I'm saying that, because I've said forever the ACC is a one-bid league, but with our brand and resume, the way Wake is absolutely demolishing people, and how much carnage we've seen, I think it's now a 2-bid league (Assuming we both win significantly the next 2 weeks). I think we smoke VT and BC off the field, and unless Mali is literally 100.0% ready, which I doubt seriously, he sits for Wake, and we get him ready for the playoffs. If we win, we probably get a bye, and he gets 4 more weeks (so, 8 weeks from surgery). If we lose, we should still make it and have to play in the first round, which at 6 weeks, gives Mali a realistic shot to be himself.
I don't see a scenario where we get in playoff if we lose to wake for acc title. That's unlikely. They don't think the acc is a strong conf which hurts us.

How do you see us getting a bye?

The games left are not likely to have many teams ahead of us lose outside of a conf champ game. That may not be enough. Maybe bama loses to Auburn or georgia to south car but not likely.

I agree, hoping for the best at this point.
 
Having Max back will certainly help.

Nothing the D-line has done convinces me we can survive. If they don’t put pressure, our DBs are cooked, even with Antoine and Antoine.

I also feel like Dunnigan has been exposed. He falls for the eye candy way too often, although I feel he’s our best nickel currently.
Great points and agree with a few, but having been there before and experience of last year helps. Coaches will tell the media and everybody that they will play free and with no fear, when you know that won't be the case. Big game experience and close game experience matters. Look at our team this year. I think everybody would agree that we lose those close games in past years.
 
God those numbers this year are ******* depressing. Was I expecting 2025 production? **** no, but I expected at least 35 sacks, 10 picks and 7-8 forced fumbles by now.
We had 25 sacks after 10 games last year. I don't think we are going to match last year's late season sack production but @PIPO hiding the ball a bit comparing numbers over 16 games to numbers over 10 games.
 
We had 25 sacks after 10 games last year. I don't think we are going to match last year's late season sack production but @PIPO hiding the ball a bit comparing numbers over 16 games to numbers over 10 games.
Ohhhh I thought he meant through 10 games. That's why I was like holy ****. Thanks for clarifying.
 
God those numbers this year are ******* depressing. Was I expecting 2025 production? **** no, but I expected at least 35 sacks, 10 picks and 7-8 forced fumbles by now.

They look even worse when you break down where they came from.

This is why I get on my high horse the first 3-4 games each year. If you're not running up stats against your cupcakes, you're not very good on whichever side of the ball. Going all the way back to 2021, you can align the team with how they played the cupcakes for the entire season.

This is just how I see it. Not scientific or binding, but usually a dead on indicator.
 
I think we are going off previous ACC bias for CFP... this year is different and every talking head has said, everyone can beat everyone this year... there's no dominant team really... SEC is down... big10 is a complete disaster this year... if there's one year 2 ACC teams can make it, it's now.... both WF and us have to look STRONG these next two games for sure...... and regardless of who wins, if the ACCCG is a hard fought decent scoring game decided by 10 or fewer points and both QB's look good, I can see them putting us both in....

now.. my other personality says, they could totally go historic NCAA and ***** the ACC in favor for 8 SEC schools too..... buttttt... lets see....
 
I don't see a scenario where we get in playoff if we lose to wake for acc title. That's unlikely. They don't think the acc is a strong conf which hurts us.

How do you see us getting a bye?

The games left are not likely to have many teams ahead of us lose outside of a conf champ game. That may not be enough. Maybe bama loses to Auburn or georgia to south car but not likely.

I agree, hoping for the best at this point.

I would disagree it's unlikely. I think there's a real path for the ACC to get two.

4 SEC
2 B1G
2 Big 12
2 ACC
ND
G6

I think that's very much in play.

As far as a bye, if we go 12-1, we got a shot.
 
I would disagree it's unlikely. I think there's a real path for the ACC to get two.

4 SEC
2 B1G
2 Big 12
2 ACC
ND
G6

I think that's very much in play.

As far as a bye, if we go 12-1, we got a shot.
Good analysis.

However, I just don't see how we can pass teams that are ahead of us just winning our last 3 including a 1 loss wake team unless a couple teams lose ahead of us. Maybe I am wrong but based on how they dropped us 6 spots after losing to ND close without Mali on road, and favored bama and Texas with 2 losses over us, I think a bye for us will be extremely difficult and unlikely. I hope I am wrong. We'll see.

We absolutely can't lose to wake, we have to win that game by whatever means necessary. We can't put our playoff hopes in the hands of the playoff comm.
 
For the rest of this year, with all of the data we have, realistic scenarios and expectations:

Best Case: ACC Championship and Semi-Final Appearance.

Likely Scenario: ACC Championship and first round playoff loss.

Very Bad Scenario: Lose ACC Championship to Wake and somehow slip into the playoff and lose in the first round.

Worst Case Scenario: Get smoked by Wake in the ACC Championship game and are totally left out of the playoff.


WHY?

1) Heatherman & defense suck this year. Plain and simple.
We wont survive vs a good offense (You think we can keep up with a Utah, Arizona, Texas Tech, Bama, Georgia, etc) type of offense without a good and consistent defense that can put pressure on the QB? We are who we are: Almost 2024 levels bad. Heatherman doesn’t adjust to his tendencies. We are still sending safeties on Blitzes from Orlando. Middle of the field hasn’t been addressed. Quick release and mobile QBs kill us. Statue QBs kill us. They all look like Joe Montana or Pat Mahomes.

Our best opponent to play in a first round would be another offensive challenged team: Indiana, UCLA type of team.

2) No safety that has replaced Jakobi Thomas. I wish we would play Fitzgerald exclusively at FS. Poyser has not been good as well.

3) We don’t have a nickel that has even come close to Agent 0. The guy we have posing as Agent Zero can’t tackle or have anywhere near the same Football IQ.

4) We are a terrible tackling team.

5) We don’t put pressure or sack the opposing QB.

6) The offensive line is not good enough. We had opportunities to play around with a rotation earlier in the year and try things out but we abandoned it. I still believe that the best o-line that would’ve of given us a chance to even compete for a championship would’ve been:

LT: Samson
LG: Condon/Max/McCoy
C: Rodriguez
RG: McCoy/Max
RT: Cantwell

Prepare Season 7 GIF by Game of Thrones
I just read Cantwell is progressing but the speed of the game is too fast for him. He did not face good enough competition in HS to be ready for the college game. Also spent most of the spring at LT only because of injury to the starter. Player development required.
 
Back
Top