Scenarios: How do we finish? Realistic Expectations

Season Scenario

  • ACC Championship & National Championship Appearance

    Votes: 49 32.0%
  • ACC Championship & Semis Appearance

    Votes: 60 39.2%
  • ACC Championship & First Round

    Votes: 24 15.7%
  • Close loss to Wake in ACC Championship and still get in

    Votes: 20 13.1%
  • Blow out loss to Wake and Stay Home

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    153

PIPO

Bathing in Nole Tears!!
Premium
Joined
Jan 9, 2019
Messages
36,673
For the rest of this year, with all of the data we have, realistic scenarios and expectations:

Best Case: ACC Championship and Semi-Final Appearance.

Likely Scenario: ACC Championship and first round playoff loss.

Very Bad Scenario: Lose ACC Championship to Wake and somehow slip into the playoff and lose in the first round.

Worst Case Scenario: Get smoked by Wake in the ACC Championship game and are totally left out of the playoff.


WHY?

1) Heatherman & defense suck this year. Plain and simple.
We wont survive vs a good offense (You think we can keep up with a Utah, Arizona, Texas Tech, Bama, Georgia, etc) type of offense without a good and consistent defense that can put pressure on the QB? We are who we are: Almost 2024 levels bad. Heatherman doesn’t adjust to his tendencies. We are still sending safeties on Blitzes from Orlando. Middle of the field hasn’t been addressed. Quick release and mobile QBs kill us. Statue QBs kill us. They all look like Joe Montana or Pat Mahomes.

Our best opponent to play in a first round would be another offensive challenged team: Indiana, UCLA type of team.

2) No safety that has replaced Jakobi Thomas. I wish we would play Fitzgerald exclusively at FS. Poyser has not been good as well.

3) We don’t have a nickel that has even come close to Agent 0. The guy we have posing as Agent Zero can’t tackle or have anywhere near the same Football IQ.

4) We are a terrible tackling team.

5) We don’t put pressure or sack the opposing QB.

6) The offensive line is not good enough. We had opportunities to play around with a rotation earlier in the year and try things out but we abandoned it. I still believe that the best o-line that would’ve of given us a chance to even compete for a championship would’ve been:

LT: Samson
LG: Condon/Max/McCoy
C: Rodriguez
RG: McCoy/Max
RT: Cantwell

Prepare Season 7 GIF by Game of Thrones
 
Last edited:
If we get Mali and Buchanon back (likely) we will make it at least to the semi finals IMO.

If we can get 1 of OJ or Antoine back (or both), assuming no other major injuries, we could go further. We'd probably need Wilson to wake his *** up at DE as well.

A lot of it will be how the bracket ends up as well. A path of going through BYU, Utah, and or ND/IU is a lot easier then going thru Bama, UGA, etc.
 
If we get Mali and Buchanon back (likely) we will make it at least to the semi finals IMO.

If we can get 1 of OJ or Antoine back (or both), assuming no other major injuries, we could go further. We'd probably need Wilson to wake his *** up at DE as well.

A lot of it will be how the bracket ends up as well. A path of going through BYU, Utah, and or ND/IU is a lot easier then going thru Bama, UGA, etc.
Having Max back will certainly help.

Nothing the D-line has done convinces me we can survive. If they don’t put pressure, our DBs are cooked, even with Antoine and Antoine.

I also feel like Dunnigan has been exposed. He falls for the eye candy way too often, although I feel he’s our best nickel currently.
 
WF is playing very well right now. I think they beat us in the ACCG. If you're in before the conference championship game then iirc you don't drop if you lose in that game. Hopefully, we'll make it but I am dubious we could survive an ACCG loss.
 
My opinion is I think we can still make the title game depending on the bracket and the matchups. We still have the best skill players including the best player in the country in Mali.

Plus we have the best QB in the country in Mensah or he is at least one of the two best besides Carr. Mensah is really accurate and makes plays despite a struggling Oline. He is a gamer at QB. He is playing at a Cam Ward level right now. That will help cover some of the weaknesses of our OLine.

We get Buchanon back for BC, I think we can keep improving and also our D seems to be getting a little better although not playoff level yet.

I think we can win a game or two in playoff depending on the matchups but with Toney and Mensah healthy, and our Dline and OLine will be getting better as year goes on, plus Fletcher and Mallory in backfield, I wouldn't bet against Miami making the title game. Lots of unknowns still.

We just don't have the horses at DE like last year unfortunately to say anything else more definitive.

I would feel a lot better about our NC chances if our D was a little better especially our pass rush.

Hopefully we keep improving.

That being said, that's why they play the games.

Go Canes!
 
Having Max back will certainly help.

Nothing the D-line has done convinces me we can survive. If they don’t put pressure, our DBs are cooked, even with Antoine and Antoine.

I also feel like Dunnigan has been exposed. He falls for the eye candy way too often, although I feel he’s our best nickel currently.
if Mali and Max are back, we at least can outscore teams which gives us a punchers chance.

our defense has certainly been disappointing, but we realistically just need them to get a few key stops per game, which they have done to this point
 
I think as of right now we win these next two comfortably. I am not convinced we will beat Wake unless Mali is somehow back and this defense continues to show SOME improvement. They are going to score in bunches on us so maybe we can keep pace with them.
 
I think if we lose to Wake by ANY amount, there's a strong chance we won't make the CFP. If we were ranked 5, then possibly. But we are 7 and will be a struggle to move up.
I hate to say this but if we can't beat Wake and win the acc we don't belong in the playoff. We absolutely have to win this game and win acc. End of discussion.
 
If we lose a close ACCCG to Wake I think we have a chance. If they beat the brakes off of us we're not getting in. The CFP is looking for every and any reason to put a 3-loss SEC team in the field and that "losing a conference championship game doesn't hurt you" narrative only applies to Alabama, Georgia etc.

Wake was the first game our defense really looked suspect, and outside of the Central Michigan game its bare *** has largely been exposed ever since. If they're able to move the ball for 4 quarters the way they did against us for much of the second half in the first game, we're going to have to score 7 every drive.

That said....Natty.

Ohio State Osu GIF by Respective
 
if people aint voting for acc championship and national title appearance, you all are a bunch of plants. We have warts like all the teams. We are playing good! Be a fan and not a mope!

“Forget what your eyes have actually shown you. If you don’t think we win 6 no matter what then you’re a *****!!!!!!”

Lol, anyway. As most have said, depends on matchups. No surprise, but our scoring D is currently the worst of all P4 top 12 playoff seeded teams. Get as healthy as we can and pray for the best matchups for us 🤷🏾‍♂️. Can’t answer anything without knowing that, atleast I can’t. I feel ehh about Wake unless Mali plays.
 
Back
Top