forums

Richt's QB rotations are irrational

ThomasM said:
Then why for God's sake start Rosier and waste ANY reps on him?
Click to expand...
Because CMR thinks Perry sucks... and everytime Perry goes in a game he proves him right. You have to be really really bad to look worse than Malik Rosier, yet Perry did exactly that last night.
 
Advertisement
i think he sabotages perry like an i told you so..to the fans. like...look both of them are bad it aint my fault
 
terdferguson said:
Much like many of his decisions. Rosier should have permanently been placed on the pine a long time ago and we should have rolled with one of the younger guys, but that didn't happen. Then the quick hook of Perry against UVA which was a head scratcher given the extraordinarily long leash Rosier has been afforded. The subsequent not playing Perry at all against BC. Then his rotations in this game. None of it makes sense.

In the game last night he inexplicably brought in Perry for just a couple series right when the torrential downpour started. This is a young qb who needs passing reps and completions to build confidence. I don't see any confidence building coming from inserting him at this spot. Then for some reason Perry heads back to the bench and Rosier returns. Why at that particular moment? No one knows. Perry is reinserted in crunch time with the game on the line having thrown no passes the entire game except a few in a monsoon. ???

The thing that made this extra weird was that Rosier had actually played pretty well immediately preceding this. He led a drive to a missed fg where he was 3-3 and...brace yourself....actually hit all three receivers in stride with perfect passes. The next drive Rosier only attempted 1 pass which was a ball in the dirt to cager under duress. So the two drives before his benching he was 3-4 with all the completions being in stride. Good job Malik, now head to the bench so we can put in this guy who's been getting stiff on the sideline the last 2 hours and hasn't attempted a non monsoon pass all game.
Click to expand...

It’s called CORCHING decisions
They have been working for 30 years
 
For_The_U said:
Because CMR thinks Perry sucks... and everytime Perry goes in a game he proves him right. You have to be really really bad to look worse than Malik Rosier, yet Perry did exactly that last night.
Click to expand...
Alright, then why put Perry in to finish the game, or when backed up against his goal line? There is no good way to slice this **** pie.
 
ThomasM said:
Alright, then why put Perry in to finish the game, or when backed up against his goal line? There is no good way to slice this **** pie.
Click to expand...
I agree. I'm just being cranky. The whole QB situation both sucks at its core (i.e. we have no good options) and has also been terribly mismanaged.
 
For_The_U said:
I agree. I'm just being cranky. The whole QB situation both sucks at its core (i.e. we have no good options) and has also been terribly mismanaged.
Click to expand...
Imagine for a minute if they just started Williams against LSU. We'd have still lost, but at least he would have grown enough to, more than likely, beat our last three opponents. The two guys ahead of him are either arm dead or brain dead. You can not win games with either of them.

Then again, our O is so bad, Joe Montana probably couldn't make it look good.

You know what kills me about Rosier? Not only is his arm average, his accuracy terrible, but his TIMING is the absolute worst I have ever seen at this level. He literally throws the ball a full second too late at times. You can get away with lack of arm strength at this level if you have good timing, but dear lord I have never seen timing SO bad.
 
There is prescedent, here. See the Georgia vs Florida game in 2015 that led to his firing. He started the 3rd string QB- a guy that never played a snap- in the biggest game of the season, against their fiercest rival. He said he went with his “gut”

This 3rd stringer went on to throw 4INTs that game, in a blowout loss, and this was the final nail that led to Richt being fired

No sane coach makes that kind of decision. I think he’s senile or suffering from some form of dementia
 
terdferguson said:
Much like many of his decisions. Rosier should have permanently been placed on the pine a long time ago and we should have rolled with one of the younger guys, but that didn't happen. Then the quick hook of Perry against UVA which was a head scratcher given the extraordinarily long leash Rosier has been afforded. The subsequent not playing Perry at all against BC. Then his rotations in this game. None of it makes sense.

In the game last night he inexplicably brought in Perry for just a couple series right when the torrential downpour started. This is a young qb who needs passing reps and completions to build confidence. I don't see any confidence building coming from inserting him at this spot. Then for some reason Perry heads back to the bench and Rosier returns. Why at that particular moment? No one knows. Perry is reinserted in crunch time with the game on the line having thrown no passes the entire game except a few in a monsoon. ???

The thing that made this extra weird was that Rosier had actually played pretty well immediately preceding this. He led a drive to a missed fg where he was 3-3 and...brace yourself....actually hit all three receivers in stride with perfect passes. The next drive Rosier only attempted 1 pass which was a ball in the dirt to cager under duress. So the two drives before his benching he was 3-4 with all the completions being in stride. Good job Malik, now head to the bench so we can put in this guy who's been getting stiff on the sideline the last 2 hours and hasn't attempted a non monsoon pass all game.
Click to expand...


Man I am sorry but that's stupid. Perry is awful and his numbers prove it. That pass he made in yesterdays game was a pick 6 if it wasn't raining and his reciever was not open ever not even for 1 second,. If he played every minute he would set the record for interceptions by any QB in D1 history. Miami was statistically still in the running for the coastal before yesterday. Richt should have pulled Perry after that series yesterday. When the season was on the line and you have the one guy who you have no confidence in then I question whether or not your even trying to win. Rosier is bad overall but Perry is a turnover machine that would make Jacory Harris look like a smart QB.
 
Advertisement
For_The_U said:
Enough with the 'Richt wants Perry to fail' bullsh-it. It was a 2 and 2 rotation. And then when it came down to the final drive and a chance to get the game to OT, who was under center? Perry. Yet Richt wants him to fail, right? Stupid. Perry does a fine job failing all by himself.
Click to expand...
They both have failed. What coach in their right mind would put Perry in the game when Mork did? Your answer, NONE! And as far as putting Perry in at the end, nice job coach, just when Malik was actually doing something half ***, you put in the RS freshman who has been on the bench for 2 hours. You sound like a CMR slurper to me.
 
There is no way richt got away with this type of pop Warner coaching at Georgia his first 13 years, no way.
 
WhatTheHell said:
He’s completely botched the QB situation this season.

It’s almost like he spins a wheel before every possession to see who he’s gonna trot out. The minute he yanked Perry vs UVA, following his 4 TDs against FSU, the team started to quit. Removed all our (and Perry’s) momentum by going back to the QB everyone hates.

Playing an awful, 5th year senior is inexcusable. More horrible coaching moves.
Click to expand...

This season, Brad Kaaya said hello! That 4 game losing streak is on him, his son and Thomas brown. Rpo for Peyton Manning!!! Really
 
troyskiles said:
They both have failed. What coach in their right mind would put Perry in the game when Mork did? Your answer, NONE! And as far as putting Perry in at the end, nice job coach, just when Malik was actually doing something half ***, you put in the RS freshman who has been on the bench for 2 hours. You sound like a CMR slurper to me.
Click to expand...
Wrong, not at all a CMR slurper. I'm just tired of all the Perry slurpers making excuse after excuse for the stone cold realty that the kid flat out sucks on the game day field. His performance last night was atrocious. Yet the slurpers come on here the next day with "CMR wants him to fail; he threw some nice balls; it wasn't fair when he was inserted; it's all Richt's fault for pulling him during UVA game; etc etc etc". No, none of that is the truth. The truth is Kosi is garbage.
 
Jedi Master Cane said:
We're talking about the same guy who came to the in game conclusion last year that benching Rosier for Evan Sherieffs was a good idea.

He panics, plain and simple. There is no "grand plan", there is no logical thought process. He's flying by the seat of his pants all while refusing to change the scheme.

He makes Pat Nix and James Coley look like competent OC's. Period.
Click to expand...
That’s what ****es me off about Richt, across the board with this offense you can see the lack of plan and strategy.

QB rotation
LSU totally out schemes us
We use the 2018 bye week and come out looking like trash
Our snap count clap garbage
DL know exactly how to stunt against us
All of the slant routes against BC
Complete lack of a 2minute offense

I can go on and on, he needs to hire an established OC or gtfo
 
Advertisement
Back
Top