forums

Richt as OC

Pentagon Cane said:
Take away the 50 yard touchdown run where for some know reason Jennings vacated his gap responsibility and completely took himself out of the play.

LoL, I wish we had a quarterback who could audible out of a bad play. That's what Burrow did on that play. Still should have only gone for 4 or 5 yards if Jennings plays his assignment.
Click to expand...

Believe it was m.smith? Also why is he on the field there?
 
Advertisement
There are good programs playing true freshmen QBs these days. Yet we can’t get guys who have been here two years prepared to outplay a guy with such obvious limitations. Either Perry and Weldon are vomit chunks, or Rick can’t get them coached up.
 
Canes_ said:
That is a bigger indictment on Richt the HC. In year three, you can't really use personnel as an excuse.
Click to expand...

Richt is a qb guy and his son is on staff as a qb coach. I support Richt and like a lot of what he is doing...but there is no excuse for trotting out rosier (or anyone as limited as rosier) 2 years in a row. As i stated above I don’t mind the play calling at all...and i HOPE the only reason he’s stuck with Rosier is because he wanted someone who hs faced that kinda speed and environment before (which i understand) but no more excuses, time to move on
 
The Franchise said:
There are good programs playing true freshmen QBs these days. Yet we can’t get guys who have been here two years prepared to outplay a guy with such obvious limitations. Either Perry and Weldon are vomit chunks, or Rick can’t get them coached up.
Click to expand...

What i’ve been saying everywhere

YOu are a qb guy mark richt. Your son is on staff...you either recruit or develop qb play. IF you get stuck with a rosier one year ok. No need or excuse for 2 years of this.

Change gotta come now
 
Last edited:
The Franchise said:
There are good programs playing true freshmen QBs these days. Yet we can’t get guys who have been here two years prepared to outplay a guy with such obvious limitations. Either Perry and Weldon are vomit chunks, or Rick can’t get them coached up.
Click to expand...
Because he was rolling with experience going into a big game. I believe if Perry has available he would have Rosier. If he is going to pull the trigger, then Savannah State is the perfect game.
 
skeeter said:
What i’ve been saying everywhere

YOu are a quy mark richt. Your son is on staff...you either recruit or develop qb play. IF you get stuck with a rosier one year ok. No need or excuse for 2 years of this.

Change gotta come now
Click to expand...
QB situation is looking sadly similar to Rick’s last couple years at UGA where he had to drag in a kumbum who couldn’t win the job at Virginia because the QBs he recruited flopped so badly.
 
Pentagon Cane said:
Because he was rolling with experience going into a big game. I believe if Perry has available he would have Rosier. If he is going to pull the trigger, then Savannah State is the perfect game.
Click to expand...
You’re right. But there are teams with experience at QB who are playing true freshmen anyway.

At some point as the HC you have to realize that bad experience isn’t a great asset. It’s like every time I see a big play against our D Knowles is on the field and missing a chance to stop the big play. He’s experienced, but all his experience is bad.
 
Advertisement
You can blame rosier all you want, but the OL was the worst I’ve seen in a decade.

Also abandoning the run and play calling was atrocious.

Special teams unit gave LSU a short field 3 times in the early portion of 1st half.

Diaz is a joke.

We got beat in all 3 phases of the game.

That’s on CMR
 
The Franchise said:
You’re right. But there are teams with experience at QB who are playing true freshmen anyway.

At some point as the HC you have to realize that bad experience isn’t a great asset. It’s like every time I see a big play against our D Knowles is on the field and missing a chance to stop the big play. He’s experienced, but all his experience is bad.
Click to expand...

I think you will see quite a few corrections. Dean is moving down the depth chart. Glad to see Ivey can real reps. I think Knowles is about done playing a meaningful down at safety. You notice that Choc never saw the field again after being lost on pass pro.

You have to believe that Richt is going to make the change. It is now all about conference play. We are a different offense with competent quarterback play.
 
Richt puts all the pressure on the worst position player. No end arounds, no trickery. Three or four times per game would be a vast improvement!
 
M3N said:
You can blame rosier all you want, but the OL was the worst I’ve seen in a decade.

Also abandoning the run and play calling was atrocious.

Special teams unit gave LSU a short field 3 times in the early portion of 1st half.

Diaz is a joke.

We got beat in all 3 phases of the game.

That’s on CMR
Click to expand...

Lol nah the coaches really aren’t that bad.

Lsu teed off late but rosier had time the first 2-3 quarters. At least as much time as you can expect against a fast, athletic d, a team that hasn’t fielded a weak defense in 15 years

The problems were rosier (which is on richt at this point)/penalties (some of which were awful)/punting...and if ou wanna gripe, run defense isn’t where it needs to be but we knew that when those 2 goofs declared for draft
 
Rick will move on from Manny, Rumph and Diaz’s crony puppet Patke at the end of the season. He will have to in my opinion. I still think Rick is too stubborn to realize he needs help offensively and sorry Thomas Brown (although I like Brown especially he ability to recruit) isn’t an Xs and Os guy. Dugans isn’t an Xs and Os guy either and yet he is the best coach on the staff. What does that say about the rest of the coaches and their Xs or Os knowledge?

Why exactly Rumph and Banda are still on this staff is the million dollar question. What mechanics are they teaching Dean and Knowles because whatever it is try something else!
 
Last edited:
We need help on all 3 phases of the game. I think the declining play of our linebackers is more of a concern than richts playcalling actually...

Oline wasn’t nearly as bad as some are saying. The rbs had some room but when you get down like that it’s only so much running you can do. They pass blocked well a lot of times but of course got beat on quite a few times too. Rosier isn’t putting this team in the best decision to win. All experience isn’t good experience...
 
#26-MEAST said:
We will never compete with him calling plays.
Click to expand...
Been saying that for over 2 years. His offense has all the imagination of a pet rock. 3rd down Chernobyl meltdown and trotting Rosier out as a QB would be reason enough to get you fired, never alone remain as OC.
 
Advertisement
skeeter said:
I think play calling was fine...Penalties/Rosier (and some of this is on Richt, as the kid shouldn't be your QB 2 years in a row...An off year with transfers/it was your 2nd year on job/kid's a gamer, etc, etc...you can get stuck with him one year, BUT NOT 2), and Feagles lost this game.

penalties/rosier/feagles

Run D needs help too, but we knew that when those two goofs decided to declare for the draft.
Click to expand...

Respectfully disagree on the offense.
Dave Aranda said to the comentators that our offense consisted of just deep balls and RPO’s. That we don’t have a intermediate passing game. That’s the opposing DC essentially saying he only has to worry about two thing when defending us.
He also seems incapable of developing a QB that can be functional enough to compete with Rosier.....so in other words he can’t develop QB’s period.
On defense it’s beyond just the two guys that declared early since a lot of the same issues still happened last year. He also intentionally rotates less talented players over more talented players on critical snaps. For no reason.
That is indefensible IMO
 
Last edited:
PlanoCane said:
I think it is the person at QB.
Click to expand...

I think you can expend on that.
I think it is the person at QB.
I think it is the persons (dad and son) coaching the QB’s
I think it is the person Evaluating QB’s
I think it is the person Developing QB’s
I think it is the person calling plays
I think it is the person who came up with this offense
 
The Franchise said:
There are good programs playing true freshmen QBs these days. Yet we can’t get guys who have been here two years prepared to outplay a guy with such obvious limitations. Either Perry and Weldon are vomit chunks, or Rick can’t get them coached up.
Click to expand...
Neither...it’s a “maturity” thing and I’m 100% positive about that because I’ve seen before!
 
#26-MEAST said:
We will never compete with him calling plays.
Click to expand...

No, it's worse. We will never compete with him designing the offense. I can see him giving up playcalling but he's not gonna withdraw himself from running his Jurassic scheme.
 
Back
Top