OSU should be in the playoffs

[HarryCarayisGoat]

And it will be ******* awesome if they don't get in.

 

[UMFarArcher]

If we went to 32 teams and started the playoffs, it would all work out.

This current system sucks balls - and there will always be a few teams that feel they deserve to play, but just got cut out.

 

[FullyERicht]

Simplest thing in the world. Power-5 conference winners plus 3 at large bids based on the rankings. Simple, fair, and fun. You can thank Notre Dame's ******ry of being an independent for being the stumbling block to this.

 

[nystateofmind]

Simplest thing in the world. Power-5 conference winners plus 3 at large bids based on the rankings. Simple, fair, and fun. You can thank Notre Dame's ******ry of being an independent for being the stumbling block to this.

That would completely devalue the regular season. You could have a four loss team as Champion.

 

[FullyERicht]

Simplest thing in the world. Power-5 conference winners plus 3 at large bids based on the rankings. Simple, fair, and fun. You can thank Notre Dame's ******ry of being an independent for being the stumbling block to this.

That would completely devalue the regular season. You could have a four loss team as Champion.

Yes, the NFL system is just so unfair and devalued. I mean it's not like the NFL regular season AND playoffs is more than three times as popular than the next most popular sport.......oh wait....

 

[OrangetieFatface]

Simplest thing in the world. Power-5 conference winners plus 3 at large bids based on the rankings. Simple, fair, and fun. You can thank Notre Dame's ******ry of being an independent for being the stumbling block to this.

That would completely devalue the regular season. You could have a four loss team as Champion.

Imagine a 6-6 GT beating a 12-0 FSU.

 

[HarryCarayisGoat]

Simplest thing in the world. Power-5 conference winners plus 3 at large bids based on the rankings. Simple, fair, and fun. You can thank Notre Dame's ******ry of being an independent for being the stumbling block to this.

You're one the best posters on this board. But this is a horrible post. College Basketball sucks dude. Don't need football to suck too.

 

[OrangetieFatface]

Simplest thing in the world. Power-5 conference winners plus 3 at large bids based on the rankings. Simple, fair, and fun. You can thank Notre Dame's ******ry of being an independent for being the stumbling block to this.

That would completely devalue the regular season. You could have a four loss team as Champion.

Yes, the NFL system is just so unfair and devalued. I mean it's not like the NFL regular season AND playoffs is more than three times as popular than the next most popular sport.......oh wait....

Apples and oranges. CFB has 100 more teams to compare/evaluate.

 

[FullyERicht]

Simplest thing in the world. Power-5 conference winners plus 3 at large bids based on the rankings. Simple, fair, and fun. You can thank Notre Dame's ******ry of being an independent for being the stumbling block to this.

That would completely devalue the regular season. You could have a four loss team as Champion.

Imagine a 6-6 GT beating a 12-0 FSU.

Umm, this is what sports are about. Beat a team on the field in a gig that matters, and you are the better team.

 

[nystateofmind]

Simplest thing in the world. Power-5 conference winners plus 3 at large bids based on the rankings. Simple, fair, and fun. You can thank Notre Dame's ******ry of being an independent for being the stumbling block to this.

That would completely devalue the regular season. You could have a four loss team as Champion.

Yes, the NFL system is just so unfair and devalued. I mean it's not like the NFL regular season AND playoffs is more than three times as popular than the next most popular sport.......oh wait....

College football has the best regular season in sports because every game is life or death.

In '12, we were set to play in the ACCCG at 7-5, say we win. We'd be more deserving than a one loss team who lost in their conference title game? Of course not.

 

[Gatorhater]

If OSU and the noles get left out, it is fine.

 

[FullyERicht]

Simplest thing in the world. Power-5 conference winners plus 3 at large bids based on the rankings. Simple, fair, and fun. You can thank Notre Dame's ******ry of being an independent for being the stumbling block to this.

That would completely devalue the regular season. You could have a four loss team as Champion.

Yes, the NFL system is just so unfair and devalued. I mean it's not like the NFL regular season AND playoffs is more than three times as popular than the next most popular sport.......oh wait....

Apples and oranges. CFB has 100 more teams to compare/evaluate.

So you don't think beating a team in a "for all the marbles" game has any value? When the Giants beat the Patriots, twice, you would say the Pats should just be handed the title b/c they were "better". But on the field, they had a chance to show who is better.

 

[OrangetieFatface]

Simplest thing in the world. Power-5 conference winners plus 3 at large bids based on the rankings. Simple, fair, and fun. You can thank Notre Dame's ******ry of being an independent for being the stumbling block to this.

That would completely devalue the regular season. You could have a four loss team as Champion.

Imagine a 6-6 GT beating a 12-0 FSU.

Umm, this is what sports are about. Beat a team on the field in a gig that matters, and you are the better team.

Agree to disagree. 12-1 as a complete body of work vs similar competition trumps 7-6 to me.

 

[FullyERicht]

Simplest thing in the world. Power-5 conference winners plus 3 at large bids based on the rankings. Simple, fair, and fun. You can thank Notre Dame's ******ry of being an independent for being the stumbling block to this.

That would completely devalue the regular season. You could have a four loss team as Champion.

Yes, the NFL system is just so unfair and devalued. I mean it's not like the NFL regular season AND playoffs is more than three times as popular than the next most popular sport.......oh wait....

College football has the best regular season in sports because every game is life or death.

In '12, we were set to play in the ACCCG at 7-5, say we win. We'd be more deserving than a one loss team who lost in their conference title game? Of course not.

Apparently the "3 at larges" part went over your head. A one loss team whose only loss was in their conference title game would still get in. But if they didn't, too bad. They already had a chance to show they were better than a team who is in the playoffs, and weren't as good. Why should they get another chance?

Second of all, every measurable poll would show you that the NFL regular season is wildly more popular than the college football season. Now YOU may like college better, but an overwhelming majority prefers NFL.

 

[OrangetieFatface]

Simplest thing in the world. Power-5 conference winners plus 3 at large bids based on the rankings. Simple, fair, and fun. You can thank Notre Dame's ******ry of being an independent for being the stumbling block to this.

That would completely devalue the regular season. You could have a four loss team as Champion.

Yes, the NFL system is just so unfair and devalued. I mean it's not like the NFL regular season AND playoffs is more than three times as popular than the next most popular sport.......oh wait....

Apples and oranges. CFB has 100 more teams to compare/evaluate.

So you don't think beating a team in a "for all the marbles" game has any value? When the Giants beat the Patriots, twice, you would say the Pats should just be handed the title b/c they were "better". But on the field, they had a chance to show who is better.

Again, it's apples and oranges. there are 100 less teams. I'm not saying the NFL should pick up the CFB playoff system, so that's a strawman.

 

[SmokeyRone]

VT just won the B10.

 

[FullyERicht]

Simplest thing in the world. Power-5 conference winners plus 3 at large bids based on the rankings. Simple, fair, and fun. You can thank Notre Dame's ******ry of being an independent for being the stumbling block to this.

That would completely devalue the regular season. You could have a four loss team as Champion.

Imagine a 6-6 GT beating a 12-0 FSU.

Umm, this is what sports are about. Beat a team on the field in a gig that matters, and you are the better team.

Agree to disagree. 12-1 as a complete body of work vs similar competition trumps 7-6 to me.

So in your opinion the Giants should have just handed the trophy to the Pats all those times? Pats record was significantly better.

 

[FullyERicht]

That would completely devalue the regular season. You could have a four loss team as Champion.

Yes, the NFL system is just so unfair and devalued. I mean it's not like the NFL regular season AND playoffs is more than three times as popular than the next most popular sport.......oh wait....

Apples and oranges. CFB has 100 more teams to compare/evaluate.

So you don't think beating a team in a "for all the marbles" game has any value? When the Giants beat the Patriots, twice, you would say the Pats should just be handed the title b/c they were "better". But on the field, they had a chance to show who is better.

Again, it's apples and oranges. there are 100 less teams. I'm not saying the NFL should pick up the CFB playoff system, so that's a strawman.

How many power 5 teams are there?

 

[nystateofmind]

If you want an 8 team playoff, fine. But make it the 8 best teams, not conference champions.

 

[OrangetieFatface]

That would completely devalue the regular season. You could have a four loss team as Champion.

Imagine a 6-6 GT beating a 12-0 FSU.

Umm, this is what sports are about. Beat a team on the field in a gig that matters, and you are the better team.

Agree to disagree. 12-1 as a complete body of work vs similar competition trumps 7-6 to me.

So in your opinion the Giants should have just handed the trophy to the Pats all those times? Pats record was significantly better.

I don't know which strawman you're arguing with, but he's an idiot if he thinks the NFL should adopt the CFB system.