NLRB Beats Down NCAA

Empirical Cane

We are what we repeatedly do.
Joined
Sep 3, 2018
Messages
45,156
Advertisement
Haven’t looked at the make up of the board recently but all are supposed to be independent but basically are political appointees as they have to be confirmed by the Senate. Depending on who appointed them and their political leanings will go a long way in where this case goes.

I dealt with them about 20 years ago and at that time leaned to the conservative side.
 
Advertisement
This could open up a big can of worms. If a school is a company employing athletes can they fire said athlete at any time for not performing to standards? Can said athlete quit his company (school) and go work for another at any time. Can a company (school) close down a div if losing money (track, swimming, most women's sports and etc). Just a few questions in my mind as I try to imagine this happening
 
OK, I’m not going to jump into this from an either or side, but the p word in sports rarely work since most of those goofs never played a sport at any level.

So help me out; I saw the word “exploit” & using the terms student-athlete vs. employee. So what’s a scholarship; is not a scholarship offered to those who meet a certain requirement either academically and/or athletically where they receive a free ride to an often, 6-figure tuition?

What about the 99% of the athletes who r on b-ball, football, track, swimming, golf, and other club sports that are NCAA regulated, who have zero shot of having a professional career in said sports, but r using this opportunity to graduate & further themselves elsewhere; is that exploitation?

So the NIL money that’s now being offered, received…since students r now considered employees, is that taxed? Better yet, is their room, board, scholarship now taxable since they are no longer considered a student? Do they no longer have to attend class or keep up a certain GPA as a free lance employee, like the ringers who were used in the 1800-early 1900’s to help Yale & the Ivys secure championships? Can they now be fired or kicked off a team for any reason?

There’s a lot of ?’s I have from this ruling, & I believe they r trying to do this w/ best intentions, as it’s true, the NCAA holding students’ NIL hostage while profiting was bull chit. HOWEVER, I recall reading upon Dr Spock, & how he was the foremost voice to parents, criticizing them 4 disciplining their children. Those children took full advantage & became disrespectful little brats which transcended society; it was later where he admitted he made a grave mistake AFTER the consequences lent itself.

The moral is w/ how things r going, imo, this is a grave mistake for the overall health of CFB.
 
OK, I’m not going to jump into this from an either or side, but the p word in sports rarely work since most of those goofs never played a sport at any level.

So help me out; I saw the word “exploit” & using the terms student-athlete vs. employee. So what’s a scholarship; is not a scholarship offered to those who meet a certain requirement either academically and/or athletically where they receive a free ride to an often, 6-figure tuition?

What about the 99% of the athletes who r on b-ball, football, track, swimming, golf, and other club sports that are NCAA regulated, who have zero shot of having a professional career in said sports, but r using this opportunity to graduate & further themselves elsewhere; is that exploitation?

So the NIL money that’s now being offered, received…since students r now considered employees, is that taxed? Better yet, is their room, board, scholarship now taxable since they are no longer considered a student? Do they no longer have to attend class or keep up a certain GPA as a free lance employee, like the ringers who were used in the 1800-early 1900’s to help Yale & the Ivys secure championships? Can they now be fired or kicked off a team for any reason?

There’s a lot of ?’s I have from this ruling, & I believe they r trying to do this w/ best intentions, as it’s true, the NCAA holding students’ NIL hostage while profiting was bull chit. HOWEVER, I recall reading upon Dr Spock, & how he was the foremost voice to parents, criticizing them 4 disciplining their children. Those children took full advantage & became disrespectful little brats which transcended society; it was later where he admitted he made a grave mistake AFTER the consequences lent itself.

The moral is w/ how things r going, imo, this is a grave mistake for the overall health of CFB.
College football as we know it is already dead. These are professional athletes at this point.

I was never against the concept of NIL, but I knew if they didn't put restrictions in place, we'd end up where we are now.

i also hated how people treated the benefits these players receive as nothing, because most college athletes aren't getting NIL deals and benefit greatly from their scholarship packages. That could be lost in all this. Too late to go back now. The flood gates have already been opened.
 
Things are going great for Indianapolis!!

US National Labor Relations Board rules NCAA violated athletes' labor rights; court meetings likely: reports

I don’t think you will be asked to be involved in this situation due to a disturbing picture circulating around social media from your college days

1671234679661.gif
 
Back
Top