NCAA Oversight Committee proposes New Penalties for Transfers who unenroll....

[Hoyacane1620]

 

[Cribby]

How cute the NCAA must’ve went to Aspen Dental and got a few implants.

 

[cookies]

 

[MedleyCane]

WTF?
As much as I hate players bolting on their teams in this manner, this sounds like an overreaction.
In this sense it reminds me of players getting suspended for targeting.
Hard no on this proposal.

 

[EudocimusAlbus]

But but, it's all about the student athlete...what a crock of ****

 

[CreativeCane]

And what is the penalty for schools who refuse to follow the rules and put said players in the portal?

 

[PeterNorth]

Really? How about:

- The NCAA would be prohibited from all football and administrated duties through the sixth contest of the season.
- The NCAA would give 20% of its football revenues to fund athletic departments.
- The NCAA would be required to lose the number of football playoff selection committe member spots by five for next season, regardless of the head selection committee member's status.

 

[CreamCityCane]

Not a lawyer and I did not stay in a holiday inn express last night... This looks like the NCAA and member institutions have recognized they cannot stop the players from moving and so the penalties will be levied on the coaches (employees) and program (member institution) instead.

But, doesn't that still violate anti-trust if the end effect is essentially freezing out student athlete movement?

 

[johnnytsunami01]

But is it enforceable?

 

[TheOriginalCane]

How cute the NCAA must’ve went to Aspen Dental and got a few implants.

Which will be knocked the **** out of their (collective) mouth the first time a lawsuit is filed...

 

[TheOriginalCane]

But is it enforceable?

Not once the courts get ahold of it. And/or read the Supreme Court ruling in NCAA v. Alston.

 

[Ispyin]

And what is the penalty for schools who refuse to follow the rules and put said players in the portal?

they get stuck living in wisconsin

 

[Ispyin]

But is it enforceable?

as easy as trying to hold jello

 

[BigDikDaddyFromCincinnati]

as easy as trying to hold jello

I believe Tootsies is a good place to practice holding "jello" although a lot of their offerings are on the firmer silicone side, if ya know what I mean....

 

[PennsylvaniaCane]

Not once the courts get ahold of it. And/or read the Supreme Court ruling in NCAA v. Alston.

I’m not a lawyer but to me the back door nature of it presents way worse than if they just came out and said any player who transfers out of the window has to sit a year.

 

[JamesQuall]

How cute the NCAA must’ve went to Aspen Dental and got a few implants.

You have a student that attends a university but decides to transfer the next semester to a university who will benefit the student more for the next semester? The NCAA and the rest of the country say this is logical and what happens all the time.

You have a student athlete that is held hostage by his current school and refuses to put the paperwork in for him to transfer? The NCAA says this is perfectly ok.

The "Xavier Lucas Rule" now allows the NCAA to say "nuh uh! Your new school owes us 10-20 million dollars and they lose 5 scholarship spots."

Absolutely laughable. The NCAA must be run by dudes older and less lucid than Mitch McConnell.