Mario, please retain all your defensive coaches

Joined
Aug 22, 2024
Messages
39
Reading some of the reactions here, you’d think everyone expects Tecmo Bowl: call the right play, score a touchdown; call the right defense, force a turnover. Canes win 119-0.

Real opponents have good players and good coaches, too. They prepare, exploit, and make plays.

One reason I started paying closer attention to statistics was the 2017 season. Richt had us 10-0. We had just beat VT, ND and UVA convincingly in a row. I couldn’t understand why analysts weren’t seeing the beginning of another 2000-2003 run. Then came Pitt, Clemson, and Wisconsin. The turnover chain and the winning streak were fun, but analysts saw things I did not.

Here is advanced box score from Duke’s perspective and perhaps it can give us some insights we miss during the ups and downs of the game. The numbers in parentheses show how Duke's performance differed from its season averages entering the game. 1st: Duke finished with an 8% performance win expectancy. Yet much of the discussion centers on zero sacks, blown coverages, and Nate Sheppard two long runs and three endzone taunts. Not to mention blown blocking assignments, which I won't discuss as this is about the defensive performance and coaching.

Here’s what Miami’s defense accomplished during the game:
  • 4.8 yards per pass attempt, down roughly 30% from Duke’s 6.9 average. Miami achieved that without sack yardage lowering the number.
  • Duke's 130 yards rushing yards are down 52 yards from its average
  • 24% runs were stuffed at or behind the line of scrimmage up 4% on Duke's average
  • 0.07 passing Expected Points Average per play, down roughly 77% from Duke’s 0.30 average.
  • 22% success on passing downs, down from 32%.
  • 0.00 early-down EPA, down from 0.17 that Duke averages. Miami D's YTD average is 0.10 this is a huge win as FBS avg is 0.08
  • Scoring opportunities on 40% of possessions, down from 54%.
  • 16% havoc against Duke’s offense, up from the 12% its opponents had averaged.
  • Six pass breakups, compared with the 3.9 Duke’s opponents had averaged, also 6 PBUs is double the amount Hurricanes avg YTD.
Duke attempted 13 more passes than avg and still finished below its average passing performance. The offense everyone wanted us to sack, entered the game allowing half a sack per game.

There are things to clean up. The explosive runs count. Duke finished its scoring opportunities. Its overall success rate was slightly above its season average. That's fair - but that's not what I hear. Miami dented their offense and defense performances, they bent to Miami's will. So yes, sign me up for holding Duke to 4.8 yards per pass attempt across 44 attempts over obtaining sack highlights.

Glossary
EPA - expected points added, is the difference between expected points after each play. A good play adds EPA and a bad play subtracts it. For instane a 4 yard agin on 3rd and 3 is adding while a 4 yard gain on 3rd and 7 is subtracting.
Success= Staying on schedule usually 50% of the yards to gain on 1st down, 70% on 2nd down and 100% on 3rd and 4th down. For example a series where you gain 1 yard on 1st down, fail; 6 yards on 2nd down, success; 2 yards on 3rd down, fail; 1 yard on 4th down, success - is 50% success.Scoring Opportunities - offense having a snap inside the defense's 35 yard line or scoring a touchdown from 36+
Havoc = tackles for loss, pass breakups and forced fumbles
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot 2026-11-18 at 8.26.46 AM.png
    Screenshot 2026-11-18 at 8.26.46 AM.png
    325.9 KB · Views: 0
  • Screenshot 2026-11-18 at 8.28.14 AM.png
    Screenshot 2026-11-18 at 8.28.14 AM.png
    278.9 KB · Views: 0
Duke was an improvement, but they are one dimensional.
Exactly! Duke’s QB stinks. They rely on one player, and we couldn’t stop him all day. They have no talent on the outside to challenge us, plus their QB missed a bunch of open throws. Their defense is decent though for who they have on their roster
 
Reading some of the reactions here, you’d think everyone expects Tecmo Bowl: call the right play, score a touchdown; call the right defense, force a turnover. Canes win 119-0.

Real opponents have good players and good coaches, too. They prepare, exploit, and make plays.

One reason I started paying closer attention to statistics was the 2017 season. Richt had us 10-0. We had just beat VT, ND and UVA convincingly in a row. I couldn’t understand why analysts weren’t seeing the beginning of another 2000-2003 run. Then came Pitt, Clemson, and Wisconsin. The turnover chain and the winning streak were fun, but analysts saw things I did not.

Here is advanced box score from Duke’s perspective and perhaps it can give us some insights we miss during the ups and downs of the game. The numbers in parentheses show how Duke's performance differed from its season averages entering the game. 1st: Duke finished with an 8% performance win expectancy. Yet much of the discussion centers on zero sacks, blown coverages, and Nate Sheppard two long runs and three endzone taunts. Not to mention blown blocking assignments, which I won't discuss as this is about the defensive performance and coaching.

Here’s what Miami’s defense accomplished during the game:
  • 4.8 yards per pass attempt, down roughly 30% from Duke’s 6.9 average. Miami achieved that without sack yardage lowering the number.
  • Duke's 130 yards rushing yards are down 52 yards from its average
  • 24% runs were stuffed at or behind the line of scrimmage up 4% on Duke's average
  • 0.07 passing Expected Points Average per play, down roughly 77% from Duke’s 0.30 average.
  • 22% success on passing downs, down from 32%.
  • 0.00 early-down EPA, down from 0.17 that Duke averages. Miami D's YTD average is 0.10 this is a huge win as FBS avg is 0.08
  • Scoring opportunities on 40% of possessions, down from 54%.
  • 16% havoc against Duke’s offense, up from the 12% its opponents had averaged.
  • Six pass breakups, compared with the 3.9 Duke’s opponents had averaged, also 6 PBUs is double the amount Hurricanes avg YTD.
Duke attempted 13 more passes than avg and still finished below its average passing performance. The offense everyone wanted us to sack, entered the game allowing half a sack per game.

There are things to clean up. The explosive runs count. Duke finished its scoring opportunities. Its overall success rate was slightly above its season average. That's fair - but that's not what I hear. Miami dented their offense and defense performances, they bent to Miami's will. So yes, sign me up for holding Duke to 4.8 yards per pass attempt across 44 attempts over obtaining sack highlights.

Glossary
EPA - expected points added, is the difference between expected points after each play. A good play adds EPA and a bad play subtracts it. For instane a 4 yard agin on 3rd and 3 is adding while a 4 yard gain on 3rd and 7 is subtracting.
Success= Staying on schedule usually 50% of the yards to gain on 1st down, 70% on 2nd down and 100% on 3rd and 4th down. For example a series where you gain 1 yard on 1st down, fail; 6 yards on 2nd down, success; 2 yards on 3rd down, fail; 1 yard on 4th down, success - is 50% success.Scoring Opportunities - offense having a snap inside the defense's 35 yard line or scoring a touchdown from 36+
Havoc = tackles for loss, pass breakups and forced fumbles
Good stuff.
 
Reading some of the reactions here, you’d think everyone expects Tecmo Bowl: call the right play, score a touchdown; call the right defense, force a turnover. Canes win 119-0.

Real opponents have good players and good coaches, too. They prepare, exploit, and make plays.

One reason I started paying closer attention to statistics was the 2017 season. Richt had us 10-0. We had just beat VT, ND and UVA convincingly in a row. I couldn’t understand why analysts weren’t seeing the beginning of another 2000-2003 run. Then came Pitt, Clemson, and Wisconsin. The turnover chain and the winning streak were fun, but analysts saw things I did not.

Here is advanced box score from Duke’s perspective and perhaps it can give us some insights we miss during the ups and downs of the game. The numbers in parentheses show how Duke's performance differed from its season averages entering the game. 1st: Duke finished with an 8% performance win expectancy. Yet much of the discussion centers on zero sacks, blown coverages, and Nate Sheppard two long runs and three endzone taunts. Not to mention blown blocking assignments, which I won't discuss as this is about the defensive performance and coaching.

Here’s what Miami’s defense accomplished during the game:
  • 4.8 yards per pass attempt, down roughly 30% from Duke’s 6.9 average. Miami achieved that without sack yardage lowering the number.
  • Duke's 130 yards rushing yards are down 52 yards from its average
  • 24% runs were stuffed at or behind the line of scrimmage up 4% on Duke's average
  • 0.07 passing Expected Points Average per play, down roughly 77% from Duke’s 0.30 average.
  • 22% success on passing downs, down from 32%.
  • 0.00 early-down EPA, down from 0.17 that Duke averages. Miami D's YTD average is 0.10 this is a huge win as FBS avg is 0.08
  • Scoring opportunities on 40% of possessions, down from 54%.
  • 16% havoc against Duke’s offense, up from the 12% its opponents had averaged.
  • Six pass breakups, compared with the 3.9 Duke’s opponents had averaged, also 6 PBUs is double the amount Hurricanes avg YTD.
Duke attempted 13 more passes than avg and still finished below its average passing performance. The offense everyone wanted us to sack, entered the game allowing half a sack per game.

There are things to clean up. The explosive runs count. Duke finished its scoring opportunities. Its overall success rate was slightly above its season average. That's fair - but that's not what I hear. Miami dented their offense and defense performances, they bent to Miami's will. So yes, sign me up for holding Duke to 4.8 yards per pass attempt across 44 attempts over obtaining sack highlights.

Glossary
EPA - expected points added, is the difference between expected points after each play. A good play adds EPA and a bad play subtracts it. For instane a 4 yard agin on 3rd and 3 is adding while a 4 yard gain on 3rd and 7 is subtracting.
Success= Staying on schedule usually 50% of the yards to gain on 1st down, 70% on 2nd down and 100% on 3rd and 4th down. For example a series where you gain 1 yard on 1st down, fail; 6 yards on 2nd down, success; 2 yards on 3rd down, fail; 1 yard on 4th down, success - is 50% success.Scoring Opportunities - offense having a snap inside the defense's 35 yard line or scoring a touchdown from 36+
Havoc = tackles for loss, pass breakups and forced fumbles
Prepare for the emotional women cosplaying as men to come out with pitchforks for this one.

They hate data and facts. Love emotional **** though.

Great write up. Too many of these “fans” expect video games to translate to reality.
 
We made Duke throw 44 times. They average 28 pass attempt per game. Held them to 17 points until the waning moments.

Whoever doesn't recognize this as a good and encouraging defensive performance is just an a-hole who is never satisfied.
It was encouraging, proving my point a little there though
 
While I genuinely appreciate the analytical approach, when this is literally your first bullet point when trying to explain something, you kind of lose all credibility:

  • 4.8 yards per pass attempt, down roughly 30% from Duke’s 6.9 average. Miami achieved that without sack yardage lowering the number.

Sacks/sack yardage have nothing to do with yards per pass attempt. Yards per pass attempt is the number of passing yards divided by pass attempts. If you get sacked, you don't attempt a pass. If you get sacked, in college, it's considered a rushing attempt for the QB, and your rushing yards decrease. Sacks have zero correlation to yards per attempt.

So, again, I do appreciate the detailed data, but you gotta make sure it makes sense before you try to use it to convince people.

It was a "better" defensive performance. Not great, not even very good, but better than what we've seen the last few weeks. Before I throw a party, I'd like to see it happen against a quarterback who might not realize he's actually a lefty.
 
Look at who Duke has played and then get back to us with how impressive the variances actually are/were.

And I’m not saying Hetherman should be fired. But we absolutely have significant issues defensively - the status quo is not close to good enough.
 
It was encouraging, proving my point a little there though
Oh I wasn't replying to your post specifically or calling you out. More so agreeing on the one dimensional front.

The Nate Sheppard explosive plays were a bummer but we should celebrate forcing Eget into 42 pass attempts.
 
Reading some of the reactions here, you’d think everyone expects Tecmo Bowl: call the right play, score a touchdown; call the right defense, force a turnover. Canes win 119-0.

Real opponents have good players and good coaches, too. They prepare, exploit, and make plays.

One reason I started paying closer attention to statistics was the 2017 season. Richt had us 10-0. We had just beat VT, ND and UVA convincingly in a row. I couldn’t understand why analysts weren’t seeing the beginning of another 2000-2003 run. Then came Pitt, Clemson, and Wisconsin. The turnover chain and the winning streak were fun, but analysts saw things I did not.

Here is advanced box score from Duke’s perspective and perhaps it can give us some insights we miss during the ups and downs of the game. The numbers in parentheses show how Duke's performance differed from its season averages entering the game. 1st: Duke finished with an 8% performance win expectancy. Yet much of the discussion centers on zero sacks, blown coverages, and Nate Sheppard two long runs and three endzone taunts. Not to mention blown blocking assignments, which I won't discuss as this is about the defensive performance and coaching.

Here’s what Miami’s defense accomplished during the game:
  • 4.8 yards per pass attempt, down roughly 30% from Duke’s 6.9 average. Miami achieved that without sack yardage lowering the number.
  • Duke's 130 yards rushing yards are down 52 yards from its average
  • 24% runs were stuffed at or behind the line of scrimmage up 4% on Duke's average
  • 0.07 passing Expected Points Average per play, down roughly 77% from Duke’s 0.30 average.
  • 22% success on passing downs, down from 32%.
  • 0.00 early-down EPA, down from 0.17 that Duke averages. Miami D's YTD average is 0.10 this is a huge win as FBS avg is 0.08
  • Scoring opportunities on 40% of possessions, down from 54%.
  • 16% havoc against Duke’s offense, up from the 12% its opponents had averaged.
  • Six pass breakups, compared with the 3.9 Duke’s opponents had averaged, also 6 PBUs is double the amount Hurricanes avg YTD.
Duke attempted 13 more passes than avg and still finished below its average passing performance. The offense everyone wanted us to sack, entered the game allowing half a sack per game.

There are things to clean up. The explosive runs count. Duke finished its scoring opportunities. Its overall success rate was slightly above its season average. That's fair - but that's not what I hear. Miami dented their offense and defense performances, they bent to Miami's will. So yes, sign me up for holding Duke to 4.8 yards per pass attempt across 44 attempts over obtaining sack highlights.

Glossary
EPA - expected points added, is the difference between expected points after each play. A good play adds EPA and a bad play subtracts it. For instane a 4 yard agin on 3rd and 3 is adding while a 4 yard gain on 3rd and 7 is subtracting.
Success= Staying on schedule usually 50% of the yards to gain on 1st down, 70% on 2nd down and 100% on 3rd and 4th down. For example a series where you gain 1 yard on 1st down, fail; 6 yards on 2nd down, success; 2 yards on 3rd down, fail; 1 yard on 4th down, success - is 50% success.Scoring Opportunities - offense having a snap inside the defense's 35 yard line or scoring a touchdown from 36+
Havoc = tackles for loss, pass breakups and forced fumbles
Whether someone agrees or disagrees is one thing.... but everyone should appreciate the research and info you have presented.
 
Prepare for the emotional women cosplaying as men to come out with pitchforks for this one.

They hate data and facts. Love emotional **** though.

Great write up. Too many of these “fans” expect video games to translate to reality.

Dude when Dono said on Locked on Canes. Most of our fans learned football from playing video games.

I realized I need to stop arguing with half of you fans🤣🤣🤣🤣

I went outside and played football and learned the game through my ears.

I really feel bad for all of you that learned football form a video game….I really do.
You understand the game but not like most of us. It’s not the same
Sorry

It explains itself but yall better stop saying.I know what I see because people who played are not in the same category. As the people who make these weird *** comments. It’s silly 🤷🏾‍♂️
 
Back
Top