forums

Malik Rosier NFL QB?

hoops156 said:
i think rosen was the better prospect coming out of college (than tua) and if he isn't, you tank for sunshine imo not tua
Click to expand...
Absolutely. I have never been sold on Rosen because I've always felt hes very turn over prone & VERY fragile. But I like him as a prospect more than tua. I'd take herbert sunshine or fromm over tua. Just think about it. If tua was on say Arizona or some school like that would his game get anywhere near the attention he gets at bama? Not even close. Hes good. Dont get me wrong. But hes nowhere near a top pick or a amazing prospect.
 
Advertisement
dsddcane said:
Absolutely. I have never been sold on Rosen because I've always felt hes very turn over prone & VERY fragile. But I like him as a prospect more than tua. I'd take herbert sunshine or fromm over tua. Just think about it. If tua was on say Arizona or some school like that would his game get anywhere near the attention he gets at bama? Not even close. Hes good. Dont get me wrong. But hes nowhere near a top pick or a amazing prospect.
Click to expand...

He's also a lefty. Off the top of my head I think he'll be the only one in the league. How's it gonna work out for him when he goes where there's no offensive line outside of.. maybe LT? And even if we give them LT, Tua's blindside will be RT. Good luck with that.
 
SCarolina Ibis said:
He's also a lefty. Off the top of my head I think he'll be the only one in the league. How's it gonna work out for him when he goes where there's no offensive line outside of.. maybe LT? And even if we give them LT, Tua's blindside will be RT. Good luck with that.
Click to expand...
Only way the dolphins could do worse is hire Dave ****** gettleman as GM than your season turns into tank for Daniel Jones! You think losing is bad for a teams morale. Just wait till they find out all that losing results in a gm in over his head drafting a qb in over his... atleast **** be able to do quantum physics and ****. Hes in the perfect place to transition to wall street!
 
Tua has tons of ability. Great arm, excellent anticipation and accuracy. Athleticism to escape the pocket. The one thing that scares me about drafting him is the fact that he's rarely pressured at Alabama. Give any decent QB all the time in the world to find a receiver and they'll light it up. It's no coincidence that the two best defensive lines Alabama faced last year (Georgia and Clemson) made Tua look very average. No matter what team he ends up on, he's never going to have the ridiculous talent advantage over opponents that he has at Bama.
 
dsddcane said:
Absolutely. I have never been sold on Rosen because I've always felt hes very turn over prone & VERY fragile. But I like him as a prospect more than tua. I'd take herbert sunshine or fromm over tua. Just think about it. If tua was on say Arizona or some school like that would his game get anywhere near the attention he gets at bama? Not even close. Hes good. Dont get me wrong. But hes nowhere near a top pick or a amazing prospect.
Click to expand...

Agree. NEver understood the tanking for Tua stuff. He's a great college QB and I love his intangibles but I'm not convinced yet.

As for Rosen, he's a big meh to me. Nice game, but I see him more of a product of the system. I see him as a manufactured QB. Kid who comes from a lot of money and was enrolled in the top QB camps as a kid - blessed to have good athletic genes, etc. When you combine those things, I think it's pretty easy to become a very good QB. But, I see him lacking fire, drive, leadership out there. He's a 7-9/8-8 guy.
 
AUcane said:
Agree. NEver understood the tanking for Tua stuff. He's a great college QB and I love his intangibles but I'm not convinced yet.

As for Rosen, he's a big meh to me. Nice game, but I see him more of a product of the system. I see him as a manufactured QB. Kid who comes from a lot of money and was enrolled in the top QB camps as a kid - blessed to have good athletic genes, etc. When you combine those things, I think it's pretty easy to become a very good QB. But, I see him lacking fire, drive, leadership out there. He's a 7-9/8-8 guy.
Click to expand...
100% my outlook too.
 
AUcane said:
Agree. NEver understood the tanking for Tua stuff. He's a great college QB and I love his intangibles but I'm not convinced yet.

As for Rosen, he's a big meh to me. Nice game, but I see him more of a product of the system. I see him as a manufactured QB. Kid who comes from a lot of money and was enrolled in the top QB camps as a kid - blessed to have good athletic genes, etc. When you combine those things, I think it's pretty easy to become a very good QB. But, I see him lacking fire, drive, leadership out there. He's a 7-9/8-8 guy.
Click to expand...
My only curiosity with him at this point is how will he respond to the public shame... will it put a fire in him or will he do exactly what I suspect he will(like his clone Jimmy Clausen) & fold from the adversity. For his sake I hope he takes this as a lesson that it's a business & hes gotta get tough.
 
AUcane said:
Agree. NEver understood the tanking for Tua stuff. He's a great college QB and I love his intangibles but I'm not convinced yet.

As for Rosen, he's a big meh to me. Nice game, but I see him more of a product of the system. I see him as a manufactured QB. Kid who comes from a lot of money and was enrolled in the top QB camps as a kid - blessed to have good athletic genes, etc. When you combine those things, I think it's pretty easy to become a very good QB. But, I see him lacking fire, drive, leadership out there. He's a 7-9/8-8 guy.
Click to expand...

I like Rosen.

However, I can already see his career flaming out...he's had zero consistency with an OC throughout his life. He might be damaged goods before he even gets to a situation where he has the same OC for two years. A shame. He's got arm talent and moxy.
 
Advertisement
1mg of Epi said:
Still don’t understand why anybody on this board would support a team that hosted a Tim Tebow suck off... on the Hurricanes home field.
Click to expand...
I think it has to do with someone's priorities. My stepson is a UM grad but was a Fins fan first, has had Fins season tickets (never Canes) and sports a Fins tattoo... where's his priority?
Fins have dissed Cane players for many years and the Tebow blow-fest was the straw that broke the camel's back, IMO.
 
gruntking said:
I think it has to do with someone's priorities. My stepson is a UM grad but was a Fins fan first, has had Fins season tickets (never Canes) and sports a Fins tattoo... where's his priority?
Fins have dissed Cane players for many years and the Tebow blow-fest was the straw that broke the camel's back, IMO.
Click to expand...
I suppose you’re right. I guess the guys that can stomach Teblow Fest are dolphins first Fans.
 
Back
Top