Malachi Toney should be a Heisman Finalist

[nvlahos]

his stats this year are comparable to Jeremiah smith plus he throws passes and returns punts.
If they played together, it would have been something special

What could’ve been… ****

That would’ve been like Moss and Dre on the same team

 

[Pentagon Cane]

No one in the past 50 years has done as many different things at such a high level.

So Maybe Paul Horning, who played at Notre Dame in the 50’s and won a Heisman

Plus, Toney is an outstanding and willing blocker.

 

[FuriousStyles]

Who is his best comparison? He's just unreal and seemingly never tired.

David Palmer comes to mind.

 

[TooWise]

He’s gonna win it his junior year & we’re gonna be a championship contender

 

[shumbly33]

Who is his best comparison? He's just unreal and seemingly never tired.

Antoine Randel-El is who comes to mind for me

 

[KANE]

Santana Moss

The impact is certainly there. Idk if we’ve EVER seen anything like Baby Jesus. He’s different….. and think about it, he legit could STILL be doing this **** to high school kids, right now. Glad to have the young man in Orange and Green. Go Canes!!!

 

[77cane]

I remember a recruiting show comparing him to former Carolina Panther Steve Smith, when Smith was a college freshman. Smith was the same size( height and weight as Toney is now.)

 

[AtlAtty]

Antoine Randel-El is who comes to mind for me

So 30 years ago? That’s a really good comp.

 

[RozayCane]

I remember a recruiting show comparing him to former Carolina Panther Steve Smith, when Smith was a college freshman. Smith was the same size( height and weight as Toney is now.)

He reminds me of AB., the Steelers AB, not his father AB (never seen pops games)

 

[insaneinthecane]

duke and mali both got that Liberty City blood as well.

How do you figure?

Duke was a Norland guy in an area that was once considered Carol City and Mali is from Broward. I’m not saying they don’t have Liberty City ties but if they do, please share the deets!

 

[insaneinthecane]

Who is his best comparison? He's just unreal and seemingly never tired.

He took a beating today. He was everywhere and welcomed the contact. He’s only 18 so his bounce back will be minimal but man is this kid the goods. Probably the most complete football player that I’ve seen in a very long time. Dudes football IQ is bananas! Gotta hope he gets a chance to show out in the playoffs!!

 

[insaneinthecane]

He’s Peter Warrick

Peter Warrick wishes he was Malachi Toney!!!

 

[insaneinthecane]

He’s an offensive Sean Taylor....total wild man offensively.

Good comp

 

[insaneinthecane]

5-11, 188 is big?

He just turned 18 so 5’11 ain’t small. Dude might still be growing.

 

[RozayCane]

 

[E1k]

If we started the season maximizing him he would for sure be a finalist

 

[TheTruth305]

He’s Az-Zahir Hakim 2.0… IYKYK

 

[Udynasty]

 

[RozayCane]

 

[TheOriginalCane]

Malachi should absolutely be a Heisman finalist.

He is TWO receptions away from the ALL-TIME Miami single season recptions record.

He is THIRTY yards away from 1,000 yards. He is 203 yards away from the ALL-TIME Miami single season reception yardage record.

And that is completely separate from what he has done running the ball, passing the ball, and returning the ball.