Let's talk about Jarren...

[umiamifan1]

Based on practice reports (even going as far back as last season), it seems that Jarren Williams is consistently regarded as having the best arm talent in the QB room. "Most accurate" and "throws the prettiest ball" are two observations that I've seen attributed to him repeatedly so far throughout Spring and now Fall...so what exactly is he missing? Is it decision-making, feel for the game, lack of pocket awareness? I would assume he has decent legs and can run if needed, but I also recognize that he is probably inferior to Tate in this regard. Where does Kosi outshine him though? Any insight here would be appreciated.

 

[OrangeBowlMagic]

Based on practice reports (even going as far back as last season), it seems that Jarren Williams is consistently regarded as having the best arm talent in the QB room. "Most accurate" and "throws the prettiest ball" are two observations that I've seen attributed to him repeatedly so far throughout Spring and now Fall...so what exactly is he missing? Is it decision-making, feel for the game, lack of pocket awareness? I would assume he has decent legs and can run if needed, but I also recognize that he is probably inferior to Tate in this regard. Where does Kosi outshine him though? Any insight here would be appreciated.

Experience. The only way you start a kid with zero experience on national TV against your most hated rival in a season opener is because he's either miles better than your other options or you have no other choice.

He's not miles better (yet), and Enos has another choice (2, actually). It may be Jarren's time soon, but it's not yet.

And before everyone yells about Tate's experience, he has played in 6 college games, he has played in something other than total mop-up duty, and he's a year older aka more exposure to the college game. I'd certainly not call him "experienced", but he's got more than Jarren.

 

[90scane]

Hasn't been able to handle the pressure in a live pocket. It may come with time and the only way to learn the skill is being put in the fire. The speed on a college game: having to go through the reads much faster due to a 2-3second pass rush.

 

[skillydoo]

He's missing the nod from Enos.

 

[Canesfan1899]

Based on practice reports (even going as far back as last season), it seems that Jarren Williams is consistently regarded as having the best arm talent in the QB room. "Most accurate" and "throws the prettiest ball" are two observations that I've seen attributed to him repeatedly so far throughout Spring and now Fall...so what exactly is he missing? Is it decision-making, feel for the game, lack of pocket awareness? I would assume he has decent legs and can run if needed, but I also recognize that he is probably inferior to Tate in this regard. Where does Kosi outshine him though? Any insight here would be appreciated.

There are a lot of guys that can sling the ball that didn't make good QB's. Knowing where the ball is going, what the defense is giving you, and just having game experience are just important for a QB.

Ken Dorsey had a noodle arm and threw some absolute ducks, but he knew timing and where to go with the football.

 

[The Franchise]

Jaren might turn out to be a great QB, but throwing a “pretty ball” in the warmup session the media watches is meaningless.

 

[MotoSniper]

Based on practice reports (even going as far back as last season), it seems that Jarren Williams is consistently regarded as having the best arm talent in the QB room. "Most accurate" and "throws the prettiest ball" are two observations that I've seen attributed to him repeatedly so far throughout Spring and now Fall...so what exactly is he missing? Is it decision-making, feel for the game, lack of pocket awareness? I would assume he has decent legs and can run if needed, but I also recognize that he is probably inferior to Tate in this regard. Where does Kosi outshine him though? Any insight here would be appreciated.

Maturity apparently...but that is fixable

 

[hoops156]

Jaren might turn out to be a great QB, but throwing a “pretty ball” in the warmup session the media watches is meaningless.

that and DSDcane alluded to off field issues hes recently had (manny mentioned this either directly or indirectly (cant remember which) in an interview a little while back (i think before fall camp started). if he can get his off field stuff together, **** end up being good wherever he goes (if he doesnt start here).

 

[blackvern]

Definitely lacked confidence spring game and scrimmage, was indecisive at times, prepration last year as a 3rd stringer was lackluster.

 

[hoops156]

Definitely lacked confidence spring game and scrimmage, was indecisive at times, prepration last year as a 3rd stringer was lackluster.

prep from every QB last year lackluster

 

[umiamifan1]

I really don't have a dog in this race, I'm just happy to hear that all three guys have reportedly improved significantly since the beginning of camp. The significance of replacing Lil Richt with a guy as experienced as Enos is absolutely massive and cannot be overstated.

 

[305to954]

Jamarcus Russell probably threw the prettiest ball..see where that got him..you have to have a feel for the game. That comes with Timing and understanding of the offense

 

[hoops156]

Jamarcus Russell probably threw the prettiest ball..see where that got him..you have to have a feel for the game. That comes with Timing and understanding of the offense

in fairness, Codeine didnt help lol

 

[305to954]

in fairness, Codeine didnt help lol

He still could spin that ***** tho lol

 

[Cribby]

in fairness, Codeine didnt help lol

And doughnuts

 

[Golsen82]

If only jarren had Martells attitude

 

[Stylie]

in fairness, Codeine didnt help lol

Purple drank is overrated. Stick to the weed kids.

 

[theibisrules]

Based on practice reports (even going as far back as last season), it seems that Jarren Williams is consistently regarded as having the best arm talent in the QB room. "Most accurate" and "throws the prettiest ball" are two observations that I've seen attributed to him repeatedly so far throughout Spring and now Fall...so what exactly is he missing? Is it decision-making, feel for the game, lack of pocket awareness? I would assume he has decent legs and can run if needed, but I also recognize that he is probably inferior to Tate in this regard. Where does Kosi outshine him though? Any insight here would be appreciated.

Kosi may be a better runner as well.

 

[hoops156]

If only jarren had Martells attitude

imagine our shock when manny names matoocha the starter.

 

[Genghis Cane]

My GUESS is that Jarren is still a little behind in the mental aspect of the game. Whether it’s diagnosing coverages, going through progressions, or making quick decisions, he might be a step behind.

It doesn’t mean he can’t improve, but at this standpoint Enos is looking for a guy he can trust in week one against UF.

I remember watching the QB1 series featuring Martell and there was a scene where he pulled out a binder that he started making for himself in middle school that highlighted different coverages and where the ball should be going depending on what the QB sees. I think that’s one area where he’s a cut above the rest.

The problem is he’s not as consistent or talented as a passer as Jarren. It’s going to be interesting to see if he can get better in that department, or if Jarren can improve his mental understanding of the game.

I think the QB race is going to come down to the two of them. I’ll support whoever wins, though, as should everybody else on this board. I believe they both have what it takes to get us to 10 wins and a coastal division crown with this schedule. And for what it’s worth, I believe Perry can do the same.