Keepin It Real: My Post Game Analysis…

cribby told you the routes were an issue from camp. a lot of it takes way too long to develop imo. for 100th time, we need to pick up the pace. idc who is coaching, but this pace has to pick up asap. we look slow and lack urgency out there. we also dont know how to manage a clock

I agree with the pace. I'm not sure on the routes.

I fully understand they can be long developing, but TVD had also had time in the pocket. It's one thing to not have protection and attempt them vs the opposite. It's a combo of TVD + WR (what WR can't get open given 5+ seconds?) + Gattis not together.

Now, if TVD and/or the WRs just can't do it Gattis has to make the QB change or almost entirely change his offense. Is it more counterproductive to change the entire offense? I don't know. I sure like the OL and RB play though.
 
Advertisement
I agree with the pace. I'm not sure on the routes.

I fully understand they can be long developing, but TVD had also had time in the pocket. It's one thing to not have protection and attempt them vs the opposite. It's a combo of TVD + WR + Gattis not together.

Now, if TVD and/or the WRs just can't do it Gattis has to make the QB change or almost entirely change his offense. Is it more counterproductive to change the entire offense? I don't know. I sure like the OL and RB play though.
I dont think TVD is comfortable in this offense. it shows when you watch him and the WRs are playing like trash as well. they're not on the same page either. its time to reinstall some of lashlees plays/concepts in there to get a comfort level for these guys imo.

Garcia hasn't played anyone outside of a few snaps against two scrubs. he may be the answer but he isnt right now. the answer is to fix the offense to fit TVD and the WRs.

gattis calls a better run game than lashlee did. we still didnt get that explosive run and would've liked to use rooster in the pass game on the ones that Parrish got
 
I was at the game. Texas A&M’s secondary was just much better than our WR. Nobody was open. Period.

There is no scheme that could have fixed that. They were blanketing our receivers all night, tgeir CB’s and safeties were faster bigger and more athletic than our receivers and that was the difference.

If I fault Gattis for anything, it’s not running the ball MORE. We were pushing them back every play. We could have lined up and just pounded them, but we kept trying to force the pass and it never worked. Our OL looks good. But their defense was faster than our offense so we didn’t pop anything.

On Van Dyke, he would have had to make NFL throws to get the ball in some of those windows. He’s not a first round QB, doesn’t have that elite NFL accuracy, but this game is not on him. It’s on Stevenson for muffing a punt, missed/blocked field goals and **** special teams play, and on not having the horses at receiver
 
I dont think TVD is comfortable in this offense. it shows when you watch him and the WRs are playing like trash as well. they're not on the same page either. its time to reinstall some of lashlees plays/concepts in there to get a comfort level for these guys imo.

Garcia hasn't played anyone outside of a few snaps against two scrubs. he may be the answer but he isnt right now. the answer is to fix the offense to fit TVD and the WRs.

gattis calls a better run game than lashlee did. we still didnt get that explosive run and would've liked to use rooster in the pass game on the ones that Parrish got


Parrish vs Knighton in the passing game is a wash. Parrish is a very capable and proven receiving back he just had a horrible drop tonight. Knighton was also out for a while.

It is a conundrum....scrap your offense right now, all but admitting your QB is highly limited. Or keep instilling your philosophy and find someone who can run it.

With some of the reads TVD had tucking it, Brown may be the style Gattis wants to go to. We really don't know until these coaches really get their guys. We're working with years of Manny crootin here.

I'd seriously consider giving Garcia heavy snaps next week. More mobile than TVD and a live arm.
 
Parrish vs Knighton in the passing game is a wash. Parrish is a very capable and proven receiving back he just had a horrible drop tonight. Knighton was also out for a while.

It is a conundrum....scrap your offense right now, all but admitting your QB is highly limited. Or keep instilling your philosophy and find someone who can run it.
so there is where stubbornness kills seasons and careers. you have who you have. you gotta find a wya to make it work this season w these guys. you hide your QBs weaknesses w your scheme and play calling. hes not perfect but we know hes capable and can look like An all American. I think Rooster is just more explosive and more capable of breaking a big one which is why I prefer him in on passing downs. we lack that in our offense. we scored 9 points after running for 175 yards and controlling the clock. I said the app state way wouldn't win us the game. now, we did try to pass but we failed miserably (plenty of blame to go around here). either way, were three games in and the passing game hasn't clicked. seasons still young but if you dont change stuff up, its going to be a long season.
 
I was at the game. Texas A&M’s secondary was just much better than our WR. Nobody was open. Period.

There is no scheme that could have fixed that. They were blanketing our receivers all night, tgeir CB’s and safeties were faster bigger and more athletic than our receivers and that was the difference.

If I fault Gattis for anything, it’s not running the ball MORE. We were pushing them back every play. We could have lined up and just pounded them, but we kept trying to force the pass and it never worked. Our OL looks good. But their defense was faster than our offense so we didn’t pop anything.

On Van Dyke, he would have had to make NFL throws to get the ball in some of those windows. He’s not a first round QB, doesn’t have that elite NFL accuracy, but this game is not on him. It’s on Stevenson for muffing a punt, missed/blocked field goals and **** special teams play, and on not having the horses at receiver
They had 4 starters out most of the game in their secondary. I saw no double moves or anything to get them to respect our deep ball. Didn’t help that Van Overthrow Dyke didn’t give the go receiver a chance either.
 
so there is where stubbornness kills seasons and careers. you have who you have. you gotta find a wya to make it work this season w these guys. you hide your QBs weaknesses w your scheme and play calling. hes not perfect but we know hes capable and can look like An all American. I think Rooster is just more explosive and more capable of breaking a big one which is why I prefer him in on passing downs. we lack that in our offense. we scored 9 points after running for 175 yards and controlling the clock. I said the app state way wouldn't win us the game. now, we did try to pass but we failed miserably (plenty of blame to go around here). either way, were three games in and the passing game hasn't clicked. seasons still young but if you dont change stuff up, its going to be a long season.


Not to be combative but we also have three very different QBs in the room. If TVD is killing the offense you put on your big boy pants and make a tough decision. Happens all the time. TVD isn't immune. Saban benches Hurts and winds up with another ring.

I'll be interested in watching some of the slowmo breakdowns to come.
 
Advertisement
It's neural memory, there are no muscles in your hands. Granted, some muscle tissue but your fingers are controlled by your tendons. Always stretch & warm up before practice or performance, a stretched tendon is a terrible thing for musians or FB players.
I've played guitar and keybords for 60 years.
The few students i had,,, play from your heart, Stop thinking.
Oh well, Play on.......
It’s the typical Miami coaching syndrome of the last 20 years where they try to fit a square peg into a round hole. Our QB and WR’s are all like deer in headlights. Too much complex terminology, and slow developing routes.

Don’t give our QB and WR’s so much **** to have to think about, specially in the beginning 1/4 of the season, in a big time game, and they will play much better.

I’ve been a professional touring and studio musician for 35 plus years, and have taught guitar for many years too at a music institute. One of the things that I stress to my students is to not think, because when they stop to think of the next part of a song or composition, they will most likely mess up.

Muscle memory and repetition are key in playing freely and proficiently. Anything that requires great hand-to-eye coordination becomes infinitely more difficult when having to think. The more complicated the song/composition, the more repetition that is required.

It’s the same with football, the more complicated the system, the more repetition that is required to reach the level where they can play freely and not think too much or overthink things.

It’s been stated here that Gattis runs a very complex system with lots and lots of terminology. So what we’re seeing is guys playing tight and uncomfortable because they are overthinking everything instead of just playing.It's
 
It's neural memory, there are no muscles in your hands. Granted, some muscle tissue but your fingers are controlled by your tendons. Always stretch & warm up before practice or performance, a stretched tendon is a terrible thing for musians or FB players.
I've played guitar and keybords for 60 years.
The few students i had,,, play from your heart, Stop thinking.
Oh well, Play on.......
“Muscle memory” is a phrase that is used to describe the ability of any skilled person that is able to perform their chosen profession or talent at a high level through many hours of practice and repetition.

Most music teachers and professional musicians that I have known call it muscle memory when describing it. I can safely say that I’ve never, ever heard anyone in my field refer to it as “neural memory.”

Not saying that you’re wrong, just stating that it’s a phrase that is commonly used by most musicians to describe the ability to play freely without having to think through diligent and good practice habits.

I’m a proficient pianist, too. But my first instrument is guitar.

Also, playing from your heart is great advice. Use your ears above all, and play with soul and feel. Great technique usually allows for the aforementioned to be accomplished easier/quicker.
 
Justin Herbert was an unpolished raw QB under Mario. He went to the NFL and within 1 year became a NFL All Pro Caliber QB it's talked about all over NFL circles. It's one of the things I was concerned with. Gattis isn't a QB coach and Ponce has never really developed any quality QBs. Mario just isn't a good offensive coach. Luckily he's a really good recruiter, Team Builder and Team manager.
Site sources or cut the crap.

this is one of ghe dumbest fan made up narratives I’ve ever see “mAriO rUinED HeRbERt”

Mario coached one game in 2016 after Willie quit. He really took over in 2017

After 2018 the dolphins wanted to draft him ask the first QB off the board. But he decided to go back to school.


1663500885137.jpeg
 
"A Lashlee passing game coupled with this current running game would be lethal"

I completely agree with that statement. Hopefully he evolves to that. Even Saban eventually evolved so here is hoping our guy does as well.
Saban evolved years ago. It’s pretty clear what works now lol
 
…no candy coating anything here.

This was one of the worst passing game displays, tempo and clock management that I have ever witnessed.

Coming into this game, I had stated my concerns regarding the passing game in the first 2 weeks of the season, and unfortunately I was right on the money.

I don’t know how in just the span of a few months Mario and Gattis managed to ruin a gunslinger like TVD. But he looks like a totally different QB. It’s almost as if someone kidnapped the real VanDyke, and replaced him with a ****** doppelgänger.

QB: I feel terrible for TVD. We went from an uptempo offense that was simple, but extremely effective, with quick reads and routes in the passing game, to an offense that requires the WR to run for several seconds before the pass is even released. If I’m TVD, I’m ****ed, and let these ***kers know it. NO RPO’s or rhythm throws. Just terrible.

Grade: C+

RB’s: Our RB’s are not game breakers in this offense. It’s designed to churn out yards, and wear down our opponents. Parrish and Knighton did what they could, but as I stated before the game, this line isn’t built to bully defenses like aTm’s.

Grade: B-

TE’s: Overall played pretty well, even though Mallory’s holding penalty on that last drive killed any chance that we might have had. They should have been targeted a lot more, specially Arroyo and Skinner. Our WR’s are hot doo-doo. Bad game planning by Gattis and Mario.

Grace: C-

WR’s: An abomination! Pathetic! Soft as baby ****!

Grade: F

OL: Played better than I expected, considering the defense that we were up against. TVD had all day to throw on several occasions, but either he was out of rhythm on his throws, or the WR’s dropped the pass. The run blocking was solid for most of the night. Zion’s hold on the last drive was a killer.

Grade: Solid B-



Our defense gave a heroic effort, and should be disgusted with Mario, Gattis, the play calling, TVD, and the WR’s. They gave us a chance to win all game long, but the offensive coaches and the HC refused to help them. Steele called a brilliant game. A wasted effort is an understatement.

DL: Played a very solid game overall. Had some mistakes, but did yeoman’s work in holding these ***aloons to not much. The muffed punt by #2 was horrible. I feel bad for these kids. They played their hearts out. Taylor, Agude, Jackson and Moultrie played really well.

Grade: B-

LB’s: Our LB’s played very well in my opinion, all things considered. They made several TFL’s, and did a good job overall containing Achane and Amari Daniels. Flagg and Smith played what was probably their best game as Canes.

Grade: B

CB’s: Again, another unit that surprised me. The CB’s, including Ivey, played tight and aggressive coverage for most of the night. They limited the passing Aggie game, and broke up a number of passes. They also tackled well in space.

Grade: B+

S: Kinchens and James Williams played lights out. They covered and tackled really well all game long, with very little being given up by them. They also did a good job on Johnson when he tried to run. Not giving them an A because they didn’t have any interceptions.

Grade: B+

Special Teams: Putrid performance by the Field Goal unit. Unacceptable to have such a poor performance in such a big game. Tyrique’s blunder ended up being huge, as it led to a TD that should have never been. We would have only been trailing by 1 at the end, and would have only needed 3 to win. With the way our offense was shytting the bed, this was a game killer, to say the least.

The punting unit and KO coverage teams played well. This is the only thing that kept me from giving the ST’s the lowest grade possible.

Grade: D

Coaching: The play calling and clock management by the OC and HC were atrocious. They played not to lose, instead of to win. If they don’t make some serious adjustments to the WR routes and scheme more rhythm throws for TVD that take less time to develop, we will be a 4 loss team.

Steele and the rest of the defensive staff were ready to play, and had a great game plan. They played tough, inspired football for a majority of the game. Strong and Addae in particular had their dudes playing at a high level all game long.

Grade: B

Final Analysis: What many of us feared is now evident after only 3 games. TVD has regressed to unthinkable levels. The tempo is sloth like. The WR’s are soft, and can’t get any separation. They have hands of stone, and don’t block well downfield. I wonder who the WR coach is? Oh, that’s right, it’s the same OC that schemes and calls this abomination of an offense.

I already stated it, but will repeat it. If we keep on running this same bullshyt, Fred Flintstone offense and Mario refuses to play modern football, this team will lose at least 3 more games.

Neg away.

P.S. - and to the lunatic that said a couple of days ago that we would roll, 48-10.

Halloween GIF

Season 9 Middle Finger GIF by Shameless

umbrella middle finger GIF
I’m just glad you weren’t one of my HS teachers cause it looks like an “A” is tough to get.
 
Site sources or cut the crap.

this is one of ghe dumbest fan made up narratives I’ve ever see “mAriO rUinED HeRbERt”

Mario coached one game in 2016 after Willie quit. He really took over in 2017

After 2018 the dolphins wanted to draft him ask the first QB off the board. But he decided to go back to school.


View attachment 208689

Lots of fans on top of NFL draft guys said the reason Herbert was viewed as such a raw prospect coming into the draft was due to coaching at Oregon. Herbert threw a screen pass 31% of his completions as a senior QB, that's crazy. Go to any NFL draft forum or community and ask them about why no one seen Justin Herbert having this kind of success pre draft. That's only cause of Mike tannebaum lol.
 
Advertisement
Someone should pull up the receipts on this fan base options about Lashlee after the Clemson game or Semenhole game last year.....some of the same people praising him had a very different opinion. Not saying Grattis is better than Lashlee at all but it would show something about how our fan base thinks.

Spot on. Lashlee's passing attack was much better but the run game was awful. Hard to say we are any better or worse offensively up to this point.
 
It’s not just TVD, or Gattis scheme/playcalling, or the WRs, it’s all of the above a mixture of all 3. The passing game in General needs work in general and all 3 of those play a role.
 
They did not score a touchdown, or have any game breaking runs. Considering the horrible performance overall by the offense, B- is more than generous.

It's very generous.

Some people are very generous, but A&M didn't sell out to stop the run or even the pass. They played it safe all night long with two safeties sitting back there to take away anything down the field.

So the OL only had to deal with 4 down lineman most of the time. At times, there were only three. The backers were sitting and waiting on the run. Out backs talk what was available, but didn't do much of anything beyond that. You've gotta make someone miss their tackle, we didn't do that.

I'd say as a group, C at best. They were very average.
 
Back
Top