forums

I think its safe to say that we will finally stick with our QB room next year

Advertisement
edge said:
Ward wasn't recruited out of HS. Mensah had one offer. Both turned into stars. At what point does the University of Miami, who has all the resources available, land our own homegrown Ward or Mensah? This is QBU. Someone out of HS needs to take the reins. It is kinda getting ridiculous. Hopefully that is Coleman.
Click to expand...
I think Dawson has the crew he can develop a high school quarterback first
 
RedSquare said:
he's got it. a real gunslinger.

after one practice and seeing his HS press clippings, it's obvious:

he will beat out Emory and Judd this fall, and be the backup by week 3, and then will take over next year as QB1

oh wait, my mistake .... that was CIS last spring after Luke Nickel's first day
Click to expand...

That was me for sure with Nickel since his junior year of high school, i still believe in the kid and think he's going to dominate when the time come.
 
here is how much i care whether we stick with a qb room or portal it

the wolf of wall street idgaf GIF


Coaches got to figure it out. and money still talks too, every player and coach also thinks they are better than others, they will be the change.

Spot the **** ball, just don't give me another kirby freeman ever.
 
Advertisement
Ispyin said:
here is how much i care whether we stick with a qb room or portal it

the wolf of wall street idgaf GIF


Coaches got to figure it out. and money still talks too, every player and coach also thinks they are better than others, they will be the change.

Spot the **** ball, just don't give me another kirby freeman ever.
Click to expand...

Kirby Freeman was cheeks, but he led the largely forgotten great Canes moment when he led the game winning drive to beat FSU in 2007, and almost got killed doing it.
 
Firesite said:
Of course I understand this. I am just speculating and it will be fun to look back when it is time to decide who our future QB is. We will get to see who was right or wrong.
Click to expand...
Understood I feel you. My money is on Coleman but if he gets beat out by Luke we’re still in good hands imo 🙏🏾..you go portal again only if a Cam Ward type wants in again.
 
skyman said:
Portal QBs have given us a winning program and changed trajectory of program overall, also final 4 playoff teams, 3 of them were portal guys and its obviously the best way for a program to stay at a high level. Yea lets throw that away and gamble a season away so QB can develop.

Would be better off sending QB to fau/duke or something as a farming system.. :ibis-roflmao-sm3:
Click to expand...
one of the talking points back when ppl were starting threads about why Miami has underachieved so much since joining the ACC was subpar QB play @ the U compared to the Cream of the ACC like Clemson/FSU who both had dominant runs while we were down. I said a big common denominator in those runs was elite QB play. Ppl propped up Brad Kaaya and Stephen Morris lol. I think these past couple years with the portal has shown us we’ve been either average/lacking/Subpar at the position for a loooong time..
 
facts are…everybody here would be up in arms if Miami took a QB in 27 or 28 with 1 offer from an FCS school. We want MOAR stars for a reason lmao. Kids go under the radar more often than we think. That is why so many of these kids are getting offers from non P4/FCS schools in the portal.

Sometimes kids in HS just never had the platform or hype and thats ok. That is why sports is King. Because of the stories and the journey. How much longer will the portal last?? Idk. Let’s just enjoy the ride…
 
Alex_Dynamix said:
Understood I feel you. My money is on Coleman but if he gets beat out by Luke we’re still in good hands imo 🙏🏾..you go portal again only if a Cam Ward type wants in again.
Click to expand...
of course, moral of the story is we are in a great hands. but I'm predicting Coleman to be the man! you heard it hear first!
 
Alex_Dynamix said:
one of the talking points back when ppl were starting threads about why Miami has underachieved so much since joining the ACC was subpar QB play @ the U compared to the Cream of the ACC like Clemson/FSU who both had dominant runs while we were down. I said a big common denominator in those runs was elite QB play. Ppl propped up Brad Kaaya and Stephen Morris lol. I think these past couple years with the portal has shown us we’ve been either average/lacking/Subpar at the position for a loooong time..
Click to expand...
Its bizarre to me that people want to go back.. Its like they rather be 7 and 5 with home grown QBs than playoff winning program with transfer QBs. These high school kids bust at an extreme rate and we have not shown ability to develop one into a consistent winner.. Getting a proven cfb QB with legit cfb experience is a winning formula.. We are finally ahead of curve and seem ashamed of the new era of cfb. Coleman should go to FIU to get reps.
 
Advertisement
skyman said:
Its bizarre to me that people want to go back.. Its like they rather be 7 and 5 with home grown QBs than playoff winning program with transfer QBs. These high school kids bust at an extreme rate and we have not shown ability to develop one into a consistent winner.. Getting a proven cfb QB with legit cfb experience is a winning formula.. We are finally ahead of curve and seem ashamed of the new era of cfb. Coleman should go to FIU to get reps.
Click to expand...
Although I think Coleman can blossom into something special at this level I always felt it would be interesting to use a school like FIU/FAU as a kind of farm team where you can send true freshman QBs with elite traits to develop w/ live reps with the understanding that they will be brought back up thru the transfer portal instead of sitting behind a guaranteed starter like Beck/Ward/Mensah and getting next to 0 reps live, would be a win win for both teams imo as they arent really directly competing with each other for recruits
 
Last year we kept seeing these same posts related to Luke Nickel. Now Nickel is a bum and its all about Coleman, who has yet to put on pads at the college level.

As it relates to the portal, I suspect we're going to see the NCAA makes some changes to the portal in the near term. The idea of getting a high quality portal QB every year might come to an end. If it doesn't, I continue to predict that 4 & 5 star high school QB's will start signing with mid-major programs with guarantees of starting for two years then hitting the portal. Why would any bigtime QB want to sign with Miami or Indiana or other?
 
Back
Top