Here are the requirements
- The student-athlete must suffer the injury during one of their four seasons of college competition or during the senior year of high school.
- The injury must be incapacitating. That means it must be a season-ending injury.
- The injury must occur prior to the start of the second half of the season.
- The student-athlete must not have competed in more than 30% of the season or three contests, whichever is greater.
I think Franchise is right. That sounds like the requirements to get a fifth year, not a sixth.
What I listed is the requirement for a medical redshirt. Hunter will not get a 6th year because he only missed one season which wasn't in his control. He could have competed his freshman season. NCAA gives you 5 years to to do 4 years of competition. At the end of 5 years Hunter could come competed 4. If Hunter gets hurt in the first 30% of competition this year or any other year he can get a 6th year. At the end of the day the best Hunter can do is play in 3 full seasons and less than 30% of another if he gets hurt again. If Hunter doesn't get Hurt the most he can play in his 3 full seasons. Under no circumstances that I know of will Hunter be able to compete in 4 full seasons.
How did Randy Phillips get his 6th yr? I don't remember but there's our answer.
Here are the requirements
- The student-athlete must suffer the injury during one of their four seasons of college competition or during the senior year of high school.
- The injury must be incapacitating. That means it must be a season-ending injury.
- The injury must occur prior to the start of the second half of the season.
- The student-athlete must not have competed in more than 30% of the season or three contests, whichever is greater.
I think Franchise is right. That sounds like the requirements to get a fifth year, not a sixth.
What I listed is the requirement for a medical redshirt. Hunter will not get a 6th year because he only missed one season which wasn't in his control. He could have competed his freshman season. NCAA gives you 5 years to to do 4 years of competition. At the end of 5 years Hunter could come competed 4. If Hunter gets hurt in the first 30% of competition this year or any other year he can get a 6th year. At the end of the day the best Hunter can do is play in 3 full seasons and less than 30% of another if he gets hurt again. If Hunter doesn't get Hurt the most he can play in his 3 full seasons. Under no circumstances that I know of will Hunter be able to compete in 4 full seasons.
Wrong again. Stop. You're injuring the knowledge base of this community.
How did Randy Phillips get his 6th yr? I don't remember but there's our answer.
Randy Phillips never took a non medical redshirt. He played his Freshman - Senior year and got hurt 2 games into his senior year which qualified him for a medical redshirt so he was able to play a 5th season.
Here is the quote form UM
"2008 (SENIOR): Played in two games against Florida and Texas A&M, making a start against the Gators ... Suffered an injury against the Aggies and missed the remainder of the season ... Awarded a medical hardship and returns for the 2009 season."
edit:
Link to source http://www.hurricanesports.com/ViewArticle.dbml?DB_OEM_ID=28700&ATCLID=205558349
CenterIs he a G or T?
Here are the requirements
- The student-athlete must suffer the injury during one of their four seasons of college competition or during the senior year of high school.
- The injury must be incapacitating. That means it must be a season-ending injury.
- The injury must occur prior to the start of the second half of the season.
- The student-athlete must not have competed in more than 30% of the season or three contests, whichever is greater.
I think Franchise is right. That sounds like the requirements to get a fifth year, not a sixth.
What I listed is the requirement for a medical redshirt. Hunter will not get a 6th year because he only missed one season which wasn't in his control. He could have competed his freshman season. NCAA gives you 5 years to to do 4 years of competition. At the end of 5 years Hunter could come competed 4. If Hunter gets hurt in the first 30% of competition this year or any other year he can get a 6th year. At the end of the day the best Hunter can do is play in 3 full seasons and less than 30% of another if he gets hurt again. If Hunter doesn't get Hurt the most he can play in his 3 full seasons. Under no circumstances that I know of will Hunter be able to compete in 4 full seasons.
Wrong again. Stop. You're injuring the knowledge base of this community.
Hi Franchise -
If you find my post in error I suggest you post something to counter it or prove other wise.
I think Franchise is right. That sounds like the requirements to get a fifth year, not a sixth.
What I listed is the requirement for a medical redshirt. Hunter will not get a 6th year because he only missed one season which wasn't in his control. He could have competed his freshman season. NCAA gives you 5 years to to do 4 years of competition. At the end of 5 years Hunter could come competed 4. If Hunter gets hurt in the first 30% of competition this year or any other year he can get a 6th year. At the end of the day the best Hunter can do is play in 3 full seasons and less than 30% of another if he gets hurt again. If Hunter doesn't get Hurt the most he can play in his 3 full seasons. Under no circumstances that I know of will Hunter be able to compete in 4 full seasons.
Wrong again. Stop. You're injuring the knowledge base of this community.
Hi Franchise -
If you find my post in error I suggest you post something to counter it or prove other wise.
It's incumbent upon you as a responsible community member and dear friend to refrain from delivering false information couched as fact in an attempt to look informed to your fellow community members.
We appreciate your hard work behind the scenes. There's no need for you to attempt to spin the camera around and feature yourself in an area where you're so obviously uninformed. If you've imbued one poor unsuspecting community member with erroneous information you've done us all a major disservice, as we are all representatives of each other.
I implore you to retract your erroneous comments or, in the alternative, to make sure that everyone knows you are merely guessing and that they should not view your Paranosian guesses as the factual declarations that you made.
As a helpful friend, I will suggest to you that your problem appears to be your misunderstanding of the term "medical redshirt". You appear to think that a 5th and 6th year redshirt situation are treated the same way when they absolutely are not.
I think Franchise is right. That sounds like the requirements to get a fifth year, not a sixth.
What I listed is the requirement for a medical redshirt. Hunter will not get a 6th year because he only missed one season which wasn't in his control. He could have competed his freshman season. NCAA gives you 5 years to to do 4 years of competition. At the end of 5 years Hunter could come competed 4. If Hunter gets hurt in the first 30% of competition this year or any other year he can get a 6th year. At the end of the day the best Hunter can do is play in 3 full seasons and less than 30% of another if he gets hurt again. If Hunter doesn't get Hurt the most he can play in his 3 full seasons. Under no circumstances that I know of will Hunter be able to compete in 4 full seasons.
Wrong again. Stop. You're injuring the knowledge base of this community.
Hi Franchise -
If you find my post in error I suggest you post something to counter it or prove other wise.
It's incumbent upon you as a responsible community member and dear friend to refrain from delivering false information couched as fact in an attempt to look informed to your fellow community members.
We appreciate your hard work behind the scenes. There's no need for you to attempt to spin the camera around and feature yourself in an area where you're so obviously uninformed. If you've imbued one poor unsuspecting community member with erroneous information you've done us all a major disservice, as we are all representatives of each other.
I implore you to retract your erroneous comments or, in the alternative, to make sure that everyone knows you are merely guessing and that they should not view your Paranosian guesses as the factual declarations that you made.
As a helpful friend, I will suggest to you that your problem appears to be your misunderstanding of the term "medical redshirt". You appear to think that a 5th and 6th year redshirt situation are treated the same way when they absolutely are not.