Respectfully disagree. Herbert will end up with a longer career, but I’ve never been a should’ve drafted Herbert instead guy. Herbert is Jared Goff with far less accomplishments.
Tua has been a disaster. Nothing special for the first two years. Then a bubble of 2 good years (fool's gold) that resulted in two Wild Card losses. Followed by the ridiculous extension and the inevitable decline. And an all-time NFL record cap hit on the release.
I don't care if you were ever a "should've drafted Herbert instead guy". The fact remains, the fanbase acted like we had won some sort of a prize by drating Tua at #5. The whole "Tank for Tua" thing began the year before the draft, and Tua wasn't even the first QB selected.
---We could have tried to trade up for Joe Burrow.
---I mention Justin Herbert because he was the next selection. Regardless of what you think of him, his stats are better in every year except 2023.
---Jordan Love was available later in the 1st round.
---Jalen Hurts was available in the 2nd round.
---Free agency? If you can't get Burrow and you don't like the others, you could go after Tom Brady (I know, we tried, it cost us some draft capital) or Phillip Rivers or Ryan Tannehill until you are ready to draft a QB.
Bottom line, Tua was the wrong choice.