I mean both aren't pretty but here's the way I look at it:
Defensively there are starters I can trust - Torres is coming back soon and is one of the best defensive CF in the conference and up there nationally, Odgen and Sheahan can make plays and Sosa does his job behind the plate. And the guys who aren't up to par defensively make up for it with their hitting (Williams, Cuvet, West). So defensively I know I have an elite CF and plus guys up the middle, where the corners are lacking but hit well.
Bullpen wise I genuinely only trust Dorn at the moment. There's some talent in that room but they have zero confidence or are rehabbing (Menendez can be elite but needs time to get up to speed). What makes the pitching struggles worse is that they cannot "make up for it" which impacts the team worse in my opinion and has costed us more games this season