forums

GABOS

Advertisement
RedSquare said:
Reggie Wayne and Ahmmon Richards would like to have a word with you
Click to expand...
Recency bias is a real thing.

This is a close call. For this point in their respective freshman seasons, who would you rank these 3?
And we should probably throw in Irvin as well.
 
AtlAtty said:
Recency bias is a real thing.

This is a close call. For this point in their respective freshman seasons, who would you rank these 3?
And we should probably throw in Irvin as well.
Click to expand...

I didn't include Irvin because he was a RS-FR when he first played. I was only counting the true frosh, but either way. tough call all around
 
hurricaneman said:
Just gonna throw this out there...

If that play against FSU doesn't get called back because of an illegal procedure penalty (*):

*Malachi Toney freshman season through first 5 games: 29 receptions, 428 yards, 4 TD
Jeremiah Smith freshman season through first 5 games: 23 receptions, 453 yards, 6 TD

Malachi Toney: # 6 Notre Dame, BCU, #18 USF, UF, #18 FSU
Jeremiah Smith: Akron, Western Michigan, Marshall, Michigan State, Iowa

...Just saying.
Click to expand...
What no one has said yet, of course, is that the noise from some quarters about paying Jeremiah to come back here has quieted down because Canes fans are now realizing that Cristobal and Beard may have found an American Heritage kid who may match Smith's talent, if not his height and reach.
 
AtlAtty said:
Recency bias is a real thing.

This is a close call. For this point in their respective freshman seasons, who would you rank these 3?
And we should probably throw in Irvin as well.
Click to expand...
For true comparison...

Irvin is somewhat eliminated compared to Toney just due to true frosh vs RS Frosh season performance...

I mean if we want to get apples to apples...

gLo2vzrM6ORq5Zuok6.gif
 
Advertisement
Empirical Cane said:
Toney plays as a true frosh and is on pace for 12 game regular season of 900 yds.

👀

Irvin sat has a true Frosh in '84 and played RSF '85 in 11 games (10 reg, 1 Bowl) w/ 840 yds (extrapolated to 12 for 916 yds)

Richards played as true Frosh in '16 in 13 games (12 reg, 1 Bowl) w/ 934 yds (extrapolated to 12 for 870 yds)

Toney hits 850+ yds in regular season play and he belongs in the Irvin + Richards conversation.
Click to expand...
Thru G7...

Toney is on pace for 963 yds thru G12
 
Advertisement
Empirical Cane said:
Thru G7...

Toney is on pace for 963 yds thru G12
Click to expand...
Thru G11 has 844 yds...

Toney is on pace for 921 yds thru G12

IF he has another game like VT, he could approach 1,000 but likely not reach.

To recap the context...

Irving sat as a true Frosh in '84 and played RSF '85 in 11 games (10 reg, 1 Bowl) w/ 840 yds (extrapolated to 12 for 916 yds)

Richards played as true Frosh in '16 in 13 games (12 reg, 1 Bowl) w/ 934 yds (extrapolated to 12 for 870 yds)
 
Back
Top