From the booth vs on the sideline

Hoyacane1620

All American
Premium
Joined
Feb 3, 2018
Messages
23,722
Bill O’Brien has spent his first two games as Alabama’s offensive coordinator coaching from the press box, which might not seem noteworthy, but in recent years, majority of the Crimson Tide’s offensive play-callers have coached from field level instead of with a bird’s eye view.

For Alabama’s offensive staff, which features four new hires, O’Brien and running backs coach Robert Gillespie are in the box, while offensive line coach Doug Marrone, tight ends coach and special teams coordinator and wide receivers coach Holmon Wiggins are all on the field.

Head coach Nick Saban explained the reasoning behind the coaching assignments.

“We have Doug Marrone and the other coaches that are on the sidelines, Wig as the receiver coach, who has been here, he’s assistant head coach, he knows the system,” Saban said on Thursday night. “So to split the staff up was really sort of the right thing to do. And Bill wanted to be in the press box, but he could do it either way and he’s done it either way. But it just balanced the staff out a little bit better to have Doug and Wig on the sidelines with the players because of their experience, because they could make the adjustments.

“Bill can always make the adjustments with the quarterback. And I think it enhances your ability to call the game when you’re in the press box because you don’t have all the distractions that you have on the sidelines. There’s good and bad in both, I promise you, so it really is kind of up to the individual and the group that you have and how that works best for your team.”

Just like in this case, Saban typically allows his offensive coordinators to coach from where they want. However, he insisted that Lane Kiffin be on the sidelines for his first year in 2014, and that’s where the now-Ole Miss coach stayed throughout his tenure. The coordinators before Kiffin -- Major Applewhite, Jim McElwain and Doug Nussmeier -- all coached from the booth in their time at UA. Most recently Steve Sarkisian called plays from the sideline.

Saban preferred to call games from the press box when he was Michigan State’s defensive coordinator from 1983-97, but when he worked under Bill Belichick with the Cleveland Browns, he was asked to coach from the sideline and was “absolutely scared to death” by the idea.

“I always called the game from the press box,” Saban said. “You could have all your stuff laid out, what I’m gonna call on third down, what I’m gonna call on first down, what I’m gonna call against this personnel group, whatever. So it was really easy to be organized, and in between series, you could actually look at all these things and decide what you’re gonna call next.”

In two games under O’Brien, Alabama’s offense has averaged 46.0 points and 462.5 yards per game, which ranks third and fifth in the SEC, respectively. Coaching from the booth hasn’t had much of an effect on starting quarterback Bryce Young, who has opened his sophomore season with 571 passing yards, seven touchdowns and a 70.8 completion percentage.
 
Advertisement
I've been thinking about Lashlee and the offense this week and when I saw this story, it made me wonder if maybe he wouldn't be better served trying to call a game from up in the booth. Or maybe Rob Likens, with a connection to Lashlee. Someone up in the booth will have a better/different perspective of what is going on down on the field.
 
Bill O’Brien has spent his first two games as Alabama’s offensive coordinator coaching from the press box, which might not seem noteworthy, but in recent years, majority of the Crimson Tide’s offensive play-callers have coached from field level instead of with a bird’s eye view.

For Alabama’s offensive staff, which features four new hires, O’Brien and running backs coach Robert Gillespie are in the box, while offensive line coach Doug Marrone, tight ends coach and special teams coordinator and wide receivers coach Holmon Wiggins are all on the field.

Head coach Nick Saban explained the reasoning behind the coaching assignments.

“We have Doug Marrone and the other coaches that are on the sidelines, Wig as the receiver coach, who has been here, he’s assistant head coach, he knows the system,” Saban said on Thursday night. “So to split the staff up was really sort of the right thing to do. And Bill wanted to be in the press box, but he could do it either way and he’s done it either way. But it just balanced the staff out a little bit better to have Doug and Wig on the sidelines with the players because of their experience, because they could make the adjustments.

“Bill can always make the adjustments with the quarterback. And I think it enhances your ability to call the game when you’re in the press box because you don’t have all the distractions that you have on the sidelines. There’s good and bad in both, I promise you, so it really is kind of up to the individual and the group that you have and how that works best for your team.”

Just like in this case, Saban typically allows his offensive coordinators to coach from where they want. However, he insisted that Lane Kiffin be on the sidelines for his first year in 2014, and that’s where the now-Ole Miss coach stayed throughout his tenure. The coordinators before Kiffin -- Major Applewhite, Jim McElwain and Doug Nussmeier -- all coached from the booth in their time at UA. Most recently Steve Sarkisian called plays from the sideline.

Saban preferred to call games from the press box when he was Michigan State’s defensive coordinator from 1983-97, but when he worked under Bill Belichick with the Cleveland Browns, he was asked to coach from the sideline and was “absolutely scared to death” by the idea.

“I always called the game from the press box,” Saban said. “You could have all your stuff laid out, what I’m gonna call on third down, what I’m gonna call on first down, what I’m gonna call against this personnel group, whatever. So it was really easy to be organized, and in between series, you could actually look at all these things and decide what you’re gonna call next.”

In two games under O’Brien, Alabama’s offense has averaged 46.0 points and 462.5 yards per game, which ranks third and fifth in the SEC, respectively. Coaching from the booth hasn’t had much of an effect on starting quarterback Bryce Young, who has opened his sophomore season with 571 passing yards, seven touchdowns and a 70.8 completion percentage.
When you have a former NFL head coach as your college offensive line coach to be on the sidelines, it kind of offers a bit more flexibility.
 
I've been thinking about Lashlee and the offense this week and when I saw this story, it made me wonder if maybe he wouldn't be better served trying to call a game from up in the booth. Or maybe Rob Likens, with a connection to Lashlee. Someone up in the booth will have a better/different perspective of what is going on down on the field.
It’s a good topic.

When it comes up you know your coordinators are in trouble
 
When you have a former NFL head coach as your college offensive line coach to be on the sidelines, it kind of offers a bit more flexibility.
I always called the game from the press box,” Saban said. “You could have all your stuff laid out, what I’m gonna call on third down, what I’m gonna call on first down, what I’m gonna call against this personnel group, whatever. So it was really easy to be organized, and in between series, you could actually look at all these things and decide what you’re gonna call next.”

This makes good sense to me.
 
Advertisement
I always called the game from the press box,” Saban said. “You could have all your stuff laid out, what I’m gonna call on third down, what I’m gonna call on first down, what I’m gonna call against this personnel group, whatever. So it was really easy to be organized, and in between series, you could actually look at all these things and decide what you’re gonna call next.”

This makes good sense to me.
It can’t hurt… I do wonder if Lashlee does it because that is what he was more comfortable with when he was QB and being able to talk about what each one is seeing. I guess that is what a headset is for.
 
Advertisement
You know I thought when we hired lashlee that it was a home run hire. When we hired enos I was confused as to how manure thought his drop back pro style 7 step drop offense would work here. Never bought into the spread coast nonsense.
Now that we’ve seen lashlee it is apparent that his offense is less of what we saw at smu and more of the Gus crap with a worse line and backs. I don’t think a location change will do it. Rhett is stubborn just like our previous OCs and if he refuses to adjust it will take down manny as well
 
I mentioned this two weeks ago. Ashlee gets caught in the moment and then calls nonsense. He needs to be in the box. It can't get any worse so why not?
 
I think your QB coach needs to be on the sidelines to coach. If your OC is your QB coach then have someone he trusts upstairs relaying info. I agree that it can be really helpful to have an experienced set of eyes up in the box. So Likens upstairs makes the most sense to me.
 
Advertisement
Advertisement
Back
Top