Fall Ball Thoughts

Sebastian Font

Junior
Premium
Joined
Oct 2, 2024
Messages
1,698
After another productive fall ball slate, optimism continues to grow around the Light as the season draws nearer. And while this year I wasn’t able to attend as many scrimmages as I would’ve liked (Skipped as many classes as I could), I was still able to get a decent read on the team through the practices I did attend as well as contacting some sources. With all that said, here are my immediate thoughts after fall ball:

  • Immediately the biggest change is the physicality on the roster, this looks like a legit ball team. That's the first thing everyone mentions when they see the team for the first time. In the positions of power (1B, 3B, and DH for example), Miami will likely have players all over 6-foot-3, with athletic players scattered around the rest of the field. Physicality isn’t the most important thing on the diamond, but it sure goes a long way in winning the mental battle against some of the top teams.

  • You know what does win ballgames though? Talent. That’s exactly what Miami has gotten over the offseason. Last year's group had talent, but its real prowess was with their mental fortitude and grit — the intangibles. That’s why I was looked at like crazy last year when I said the team could make a Super Regional run, because on paper the talent wasn’t there. However, this year the talent is all there. Miami returns its top four hitters from last year and pairs them with impressive hitters in Alex Sosa, Brylan West and Cian Copeland. And while the ’Canes did lose some arms, they’ve replenished in the form of Richmond transfer Ryan Bilka and other high-ceiling additions. The combination of returning cornerstones and hand-picking portal pieces works in the modern era — a method I expect J.D and co. to continue utilizing in the coming years.

  • And yet with all the talent talk, I left out some of the most exciting pieces for this season — the freshmen. I mentioned early in the fall last year that A.J Ciscar and Tate DeRias would work their way into being stars as freshmen, and this year I’m calling my shot on the offensive side with Gabriel Milano and Alonzo Alvarez. They both have that “it” factor where they don’t look like freshmen on the field, their approach at the plate is veteran-like where they fight until they get their pitch and don’t miss. The problem is both are kind of blocked at their position for everyday reps. As a catcher, Alvarez likely won’t be replacing your top transfer in Sosa, but could serve as the backup and an option at DH as a switch-hitter. Milano has a better chance at taking the starting spot from transfer second baseman Vance Sheahan, but will also likely be reduced to splitting time as a platoon hitter. Again, this is a good problem born out of an increase in talent across the board.

  • Position battles worth monitoring:
    • Second base: Sheahan vs. Milano
    • Designated hitter: Copeland vs. Milano vs. Alvarez
    • Sunday starter: Evans vs. Bilka (if they choose starter route over pen)
    • Closer: Pretty much every bullpen arm at the moment

  • Three impressive pitchers: Bilka, Evans, Collera

  • Three impressive hitters: Ogden, Cuvet, Galvin (Plus the two freshmen mentioned above)

  • Last year it was pretty clear on who would be cut to return to our 35/36 man roster. This year it looks like it’s going to be a much harder discussion. There will likely be some really talented players who will have to make way.

  • With all the talent across the board, I believe that this team will be a candidate to host a regional and should return to the Super Regionals. However, I’m hesitant to make the claim of an Omaha side. When you look at the Omaha teams over the past few years, the sheer amount of high-level arms they have is just ridiculous. I believe we have some quality arms, but would really need 1-2 more guys to really make that jump (Keep an eye on Frank Menendez’s return for example).

  • And if any of y’all have any questions I’ll do my best to answer them.
 
Advertisement
What are the timelines for Menendez and Robert to return? Will they have enough time to ramp up and pitch meaningful innings at 100% down the stretch?

Lot of talk about the summer Sheahan had - thoughts on his fall, especially with the context of how high everyone is on Milano?
 
What are the timelines for Menendez and Robert to return? Will they have enough time to ramp up and pitch meaningful innings at 100% down the stretch?

Lot of talk about the summer Sheahan had - thoughts on his fall, especially with the context of how high everyone is on Milano?
It's always hard to predict TJ recovery, but Robert has already begun to throw albeit very lightly. I expect both to pitch meaningful innings down the stretch even if they aren't at 100% because that's just the nature of late season baseball.

On Sheahan, I've liked what I've seen so far. He seems to have put his summer woes behind him and is starting to tap back into that athletic/twitchy player we were sold on. He's paired well with Ogden up the middle, but there's a clear gap between him and Ogden with that "it" factor. I expect him to start based off the tendency of the staff to opt for experience, and from there it's all about doing enough to not lose the spot --- because Milano will be there waiting
 
Pitching. How we looking? Better or worse especially starters
I think its tough to say, especially considering how many of the guys last year struggled and then really redeemed themselves (Fischer, Walters, etc).

Nearly every arm we returned got better --- all three of Ciscar, DeRias, and Evans have jumped up to sitting 93-94, and we've added an absolute dawg in Bilka who's ran it up to 96 with a really nice splitter. The bullpen has a ridiculous potential if you can get one or two of your freshmen to be solid, and again if Menendez and Robert can return 100% then pitching will be more than okay.

And on starters specifically I guess I would say better because 2/3 of that weekend rotation has returned.
 
I think its tough to say, especially considering how many of the guys last year struggled and then really redeemed themselves (Fischer, Walters, etc).

Nearly every arm we returned got better --- all three of Ciscar, DeRias, and Evans have jumped up to sitting 93-94, and we've added an absolute dawg in Bilka who's ran it up to 96 with a really nice splitter. The bullpen has a ridiculous potential if you can get one or two of your freshmen to be solid, and again if Menendez and Robert can return 100% then pitching will be more than okay.

And on starters specifically I guess I would say better because 2/3 of that weekend rotation has returned.
Appreciate the response… I wasn’t aware how we were feeling after we lost that portal addition who ultimately opted to the draft I know we were penciling him into that Friday night role.

Either way JD is a pitching coach at heart so I still have high expectations for that staff top to bottom
 
@Sebastian Font For Saturdays scrimmage and scout session, what exactly happens at the scout portion? is that something fans will enjoy or is it more for players? Will be finally making it to the Light Saturday, so just figuring out if it's worth it to go early for the scout portion.
 
@Sebastian Font For Saturdays scrimmage and scout session, what exactly happens at the scout portion? is that something fans will enjoy or is it more for players? Will be finally making it to the Light Saturday, so just figuring out if it's worth it to go early for the scout portion.
I would go for the scout portion, all of our players will be involved with that
 
Advertisement
After another productive fall ball slate, optimism continues to grow around the Light as the season draws nearer. And while this year I wasn’t able to attend as many scrimmages as I would’ve liked (Skipped as many classes as I could), I was still able to get a decent read on the team through the practices I did attend as well as contacting some sources. With all that said, here are my immediate thoughts after fall ball:

  • Immediately the biggest change is the physicality on the roster, this looks like a legit ball team. That's the first thing everyone mentions when they see the team for the first time. In the positions of power (1B, 3B, and DH for example), Miami will likely have players all over 6-foot-3, with athletic players scattered around the rest of the field. Physicality isn’t the most important thing on the diamond, but it sure goes a long way in winning the mental battle against some of the top teams.

  • You know what does win ballgames though? Talent. That’s exactly what Miami has gotten over the offseason. Last year's group had talent, but its real prowess was with their mental fortitude and grit — the intangibles. That’s why I was looked at like crazy last year when I said the team could make a Super Regional run, because on paper the talent wasn’t there. However, this year the talent is all there. Miami returns its top four hitters from last year and pairs them with impressive hitters in Alex Sosa, Brylan West and Cian Copeland. And while the ’Canes did lose some arms, they’ve replenished in the form of Richmond transfer Ryan Bilka and other high-ceiling additions. The combination of returning cornerstones and hand-picking portal pieces works in the modern era — a method I expect J.D and co. to continue utilizing in the coming years.

  • And yet with all the talent talk, I left out some of the most exciting pieces for this season — the freshmen. I mentioned early in the fall last year that A.J Ciscar and Tate DeRias would work their way into being stars as freshmen, and this year I’m calling my shot on the offensive side with Gabriel Milano and Alonzo Alvarez. They both have that “it” factor where they don’t look like freshmen on the field, their approach at the plate is veteran-like where they fight until they get their pitch and don’t miss. The problem is both are kind of blocked at their position for everyday reps. As a catcher, Alvarez likely won’t be replacing your top transfer in Sosa, but could serve as the backup and an option at DH as a switch-hitter. Milano has a better chance at taking the starting spot from transfer second baseman Vance Sheahan, but will also likely be reduced to splitting time as a platoon hitter. Again, this is a good problem born out of an increase in talent across the board.

  • Position battles worth monitoring:
    • Second base: Sheahan vs. Milano
    • Designated hitter: Copeland vs. Milano vs. Alvarez
    • Sunday starter: Evans vs. Bilka (if they choose starter route over pen)
    • Closer: Pretty much every bullpen arm at the moment

  • Three impressive pitchers: Bilka, Evans, Collera

  • Three impressive hitters: Ogden, Cuvet, Galvin (Plus the two freshmen mentioned above)

  • Last year it was pretty clear on who would be cut to return to our 35/36 man roster. This year it looks like it’s going to be a much harder discussion. There will likely be some really talented players who will have to make way.

  • With all the talent across the board, I believe that this team will be a candidate to host a regional and should return to the Super Regionals. However, I’m hesitant to make the claim of an Omaha side. When you look at the Omaha teams over the past few years, the sheer amount of high-level arms they have is just ridiculous. I believe we have some quality arms, but would really need 1-2 more guys to really make that jump (Keep an eye on Frank Menendez’s return for example).

  • And if any of y’all have any questions I’ll do my best to answer them.
Good, objective insight. Thanks. Sounds like Robert's recovery and Collera figuring it out could be the key to how far this squad advances in 2026.

It's tough for true freshmen to be key contributors in June.
 
Good, objective insight. Thanks. Sounds like Robert's recovery and Collera figuring it out could be the key to how far this squad advances in 2026.

It's tough for true freshmen to be key contributors in June.
If Erick Peralta figures out control, then we're really cooking. Like thats the type of arm that when he's on, no one is touching him. Another freshman arm who could have a nice role is LJ Drummond, I liked what I saw from him
 
If Erick Peralta figures out control, then we're really cooking. Like thats the type of arm that when he's on, no one is touching him. Another freshman arm who could have a nice role is LJ Drummond, I liked what I saw from him
Peralta has so much movement on his ball. I just wish more of the movement was over the plate.
 
Advertisement
Back
Top