You can’t average over 15 yards per catch in 75 catches if you’re not making plays downfield.A little more information. Barkate’s average was good, but slightly misleading. For example, he had a big game against Clemson, where his longest catch of the season was made (77 yard TD). Except, if you watch the game/play, it’s a busted coverage. The Corner blitzes, Mensah quickly notices, looks like a possible RPO, and there is no one around Barkate for maybe 2 miles.
Another long-ish TD comes from a savvy play where Barkate fakes a blocking tempo and then goes vertical.
So, I heard some people cite these as explosive plays without looking at how Barkate ‘won.’
He’s more of an intermediate guy, from what I watched, than a Charlie Becker vertical threat.
Lets be real here for a minute, Mensah was at Duke under the horrific Manny Diaz and still managed to lead Duke to an ACC championship. Had Manny been able to field a defense that didn't get gashed every week. We would've never made it to the playoffs, because Duke wouldn't have had that many loses and Mensah most likely wouldn't be here now.
Cam avg 7.7 yards a pass at Wash State and ballooned up to 9.5 under Dawson. Even Beck who was afraid to throw it past the LOS had 8.2 up from 7.8 under Dawson. No reason to think Mensah won't be around 9 yards a play with his BPA.
Mensah has the best offensive playmakers that we have seen since 02. This is going to be an amazing big play offense. No reason Mensah shouldn't have the best season that we have seen from a Miami QB. Ward was/is a beast and I'm not downplaying him, I just understand that this team is better than the one he played on and Mensah should benefit from that.
Because it’s not set in stone. There’s isn’t a skill player on offense who has snaps guaranteed except fletch and MaliWhy would guys like Pringle and Brown come back then? The running back room confuses me (in a good way)
Can you still bring in grad transfers, or does it have to correlate with the timing of the transfer portal?OL is the only question mark now. Mario will see how spring looks and go buy an OL if he has to over the summer. Grad transfer or from somewhere.
Yes, but I put a lot of weight on "how you win." You're not often going to "win" off a totally busted coverage that leaves you completely alone for a 77 yard TD. That's an extreme outlier play. Like I said, Barkate's average is very good, but it's because he eats up the intermediate. Want to give people context for the numbers they see.To be fair, you can make that same argument about a lot of other guys too right?
Busted coverages happen. Missed tackles happen. These things inflate numbers, not just for Barkate, for the other guys too.
I do agree though in that I don’t see an Alec Pierce type threat in Barkate. Some guys do have a knack for just finding ways to make explosive plays. Chemistry with the QB plays a big role here too à la Cam -> X.
That’s not what I’ve seen @OrangeBowlMagic. They pushed the ball downfield. That’s from watching the games.
In fact, maybe you can help me with this because you’re the stats guy I trust, I briefly looked it up and it seems Mensah had the *most* deep shot attempts (80+) over 20 yards.
Now, Mensah’s accuracy wasn’t amazing in these 20+ yard attempts, but they threw them frequently, which impacts %s on lower probability throws. Apparently, the most frequently and even more frequently than Cam Ward in 2024 (less than 80). Beck had less than 65 in 2025, apparently.
Check it out.
Where he was outstanding % wise was in the 10-19 range.
This is from a mix of watching games and looking up numbers, so I welcome corrections.
Again, he lives best in the intermediate - not deep downfield (20+). My goal was to give context to those gaudy numbers. At Duke, he operated from a bunch of alignments and often won with precision and technique as opposed to the traditional vertical threat. For those interested, this is important because you'll most likely see him in combination routes with Toney or killing zones. I think he's an exceptional complement to Toney. To max out what we can do, we'll still need a more traditional vertical threat.You can’t average over 15 yards per catch in 75 catches if you’re not making plays downfield.
He’s not Randy Moss but he’s not some prototypical “white guy slot receiver” catching a bunch of six yard outs.
We know Dawson can and will promote it.
We know Mario will allow it.
I’ll never say this will be 2024 until I see it on the field, but in terms of that explosiveness in the passing game, I think we can approach it. Here’s why:
Cam Ward in 2024 put up the best season any of us have ever seen. He averaged 9.4 yards per attempt that year. Good for #3 in the country. Who was #5? Darian Mensah at Tulane. 9.2 yards per attempt.
Now, at Duke in 2025, that number drops to 7.7 per attempt, good for 38th. But his completion percentage was virtually the same. 65.9% at Duke compared to 65.1% at Tulane. So what’s that tell you? Duke isn’t having him push the ball as much. And that tracks, because in 2024 under this Duke staff, Malik Murphy was 88th in the country in YPA. Johnathan Brewer is the OC there, you should know him. He was here with Lashlee. He’s a Lashlee disciple. Tempo, short passing attack.
So back to Mensah here. We know he can push it. We know Dawson can as well. What about the weapons?
Malachi Toney is an alien. Nuff said. He’s going to be one of the very best players in America, regardless of position. But look at the rest.
Barkate averaged 15.3 a catch last year at Duke, on 74 catches. Really, really good. Wanna know how many receivers on our team had that number this year? One. Tony Johnson, and he caught 7 balls. Even on the 2024 team, that’s a better number than Horton and George. Only Restrepo and Arroyo were better.
Enter Vandrevius Jacobs. Averaged 17.1 a catch last year on 32 catches. VERY explosive production. That number would have led our team in 2024, by the way.
Enter Cam Vaughn. Averaged 15.4 a catch last year, good for 10th in the Big 12. Again, a very good number.
That’s 3 kids who averaged at least 15 yards a catch, oh plus that Malachi Toney guy, who is pretty good.
Josh Moore. Upshaw. You HAVE to think Lofton fully healthy is a **** of a lot more explosive than Bauman. No, he won’t be Arroyo, but he can make plays down the field.
All orchestrated by a kid who has demonstrated he can get over 9 yards a throw, now in Year 3 starting in the most QB friendly offense he’s ever played in.
The question mark is the OL. No, it’s not likely Mensah is going to be able to sit in the pocket and do Wordle like Cam and Beck did. But if there’s literally anything I trust this staff to do, it’s protect the QB. Even in 2023 when TVD was broken, physically and his brain, he had all day to throw. I expect Mensah will be way better protected than he was at Duke or Tulane.
It is scary hours for everyone we play this year. We can come at you with multiple excellent backs, and we have a kid with absurd arm talent throwing to Baby Jesus and the Vertical Apostles. I’m downright aroused at the thought of what this offense can do in the air on explosives this season. I’m not saying it’s going to the Cam experience, because that’s not fair to expect. But I really think it can be **** close. A pinpoint downfield passer with an electric arm behind a good OL throwing to 4+ receivers who have demonstrated they can get over 15 a pop at the big boy level.
Wheels all the way the **** up, boys and girls. The circus is back in town.
Now with all of these weapons, can we please play with a little bit of tempo. Is it too much to ask for 72-76 plays a game? I think that’s the next big step. Put teams away in the first half this year.
Again, he lives best in the intermediate - not deep downfield (20+). My goal was to give context to those gaudy numbers. At Duke, he operated from a bunch of alignments and often won with precision and technique as opposed to the traditional vertical threat. For those interested, this is important because you'll most likely see him in combination routes with Toney or killing zones. I think he's an exceptional complement to Toney. To max out what we can do, we'll still need a more traditional vertical threat.
Can you still bring in grad transfers, or does it have to correlate with the timing of the transfer portal?
Good point. If this team is anything close to what we think it can be I could see Mensah sitting a lot of 4th quarters. Realistically, he could miss anywhere from 1-2 whole game’s worth of statistics.My only counter: if our 2026 defense is similar to 2025, Mensah won’t be playing full games. He will still be putting up massive numbers but he may not beat Cam Ward who had to play full games due to the defenses lack of ability to contain opponents.