EARTH TO MARIO…. Take a knee

I'm glad I just saw this thread, I hadn't till now.

Yet another feather in Mario and Dawson's caps....they played that to perfection. Even ran outside on 1st down to try to burn a couple "free" seconds. He'll never completely erase the GT debacle, nor should be be allowed to. The worst mistake in the history of the sport is impossible to scrub. But all you can do is learn and improve, and he absolutely has. He still makes the occasional decision that makes me scratch my head, but compared to early in his career, it's night and day.

This was a well-executed masterclass on Saturday night, and as much as I enjoy him, Sean McDonough should be embarrassed for how he called the end of that game. I expect it from CIS, not from a paid professional. A+ clock management to close out a game, exactly how it should be done.

If we **** on the staff when it's deserved, you give them their flowers when it's deserved. That's not the easiest situation in the world to manage in the moment, they did it exceptionally well.
 
I'm glad I just saw this thread, I hadn't till now.

Yet another feather in Mario and Dawson's caps....they played that to perfection. Even ran outside on 1st down to try to burn a couple "free" seconds. He'll never completely erase the GT debacle, nor should be be allowed to. The worst mistake in the history of the sport is impossible to scrub. But all you can do is learn and improve, and he absolutely has. He still makes the occasional decision that makes me scratch my head, but compared to early in his career, it's night and day.

This was a well-executed masterclass on Saturday night, and as much as I enjoy him, Sean McDonough should be embarrassed for how he called the end of that game. I expect it from CIS, not from a paid professional. A+ clock management to close out a game, exactly how it should be done.

If we **** on the staff when it's deserved, you give them their flowers when it's deserved. That's not the easiest situation in the world to manage in the moment, they did it exceptionally well.
In Monday’s presser Dawson explained why he called the run instead of kneeling. Basically, he said there was about 4-5 seconds he had to burn before he could kneel.
 
I act like someone who witness 1st hand the debacle against GT. Didn't work then. So you are comfortable with a process that has 50% chance of success when most teams are like 99.9%? By the way the 1st running play took 6 seconds off clock, you don't think if we shotgun snapped (which we did anyway) Mensah could runaround in backfield for a few seconds? It worked this time and didn't against GT.
Go watch the press conference and then shut up. I trust the best OC in the game over a guy in his basement. He explains it very well and maybe he can help you understand. He also talks about witnessing East Carolina trying to the exact same thing you are suggesting and losing the game.
 
I feel like a fumble is much more likely having your quarterback take multiple “delayed knees” than just handing the ball to a running back one time and then taking a knee. Especially a quarterback with a history of fumbling the ball.
 
I act like someone who witness 1st hand the debacle against GT. Didn't work then. So you are comfortable with a process that has 50% chance of success when most teams are like 99.9%? By the way the 1st running play took 6 seconds off clock, you don't think if we shotgun snapped (which we did anyway) Mensah could runaround in backfield for a few seconds? It worked this time and didn't against GT.
He did that and it barely took 4 seconds off the clock.

That would have left 4-6 seconds on the clock and necessitate a punt.

It's literally mind numbing how dense this fan base is.
 
He did that and it barely took 4 seconds off the clock.

That would have left 4-6 seconds on the clock and necessitate a punt.

It's literally mind numbing how dense this fan base is.
Of all the things to gripe about because a commentator made an ignorant statement. They literally executed to perfection and some are finding fault. You can't make this up. This is the equivalent of UNC fans blaming the refs for the onside kick penalties that were called exactly right.
 
Just some perspective for the short bus crowd: a college athlete can run about 50 yards in six seconds. Let's make it 40 in this situation. You're asking our QB to do a 40-yard scramble behind the line - three times - and hoping nothing goes wrong.

Or we could hand it off.
 
Tell that to CJ Bailey
That wasn’t a delayed kneel that was a compete brain meltdown. A delayed kneel and a safety wins the game or just step out of back of endzone. Him running around and fumbling is not what we’re discussing . Out of 100 plus years of ball a player having a stroke mid play is the argument against something that’s fool proof. Versus a coach who’s lost two games in 7-8 years for not kneeling.
 
He did that and it barely took 4 seconds off the clock.

That would have left 4-6 seconds on the clock and necessitate a punt.

It's literally mind numbing how dense this fan base is.
Hey mind numbingly dumb, I pointed out in post, the 1st running play only took 6 seconds off clock. You don't think if he had to, Mensah could have ran backwards for 2 seconds more? With all the penalties on the on sides kicks, we had like 60 yards to run backwards if we had to.
 
I feel like a fumble is much more likely having your quarterback take multiple “delayed knees” than just handing the ball to a running back one time and then taking a knee. Especially a quarterback with a history of fumbling the ball.
So much can go wrong on those plays. I’d prefer to do it once.
 
Hey mind numbingly dumb, I pointed out in post, the 1st running play only took 6 seconds off clock. You don't think if he had to, Mensah could have ran backwards for 2 seconds more? With all the penalties on the on sides kicks, we had like 60 yards to run backwards if we had to.
The last play barely took 4 seconds doing your snap to Mensah and then run around before flopping down.

Doing that 3x would have left us with 4-6 seconds and required a 4th down punt.

Dawson explained this very clearly in his press conference but you know better?

I refuse to believe anyone has such a low IQ, that they think Mensah running 10 yards backwards each time would somehow be better than a RB running it twice thereby making sure every second of the clock would be used and we didn't have to punt.

Dawson explains it from 6:30 to 9:30 of this video.

 
Last edited:
That wasn’t a delayed kneel that was a compete brain meltdown. A delayed kneel and a safety wins the game or just step out of back of endzone. Him running around and fumbling is not what we’re discussing . Out of 100 plus years of ball a player having a stroke mid play is the argument against something that’s fool proof. Versus a coach who’s lost two games in 7-8 years for not kneeling.

It's still not shocking that you are so wrong about this.
 
Back
Top