Whats the point in having Mario as head coach if he cant win these big recruiting battles consistently going into year 4? Recruiting elite players was supposed to be his superpower. If Mario was a good in game coach we could get away with misses like this but thats not the case smh
It’s just bad timing, right as we get a big-time recruiter for a head coach, the NIL-era begins. NIL completely outweighs recruiting ability now and for the foreseeable future.
Lincoln Riley is not a great recruiter (except for QBs). Mike Elko is not some recruiting guru. Brian Kelly, Kalen DeBoer…the list goes on. They all have top-notch NIL operations and will end up in the top 5-7 classes.
A bit simplistic, but essentially it all boils down to 2 things:
A) Get the players in the building (basically just NIL)
B) Get players drafted high year after year
Part B requires getting as many talented players to begin with - hence Part A and why NIL basically determines everything. In the past there were some position coaches where we could just have them be great recruiters and not have to be upper level in terms of actual coaching ability, but maybe that shifts going forward.
Cam Ward, Francis in 2026, we badly need impact NFL players. There are essentially no Canes on the all pro or pro bowl squads. No Canes winning awards. Slowly but surely we can get impact players into the league, but in the meantime it’s all about NIL. If you have the 50th best NIL program, you will end up with around the 50th best class. Maybe an elite recruiter can bump you up a couple of spots beyond your NIL level, but that’s probably it.