forums

Dennis Smiffs' White House- Bat Signal Thread

Big O Cane said:
Time to move on. The logic is super flawed.
Click to expand...
Name one successful high end QB that reclassified and went to ball in college..... Literally the only one I think of that somewhat meets that criteria is Quinn Ewers who was a 7th round pick. So explain to me how that logic is flawed?
 
CanesFan20 said:
Big O Cane said:
Time to move on. The logic is super flawed.
Click to expand...
Name one successful high end QB that reclassified and went to ball in college..... Literally the only one I think of that somewhat meets that criteria is Quinn Ewers who was a 7th round pick. So explain to me how that logic is flawed?
Click to expand...
Your argument was that he was going to miss out on development if he reclassed not whether he was going to be successful.

Being successful is a different story and depends on whether the player can combine athletic profile with football IQ, work ethic, mental toughness, and durability. The sample size on QB reclass is way too new and small to jump to a conclusion there anyway.

I’m sure you’re a great guy but saying a player is going to get better development in high school than in college is a terrible take.
 
Big O Cane said:
Your argument was that he was going to miss out on development if he reclassed not whether he was going to be successful.

Being successful is a different story and depends on whether the player can combine athletic profile with football IQ, work ethic, mental toughness, and durability. The sample size on QB reclass is way too new and small to jump to a conclusion there anyway.

I’m sure you’re a great guy but saying a player is going to get better development in high school than in college is a terrible take.
Click to expand...
You are not getting the point. First, he is getting great development where he is at. He’s literally at one of the best programs in the South, and his coach is Joey King, who helped develop Trevor Lawrence. His private QB coach is Tony Ballard, who is a top-tier QB coach.

The point is that leaving school one year early means he misses out on an extra year of development. Whether he stays in high school or leaves early, he’s still going to get the same five years in college. But if he leaves early, he’s losing one extra year of development, and when you’re 17-18 years old, that extra year can really help with physical development.
 
CanesFan20 said:
Big O Cane said:
Your argument was that he was going to miss out on development if he reclassed not whether he was going to be successful.

Being successful is a different story and depends on whether the player can combine athletic profile with football IQ, work ethic, mental toughness, and durability. The sample size on QB reclass is way too new and small to jump to a conclusion there anyway.

I’m sure you’re a great guy but saying a player is going to get better development in high school than in college is a terrible take.
Click to expand...
You are not getting the point. First, is he getting great development where he is at? He’s literally at one of the best programs in the South, and his coach is Joey King, who helped develop Trevor Lawrence. His private QB coach is Tony Ballard, who is a top-tier QB coach.

The point is that leaving school one year early means he misses out on an extra year of development. Whether he stays in high school or leaves early, he’s still going to get the same five years in college. But if he leaves early, he’s losing one extra year of development, and when you’re 17-18 years old, that extra year can really help with physical development.
Click to expand...
I don’t know how else to explain it to you my friend.

He’s not going to get better development in high school than at the University of Miami or any power 4 college.

If you can’t get that, then there’s no need to continue. You win I give up.
 
Big O Cane said:
Your argument was that he was going to miss out on development if he reclassed not whether he was going to be successful.

Being successful is a different story and depends on whether the player can combine athletic profile with football IQ, work ethic, mental toughness, and durability. The sample size on QB reclass is way too new and small to jump to a conclusion there anyway.

I’m sure you’re a great guy but saying a player is going to get better development in high school than in college is a terrible take.
Click to expand...

Big O Cane said:
I don’t know how else to explain it to you my friend.

He’s not going to get better development in high school than at the University of Miami or any power 4 college.

If you can’t get that, then there’s no need to continue. You win I give up.
Click to expand...

You are still not understanding something pretty simple. If he reclassifies how many years of college eligibility does he have? If he doesn't reclassify how many years of eligibility does he have? The years of college eligibility do not change but missing his senior year of high school does take away a year of development, that he will not get back.
 
Back
Top