Based on what he achieved on rebuilt knees, it's hard to argue against that.With 2 good knees he would have been the GOAT RB in football history.
With 2 good knees he would have been the GOAT RB in football history.


Keep it going FrankFrank needs over 1400yrds to catch Walter.... It would be awesome if he could but I don't think he gets that....Should end up all time #2. Congrats!
First ballot hall of famer. No doubt, but crazy to think that when I think of Canes running backs the first guys I think of are Edgerrin, Willis, and Clinton, and then I’m like, ****, we also had Frank Motherfn! Gore
Absolute Fact....he was killing it here as a true Frosh.....then injuries to both knees. Imagine if the niners would have been just an average team....he would of had 20,000 yds.With 2 good knees he would have been the GOAT RB in football history.
Agree. Portis is one of those guys that’s just 2-3 seasons or a couple of thousand yards away from being a HOFer himself. But admittedly he doesn’t make the cut. Would really like to see Edge get in this year.If Portis wasn't traded he could have had a chance at some records in Denver
True...2 more seasons and he is in HOF. Sucks because he was a great NFL RB.Agree. Portis is one of those guys that’s just 2-3 seasons or a couple of thousand yards away from being a HOFer himself. But admittedly he doesn’t make the cut. Would really like to see Edge get in this year.
Iv'e neverseen one like Walter. No offence to Frank.Frank needs over 1400yrds to catch Walter.... It would be awesome if he could but I don't think he gets that....
But he did pass Marshall Faulk for #4 on the All - Time yards from scrimmage list.... He would need another 2000+ to catch Walter for 3rd as well...