forums

Carson Beck

DC3 said:
I really wish i had your optimism when comparing a career backup QB with a below avarage arm and a guy that has NFL talent.
Click to expand...
A career backup? He's been here 2 years
I've never seen nfl potential in beck watched 10-12 games and never saw it. But I remember vandyke being mocked as a 1st too. I always thought he was terrible too
 
Advertisement
Telituesday said:
In two years at Washington state Ward threw the ball 117 more times than Beck did at UGA. Ward threw for 460 less yards and 4 less touchdowns while throwing 2 less picks (point in his favor). I would take the higher completion %, yards, tds, and passer rating stats over the 2 interception difference and it’s prob hard to say that I’m “wrong” about the stats being better. His team and competition were worse and he did worse. If you want to debate your eyes tell you Beck is a system guy that’s fine you’re entitled to that opinion. I personally don’t think he had the most amazing cast and oc in 2024
Click to expand...
You’re right how foolish of all of us. Beck >>>>>> Ward.

I’m sure Beck would’ve thrown 2x what Cam did if he was at WSU. Bobo is the sole reason Beck isn’t the Heisman.

Also if only we had Beck this year, we would’ve been 12-0. ******* bum *** Cam. Can’t even hold Beck’s jockstrap
 
You guys know UGA is top 10 in the country in drops and worst in the P4 right?

I mean Beck isn’t the star everyone thought he’d be, but he’s definitely better than Mendoza. Evidenced by the fact that…Mendoza wound up at Indiana, and not UGA.

UGA has also struggled up front this year and their OL isn’t as good as it normally is, plus the running game has been virtually nonexistent.

Also, Beck is coached by Mike Bobo. We all know how bad Mike Bobo is.

Now, if the conundrum is overpay for Beck out of desperation but don’t add quality receiving threats, or spend less on a different QB to add quality around the team…then idk.

In an ideal world, we’re spending everywhere. Beck can definitely get us 9, probably 10 wins. He’s better than Lagway, he’s better than whatever ND trots out (probably Angeli).

Would be the second best or best QB in the conference…
 
IMG_4899.jpeg
 
tdjones34 said:
A career backup? He's been here 2 years
I've never seen nfl potential in beck watched 10-12 games and never saw it. But I remember vandyke being mocked as a 1st too. I always thought he was terrible too
Click to expand...

When he was named the ACC Rookie of the Year you came on here saying he was terrible?

No. Of course you didn’t.

But, to be fair, he had played a bunch of nobodies. Beck has faced defenses and athletes far better than what he’ll see here on a weekly basis.

The kid is a proven, good player. Is he Cam Ward? No. Guess what? Nobody will be. We need someone who can keep the offense humming efficiently while hopefully improving the defense. Beck would be a home run get. There’s no debate. Especially when you are choosing between options like Mendoza, Emory, etc. Mateer was the one. He went elsewhere. A kid like Carson Beck would be a fine consolation prize.
 
Can someone definitively say that we are or aren’t targeting Beck?

And if we’re not, at this point, who the **** is left?
 
The debate isn’t whether Beck is better than Ward. News Flash: He’s not.

The debate isn’t whether Beck is better than Mendoza. New Flash: It no longer matters.

The debate should be whether Beck (and his gimpy right elbow) is better than Emory.

My $.02 is give me Beck with Emory as the backup.

Note: I reserve the right to change my mind if either Leavitt or Robertson enter the Portal.
 
Last edited:
OrangeBowlMagic said:
When he was named the ACC Rookie of the Year you came on here saying he was terrible?

No. Of course you didn’t.

But, to be fair, he had played a bunch of nobodies. Beck has faced defenses and athletes far better than what he’ll see here on a weekly basis.

The kid is a proven, good player. Is he Cam Ward? No. Guess what? Nobody will be. We need someone who can keep the offense humming efficiently while hopefully improving the defense. Beck would be a home run get. There’s no debate. Especially when you are choosing between options like Mendoza, Emory, etc. Mateer was the one. He went elsewhere. A kid like Carson Beck would be a fine consolation prize.
Click to expand...
I see plenty of debate here by our insiders
 
Advertisement
T$$$ said:
Can someone definitively say that we are or aren’t targeting Beck?

And if we’re not, at this point, who the **** is left?
Click to expand...

I imagine there's likely a board and Beck may be on it. May be several other QBs on it who aren't in the portal as well.
 
Last edited:
JamesQuall said:
You’re right how foolish of all of us. Beck >>>>>> Ward.

I’m sure Beck would’ve thrown 2x what Cam did if he was at WSU. Bobo is the sole reason Beck isn’t the Heisman.

Also if only we had Beck this year, we would’ve been 12-0. ******* bum *** Cam. Can’t even hold Beck’s jockstrap
Click to expand...
I didn’t say any of this chill out (I’m not sure what this kind of post adds to the discussion). Cam is awesome and had an amazing year. All I’m saying is Beck has produced and the 11th qbr in the country against the toughest schedule in the country (yes on a good team) is more than I’d expect out of Emory. For me of the portal qbs (or ones discussed here as potential options) it’d be Mateer> ewers/Beck> Mendoza> Emory.
 
Advertisement
flips said:
Sir, this is CIS. If Mendoza is even just decent at IU and Beck comes here and doesn't lead us to the playoff, I estimate there will be at least 10,000 porsts yelling about how we should have just taken Mendoza.
Click to expand...
Agreed.

This Board was split 60/40 against Mendoza. A year from now it will seem like it was 90/10 in favor of Mendoza with posters saying…“I knew we should have signed Mendoza…What was Mario thinking?”
 
DMoney said:
Who are the better perceived options?

I was labeled a Cuban supremacist for saying Mendoza would be a good addition. Now he went somewhere else and he’s Johnny Unitas.
Click to expand...
Well, I think most people here would take Mendoza over Beck. Definitely over Emory.

But, the vitriol is being directed in our direction because I think most here would’ve been like, ok, Mendoza it is, despite what was said here. Let’s roll into the season,

but somehow, the head man in charge is passing on Mendoza and that decision is being blamed on the people here on CIS that don’t have the power to make decisions.

Are we are supposed to buy “yeah, let’s invest in the 1 arm QB from Georgia” whatever the finances will be and roll with him because we aren’t naming others not in the portal as options.

What the **** was the plan?

Please tell me they didn’t have only Mateer. What if it didn’t fall our way? It sure as **** doesn’t look like there was a plan beside him and if there was, it can’t possibly be that the plan was to pass on Mendoza and try for Beck or Ewers .

What The **** is going on at Hecht?
 
Cribby said:
Bringing in a turnover machine with an arm that needs surgery would be hilarity lol. I’m sorry. Spring ball matters especially in the portal era . We need all the snaps in the world for skill guys . If he had two functioning arms then it wouldn’t be as bad. Give him money and hope he recovers fully. Then hope he plays well which is a crap shoot in itself. Where’s Ben Stiller from Along came Polly. We need some risk management in Coral Gables / CIS.
Click to expand...
It would 100% be indefensible.
 
Back
Top